countrynineteen 8 Posted August 23 Share Posted August 23 Who were the most robbed semi-finalists from each season? Those who you felt should had been in the top 12/13/etc. I'm going to do mine by season Season 1: None Season 2: None Season 3: Lisa Leuschner Season 4: None Season 5: Ayla Brown Season 6: Sabrina Sloan Season 7: Alexandrea Lushington, Alaina Whitaker Season 8: Mishavonna Henson, Ricky Braddy, Felicia Barton Season 9: Lilly Scott, Alex Lambert Season 10: Lauren Turner Season 11: None Season 12: None Season 13: Brandy Neely (Not even getting to sing was BS) Season 14: None Season 15: Jenn Blosil Season 16: None Season 17: Ashley Hess Season 18: None Link to post Share on other sites
Bk1234 2,485 Posted August 23 Share Posted August 23 Kimmy Gabriela from Season 18. Link to post Share on other sites
hayden98 126 Posted August 23 Share Posted August 23 Don't forget Lauren Spencer-Smith from this past year as well 2 Link to post Share on other sites
Bk1234 2,485 Posted August 23 Share Posted August 23 22 minutes ago, hayden98 said: Don't forget Lauren Spencer-Smith from this past year as well I agree with this, but out of curiosity, who would she replace? Link to post Share on other sites
Weedy_Speedy 71 Posted August 23 Share Posted August 23 Season 1: Adriel Herrera, definitely should've advanced over Jim Season 2: Aliceyn Cooney Season 3: Lisa Leuschner Season 4: I think the finalists were rather spot-on this year, the closest thing would be Aloha but her second performance wasn't very good. Season 5: Gedeon McKinney, Patrick Hall to a lesser extent Season 6: Sabrina Sloan. Maybe Sundance to keep him from robbing Billy Gilman in the future. Season 7: Alexandrea Lushington Season 8: Felicia Barton Season 9: Lilly Scott Season 10: Lauren Turner I guess, should've at least been wildcard Season 11: Aaron Marcellus Season 12: David Willis & Vincent Powell Season 13: Half of the people they didn't let sing were probably better than half of the top 13 Season 14: The girl who sang "Safe & Sound", Katherine something Season 15: Stephany Negrete Season 16: None Season 17: Twink Logan Season 18: Still haven't watched Link to post Share on other sites
Bk1234 2,485 Posted August 23 Share Posted August 23 2 minutes ago, The Ghost of Weedy Speedy said: Season 17: Twink Logan I don’t know if I’d say he deserved to go through, but I was sure disappointed to see him leave. 1 Link to post Share on other sites
Carrie_On 31 Posted August 23 Share Posted August 23 (edited) Angela Peele (S1) Adriel Herrera (S1) Kelly Glover (S1) Lisa Leuschner (S3) Ayla Brown (S5) Sabrina Sloan (S6) Alaina Whitaker (S7) Ricky Braddy (S8) Kristen McNamara (S8) Felicia Barton (S8) Jesse Langseth (S8) Lily Scott (S9) Alex Lambert (S9) Katelyn Epperly (S9) Kendra Chantelle (S10) Lauren Turner (S10) Isabelle Pascalone (S12) Kenz Hall (S13) Maurice Townsend (S13) Jillian Jensen (S13) Katherine Winston (S14) Effie Passero (S16) Shannon O’ Hara (S16) Lauren Spencer-Smith (S18) Edited August 23 by Carrie_On Link to post Share on other sites
Bk1234 2,485 Posted August 23 Share Posted August 23 To add to the Season 10 list, I will say Kendra Chantelle and Robbie Rosen. Link to post Share on other sites
Elliott 3,553 Posted August 23 Share Posted August 23 The fact that nobody's mentioned Suzy Vulaca... 1 Link to post Share on other sites
countrynineteen 8 Posted August 23 Author Share Posted August 23 16 minutes ago, Carrie_On said: Angela Peele (S1) Adriel Herrera (S1) Kelly Glover (S1) Lisa Leuschner (S3) Ayla Brown (S5) Sabrina Sloan (S6) Alaina Whitaker (S7) Ricky Braddy (S8) Kristen McNamara (S8) Felicia Barton (S8) Jesse Langseth (S8) Lily Scott (S9) Alex Lambert (S9) Katelyn Epperly (S9) Kendra Chantelle (S10) Lauren Turner (S10) Isabelle Pascalone (S12) Kenz Hall (S13) Maurice Townsend (S13) Jillian Jensen (S13) Katherine Winston (S14) Effie Passero (S16) Shannon O’ Hara (S16) Lauren Spencer-Smith (S18) Oh yeah, I forgot about Effie. She was definitely robbed also. And Lauren from this year was good. Link to post Share on other sites
psterina 258 Posted August 25 Share Posted August 25 S8 - Felicia Barton S9 - Lily Scott, Katelyn Epperly, Alex Lambert S11 - Jenn Hirsch S15 - Stephany Negrete S17 - Ashley Hess Link to post Share on other sites
hayden98 126 Posted August 25 Share Posted August 25 On 8/23/2020 at 2:48 PM, Bk1234 said: I agree with this, but out of curiosity, who would she replace? I'd probably have swapped Lauren for either Jovin, Louis, or Julia (didn't like her top 20 performance at all lol). It's kinda tough though, because I feel like all three of those guys got better the following week. 1 Link to post Share on other sites
Blirel 247 Posted August 25 Share Posted August 25 (edited) I started in Season 10 so here's my opinion. 10: Kendra Chantelle (She was top 10 material but not much more. She still deserved to make it) 11: Jen Hirsch (Same as above) 12: Nick Boddington & Breanna Steer (Especially Nick as he was stronger than every male that season except Burnell) 13: Kenz Hall & Brandy Neely (Kenz had this cool style that was a bit too creative for the time, and Brandy was a seasoned country singer) 14: Katherine Winston (Love her style. Always love 70s inspired singers) 15: no one was completely robbed but I always thought Emily brooke had potential. 16: Shannon O'hara- Yes she wasn't flawless but I enjoyed her enough. 17: Ashley Hess- most robbed of all time. No arguments here. Ashley was top 5 material. 18: Lauren Spencer Edited August 25 by Blirel Link to post Share on other sites
Blirel 247 Posted August 25 Share Posted August 25 4 minutes ago, hayden98 said: I'd probably have swapped Lauren for either Jovin, Louis, or Julia (didn't like her top 20 performance at all lol). It's kinda tough though, because I feel like all three of those guys got better the following week. You realize it's most robbed semifinalist? The 3 you mentioned were all finalists Link to post Share on other sites
hayden98 126 Posted August 25 Share Posted August 25 1 minute ago, Blirel said: You realize it's most robbed semifinalist? The 3 you mentioned were all finalists I was being asked who I'd have advanced Lauren to the finals over though? Link to post Share on other sites
psterina 258 Posted August 25 Share Posted August 25 17 minutes ago, Blirel said: I started in Season 10 so here's my opinion. 10: Kendra Chantelle (She was top 10 material but not much more. She still deserved to make it) 11: Jen Hirsch (Same as above) 12: Nick Boddington & Breanna Steer (Especially Nick as he was stronger than every male that season except Burnell) 13: Kenz Hall & Brandy Neely (Kenz had this cool style that was a bit too creative for the time, and Brandy was a seasoned country singer) 14: Katherine Winston (Love her style. Always love 70s inspired singers) 15: no one was completely robbed but I always thought Emily brooke had potential. 16: Shannon O'hara- Yes she wasn't flawless but I enjoyed her enough. 17: Ashley Hess- most robbed of all time. No arguments here. Ashley was top 5 material. 18: Lauren Spencer Totally agree 1000% Ashley Hess, was THE most robbed semi-finalists ever! Link to post Share on other sites
Blirel 247 Posted August 25 Share Posted August 25 1 hour ago, hayden98 said: I was being asked who I'd have advanced Lauren to the finals over though? Oh I’m sorry. Don’t mind me. I was just confused. Link to post Share on other sites
Bk1234 2,485 Posted August 25 Share Posted August 25 2 hours ago, hayden98 said: I'd probably have swapped Lauren for either Jovin, Louis, or Julia (didn't like her top 20 performance at all lol). It's kinda tough though, because I feel like all three of those guys got better the following week. That’s true. Especially Julia with New York State of Mind! 1 Link to post Share on other sites
hayden98 126 Posted August 25 Share Posted August 25 2 hours ago, Blirel said: Oh I’m sorry. Don’t mind me. I was just confused. Nah, you're good Link to post Share on other sites
Drew 117 Posted August 26 Share Posted August 26 On 8/23/2020 at 4:06 PM, Bk1234 said: To add to the Season 10 list, I will say Kendra Chantelle and Robbie Rosen. I agree with these two for sure. 1 Link to post Share on other sites
anticoronaperson 40 Posted September 8 Share Posted September 8 (edited) Chris Daughtry and Jennifer Hudson. I know they are not semi-finalists, but they were finalists and I feel they were robbed. Edited September 8 by anticoronaperson Link to post Share on other sites
Walker359718 33 Posted September 8 Share Posted September 8 (edited) On 8/23/2020 at 4:06 PM, Bk1234 said: To add to the Season 10 list, I will say Kendra Chantelle and Robbie Rosen. I can't agree more. But next season will be 10 years since Season 10. Where did the time go? Edited September 8 by Walker359718 Link to post Share on other sites
Bk1234 2,485 Posted September 13 Share Posted September 13 On 9/8/2020 at 3:02 PM, anticoronaperson said: Chris Daughtry and Jennifer Hudson. I know they are not semi-finalists, but they were finalists and I feel they were robbed. I agree with Jennifer Hudson completely, and Chris Daughtry to a lesser extent. Don’t forget about Queen Pia though. Link to post Share on other sites
anticoronaperson 40 Posted September 13 Share Posted September 13 (edited) @Bk1234 I agree with Jennifer Hudson completely, and Chris Daughtry to a lesser extent. Don’t forget about Queen Pia though. Oh yeah. I remember Pia Toscano. I don't know if she would have won her Season, but she was definitely robbed and probably should have made at least Top 5. In comparison to Taylor Hicks is why I felt Chris Daughtry was robbed in my opinion. Also, Adam Lambert, but to a lesser extent because I actually like Kris Allen and thought he was talented. Edited September 13 by anticoronaperson 1 Link to post Share on other sites
anticoronaperson 40 Posted September 13 Share Posted September 13 There was one contestant though that didn't make the semi finals that I thought was robbed and that's Tori Kelly. But she went on to be successful without advancing to the semifinals. Link to post Share on other sites
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now