Who sang "Faithfully" the best?

[sydneysam]

Here are the performances:

 

1. Tony Vincent and Justin Hopkins (Season 2)

 

2. Brooke Simpson (Season 13)

 

3. Toneisha Harris (Season 18)

 

Discuss.

Edited May 19, 2020 by anonymouskid_35

[QueenMae16]

Brooke easily. It was just a slayage like-

[asheryusop]

I don't know why but for some reason, I am more inclined to Toneisha's version. 

[Maxwell]

Brooke snapped in this performance!

[indii]

Meghan, Koryn, and India had the best version back in S8 tbh. But out of these three, probably Brooke

[thecarterfilez]

Brooke won this easily 

[holinessss]

Cirque de Soleil doesn't perform with just anybody, period!!

[rp3598]

Brooke's version was one of my favorite performances of the season

[Rat!]

Brooke, like 1/2 good performances in that round

[iloveadam]

Brooke. And she's not even my favorite. That's why S13 is the best season ever.

 

 

[VintageVoice]

Brooke >> Toneisha >>>>>> the battle version.