Best & Worst Group Of Finalists / Seasons 11-23

[MILO JAY]

Vote & Discuss

Edited May 29, 2023 by MILO JAY

[AliXRose]

Season 13, 17 and 21 are all solid contenders for best.

 

Worst got to be 16, even though Bryce and Brayden would like a word.

[Hamza Tufail]

Best: Season 22. Omar and Morgan both were my snowflakes, and one of my fav contestants of all time.

 

Worst: Season 17. It's not bad, but I wasn't a fan of anyone in the top 4. Nu favorites (Kyndal and Jake Haldenvang) went out early.

[MILO JAY]

yall i voted that season 22 was the worst season, but i forgot about season 16! LOL. 

[Hsamid]

Replace any semifinalist with red Marlow and S13 would have been my choice

 

Otherwise, S21.

 

 

For worst, gotta give it to S23. Sorry but the shorter the season the more bad performances stand out, and there were only 2 live rounds.. sorelle, NOIVAS were downright medsy half the time, and even Gina was underwhelming at points. Grace and D. Smooth really carried the lives imo..

Edited May 29, 2023 by Hsamid

[nytsch]

Best: S17

 

Even though I didn’t like Ricky, it had Katie and Rose which are 2 of my favorite contestants

 

Worst: S22

 

Not necessarily an obvious choice since we got Morgan’s Girl Crush and Omar’s STL… but cmon both Bryce AND Brayden?? At least on S16 Andrew wasn’t bad and Dexter was honestly pretty good

[BrokenHearted]

1. S21

2. S14

3. S18

4. S13

5. S22

6. S23

7. S19

8. S15

9. S17

10. S20

11. S12

12. S16

13. S11 

[nytsch]

2 hours ago, Hamza Tufail said:

Best: Season 22. Omar and Morgan both were my snowflakes, and one of my fav contestants of all time.

 

Worst: Season 17. It's not bad, but I wasn't a fan of anyone in the top 4. Nu favorites (Kyndal and Jake Haldenvang) went out early.

 

Oops ours are the exact opposite lol

[Gustavo527]

Best: Season 21. Epic, iconic finale. Sorry, but i can't pick Season 13 with Red Marlow there. 

 

Worst: Season 19. I think Season 16 and 22 had some of the worst individual finalists. But Season 19's finale was tragic besides Desz, so...

[Misirlou]

My pick for favorite is S10, but you skipped it so I´ll go S17.

 

I think all of the finalists on S19 are talented, but I found the finale to be really boring.

[MILO JAY]

1 hour ago, Misirlou said:

My pick for favorite is S10, but you skipped it so I´ll go S17.

 

I think all of the finalists on S19 are talented, but I found the finale to be really boring.

LOL i started watching season 11, so i didn't wanna make a poll i didn't know every option. I know Alisan and Hannah are FIRE tho

[MILO JAY]

Season 21 was the best imo. Every finalist was FIRE and each could win.

Season 22 & 16 were the worst. Just too many MEH singers (Maelyn, Morgan, and Omar are exceptions tho)

[nytsch]

27 minutes ago, MILO JAY said:

LOL i started watching season 11, so i didn't wanna make a poll i didn't know every option. I know Alisan and Hannah are FIRE tho

 

Laith was really good too

[MILO JAY]

16 minutes ago, nytsch said:

 

Laith was really good too

I will have to watch him!!

[erik g]

I accidentally picked S12 lol but it's S21 with S13 a close second. 

[VintageVoice]

S21 is the only season I can remember where none of the contestants who made the finale got significant pushback, so make of that what you will.

 

I voted for S19 as the “worst” not because anyone who made it was particularly bad, but because it was largely forgettable (which is arguably a worse thing for a reality competition contestant to be).