Who won the battle: S22 edition

[Hsamid]

Battles seems to be one of the favourite rounds of this season, and there were a few that didn't that didn't have a clear consensus as to who won on here. I think I picked the right ones in that regard..

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Edited November 18, 2022 by Hsamid

[Hamza Tufail]

1. Eric also deserved to win, but I slightly preferred Sydney.

2. Zach, easily.

3. Alyssa(Ian was good as well).

[Someone648]

1. Eric; Very close and Sydney deserved a steal. They should've been paired differently but they did fantastic with what they were given.

2. Zach; I was indifferent about this battle.

3. Alyssa; It was near equal and Alyssa won that for me just by a hair. Ian was very worthy of that steal.

[erik g]

Eric, but sydney deserved a steal

Zach

Alyssa, but it's really close

[Misirlou]

1. Very close, but Eric brought it home for me. Sydney deserved a steal, though, it sucks that they taped the battle once they were gone.

 

2. Didnt care for the battle due to the very strange song choice and arrangement, but Zach easily took it for me. 

 

3. Easily Alyssa 's best IMO, and I hope she eventually returns to that level, but my pick is Ian. The duality of his voice, starting with the lowkey beginning and exploding in the bridge did it for me.

[Hsamid]

Interesting results.

 

Curious why people prefer Eric. I'm guessing Sydney is more of an acquired taste tone wise, Eric's sound is less polarizing?. Either way, both deserved to go through.

 

Zach winning by a Landslide so far I didn't see coming lol. I dont particularly care for the battle but I thought both did pretty good. I thought Andrew sounded beautiful at parts, I just think his runs were misplaced here, which is why I lean towards Zach.

 

Alyssa and Ian is very close. I preffered alyssa in the start and Ian in the bridge. At the end they were pretty even. Ian gets the edge for me just because I think a few of Alyssa's parts were the weakest of the battle.

 

 

[ikwonic]

1. Eric was the right choice, but I would've preferred Sydney to move on

2. Zach.

3. I liked Ian a bit more, but Alyssa sounded fine too.

[QueenCami]

4 hours ago, Someone648 said:

Alyssa; It was near equal and Alyssa won that for me just by a hair.

when i read this at first i thought you were saying it was equal but you picked Alyssa “by her hair” aka that u preferred her hairstyle

[FloorWax]

1. I think I slightly preferred Sydney but this is the closest battle of the three imo so it could have gone either way.

 

2. Zach, I never really cared for Andrew's voice and style.

 

3. Ian's belted part was shocking but overall his vocal was kinda inconsistent. I think Alyssa deserved to win this.

[QueenCami]

1. eric, i thought he gave a more dynamic performance

2. zach, i think andrew’s runs detracted from the performance

3. alyssa, i thought ian sounded mildly strained while alyssa sounded just right. hoping for this kind of song for her in the future

[Misirlou]

I think Cara vs Jay was also a bit divided in terms of who won as well, correct me if I´m wrong. I do remember IDF preferring Zach over Andrew by a long shot.