Rank the 3rd Place Finishers

[Elliott]

Nikki McKibbin
Kimberley Locke
Jasmine Trias
Vonzell Solomon
Elliott Yamin
Melinda Doolittle
Syesha Mercado
Danny Gokey
Casey James
Haley Reinhart
Joshua Ledet
Angie Miller
Alex Preston
JAX
Dalton Rapattoni
Gabby Barrett
Madison VanDenburg
Grace Kintsler
Leah Marlene
Colin Stough

 

(S18 didn't reveal who placed third of the finalists, so feel free to either just rank the other seasons or whomever you think was third.)

[nytsch]

I haven't seen all those seasons, but from what I can judge on I think it would be:

 

1. Haley Reinhart

2. Melinda Doolittle

3. Dalton Rapattoni

 

From the others, Kimberley, Elliott, Madison, and Leah seem like ones I would like but I haven't watched them yet. I did like a few of Elliott's post idol singles though.

[nytsch]

I do know this iconic one from Kimberley

 

 

[D.fstudios]

Gabby is more successful then all the ABC winners

[sublymonal]

1. Melinda Doolittle
2. Elliott Yamin

3. Syesha Mercado

4. Leah Marlene

5. Kimberley Locke

6. Angie Miller

7. Vonzell Solomon

8. Nikki McKibbin

9. Colin Stough

10. Alex Preston

11. Haley Reinhart

12. Joshua Ledet 

13. Grace Kintsler

14. Casey James

15. Madison VanDenburg

16. Dalton Rapattoni

17. JAX
18. Jasmine Trias
19. Danny Gokey

20. Gabby Barrett

[istersay]

Baby V

Mindy doo

Elliot

not ranking, I don't know who some of those are

[Zoey]

01. Vonzell Solomon

02. Gabby Barrett
03. Syesha Mercado
04. Jasmine Trias

05. Kimberley Locke
06. Danny Gokey

07. Nikki McKibbin

08. Colin Stough

09. Madison VanDenburg
10. Casey James
11. Grace Kintsler

12. Haley Reinhart

13. Joshua Ledet
14. Elliott Yamin

15. Dalton Rapattoni

16. Leah Marlene
17. Alex Preston

18. Melinda Doolittle

19. JAX

20. Angie Miller

[Elliott]

1. Elliott Yamin
2. Melinda Doolittle
3. Syesha Mercado
4. Nikki McKibbin
5. Kimberley Locke
6. Angie Miller
7. Leah Marlene
8. Vonzell Solomon
9. Alex Preston
10. Casey James
11. Haley Reinhart
12. Colin Stough
13. Madison VanDenburg
14. Grace Kintsler
15. Joshua Ledet
16. Dalton Rapattoni
17. Jasmine Trias
18. Danny Gokey
19. JAX
20. Gabby Barrett

[FunkyFrankie]

Still like Angie in this group 

[xfactor22]

1. Leah

2. Jax

3. Haley

4. Grace/Angie 

5. Joshua/Madison

6. Alex Preston (yes I didn’t like him during his season but he’s grown on me)

 

Not familiar with the pre-season 10 contestants enough , and while the post-season 10 contestants that I didn’t rank are talented, I don’t care enough to rank them 

Edited May 22, 2023 by xfactor22

[*Wallace]

1. Vonzell Solomon
2. Syesha Mercado
3. Elliott Yamin
4. Melinda Doolittle
5. Haley Reinhart
6. Joshua Ledet
7. Kimberley Locke
8. Grace Kintsler
9. Angie Miller
10. Leah Marlene
11. Gabby Barrett
12. Jasmine Trias
13. Danny Gokey
14. Madison VanDenburg
15. JAX
16. Alex Preston
17. Dalton Rapattoni
18. Casey James
19. Nikki McKibbin
20. Colin Stough

[Persy]

1. Joshua Ledet

2. Melinda Doolittle

3. Grace Kinstler

4. Jax

5. Leah Marlene

6. Angie Miller

7. Vonzell Solomon

8. Haley Reinhart

9. Gabby Barrett

10. Madison VanDenburg

11. Alex Preston

12. Syesha Mercado

13. Kimberley Locke

14. Elliott Yamin

15. Dalton Rapattoni

16. Jasmine Trias

17. Casey James

18. Nikki McKibbin

19. Danny Gokey

20. Colin Stough