Jump to content
idolforums.com
Sign in to follow this  
holinessss

Rank the Top 40 Performances - Night 1!

Final Judgement - Night 1!  

28 members have voted

  1. 1. Best Performance by a Guy?

    • Devon Alexander - Tell Me You Love Me (Demi Lovato)
      1
    • DeWayne Crocker Jr. - Old Town Road (Lil Nas X)
      3
    • Dillon James - The Times They Are A-Changin' (Bob Dylan)
      4
    • Francisco Martin - Falling (Harry Styles)
      12
    • Jonny West - You Found Me (The Fray)
      6
    • Jordan Jones - Redbone (Childish Gambino)
      1
    • Jovin Webb - You Are The Best Thing (Ray Lamontagne)
      1
    • Louis Knight - Castle On The Hill (Ed Sheeran)
      0
    • Nick Merico - When I Was Your Man (Bruno Mars)
      0
  2. 2. Best Performance by a Girl?

    • Amber Fiedler - Good Kisser (Lake Street Dive)
      1
    • Camryn Leigh Smith - Break Every Chain (Tasha Cobbs)
      0
    • Faith Becnel - Ain't Nobody (Chaka Khan)
      2
    • Geena - Finesse (Bruno Mars)
      0
    • Just Sam - Como La Flor (Selena Y Los Dinos)
      24
    • Makayla Brownlee - More Hearts Than Mine (Ingrid Andress)
      1
  3. 3. Grade the Episode!

    • A
      2
    • B
      17
    • C
      6
    • D
      2
    • F
      1


Recommended Posts

Devon Alexander - Tell Me You Love Me (Demi Lovato)
DeWayne Crocker Jr. - Old Town Road (Lil Nas X)
Dillon James - The Times They Are A-Changin' (Bob Dylan)

Francisco Martin - Falling (Harry Styles)
Jonny West - You Found Me (The Fray)
Jordan Jones - Redbone (Childish Gambino)
Jovin Webb - You Are The Best Thing (Ray Lamontagne)

Louis Knight - Castle On The Hill (Ed Sheeran)
Nick Merico - When I Was Your Man (Bruno Mars)

 

Amber Fiedler - Good Kisser (Lake Street Dive)
Camryn Leigh Smith - Break Every Chain (Tasha Cobbs)

Faith Becnel - Ain't Nobody (Chaka Khan)
Geena - Finesse (Bruno Mars)
Just Sam - Como La Flor (Selena Y Los Dinos)

Makayla Brownlee - More Hearts Than Mine (Ingrid Andress)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Francisco Martin - Falling (Harry Styles)
Just Sam - Como La Flor (Selena Y Los Dinos)

Dillon James - The Times They Are A-Changin' (Bob Dylan)

Jonny West - You Found Me (The Fray)


DeWayne Crocker Jr. - Old Town Road (Lil Nas X)

Amber Fiedler - Good Kisser (Lake Street Dive)

Jovin Webb - You Are The Best Thing (Ray Lamontagne)
Geena - Finesse (Bruno Mars)

Louis Knight - Castle On The Hill (Ed Sheeran)

Camryn Leigh Smith - Break Every Chain (Tasha Cobbs)

 

Jordan Jones - Redbone (Childish Gambino)
Devon Alexander - Tell Me You Love Me (Demi Lovato)

Nick Merico - When I Was Your Man (Bruno Mars)

Faith Becnel - Ain't Nobody (Chaka Khan)
Makayla Brownlee - More Hearts Than Mine (Ingrid Andress)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)

1. Just Sam - Como La Flor (Selena Y Los Dinos)

2. DeWayne Crocker Jr. - Old Town Road (Lil Nas X)

3. Jovin Webb - You Are The Best Thing (Ray Lamontagne)

4. Amber Fiedler - Good Kisser (Lake Street Dive)

5. Devon Alexander - Tell Me You Love Me (Demi Lovato)

6. Jonny West - You Found Me (The Fray)

7. Dillon James - The Times They Are A-Changin' (Bob Dylan)

8. Francisco Martin - Falling (Harry Styles)

9. Jordan Jones - Redbone (Childish Gambino)

10. Nick Merico - When I Was Your Man (Bruno Mars)

11. Faith Becnel - Ain't Nobody (Chaka Khan)

12. Camryn Leigh Smith - Break Every Chain (Tasha Cobbs)

13. Makayla Brownlee - More Hearts Than Mine (Ingrid Andress)

14. Geena - Finesse (Bruno Mars)

15. Louis Knight - Castle On The Hill (Ed Sheeran)

Edited by taylorkat

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)

1) Samantha Diaz

2) Francisco Martin.....

 

 

 

 

Honestly....everyone else is interchangeable ....i'll have to think about it....

Edited by kenboy123

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
6 minutes ago, holinessss said:

the two who voted for faith, show yourselves! 🍵

 

Probably Faith herself...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)

Top Top

Sam Diaz    

Francisco Martin

 

Top

Jovin Webb (although I think his song choice showed his limited vocal range),

Jonny West (but I think he won’t make the cut to top 10 in favor of Louis. I think Louie may already be tco for vulnerable good-looking hurt singer-songwriter boy)

 

What to Say

Amber Fiedler Amber’s got a great voice, but that was not good 

 

Bottom

Nick Merico

Camryn Leigh Smith

 

 

Edited by tshe.ring
correction

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

(Hey all! I'm from The Voice's side of the forum, but I'm way more into American Idol this season... 😏)

 

PHENOMENAL (5/5)

  1. Just Sam - Como La Flor (Selena Y Los Dinos)
  2. Francisco Martin - Falling (Harry Styles)
  3. Jovin Webb - You Are The Best Thing (Ray Lamontagne)
  4. Dillon James - The Times They Are A-Changin' (Bob Dylan)

REALLY GOOD (4/5)

  1. (X) Jordan Jones - Redbone (Childish Gambino)
  2. Jonny West - You Found Me (The Fray)

PRETTY GOOD (3/5)

  1. (X) Geena - Finesse (Bruno Mars)
  2. DeWayne Crocker Jr. - Old Town Road (Lil Nas X)
  3. (X) Amber Fiedler - Good Kisser (Lake Street Dive)
  4. Faith Becnel - Ain't Nobody (Chaka Khan)

NOT MY FAVORITES (2/5)

  1. (X) Makayla Brownlee - More Hearts Than Mine (Ingrid Andress)
  2. (X) Devon Alexander - Tell Me You Love Me (Demi Lovato)
  3. (X) Camryn Leigh Smith - Break Every Chain (Tasha Cobbs)
  4. Louis Knight - Castle On The Hill (Ed Sheeran)

ABSOLUTE LEAST FAVORITE (1/5)

  1. Nick Merico - When I Was Your Man (Bruno Mars)

 

 

 


 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
30 minutes ago, Bouli said:

(Hey all! I'm from The Voice's side of the forum, but I'm way more into American Idol this season... 😏)

 

PHENOMENAL (5/5)

  1. Just Sam - Como La Flor (Selena Y Los Dinos)
  2. Francisco Martin - Falling (Harry Styles)
  3. Jovin Webb - You Are The Best Thing (Ray Lamontagne)
  4. Dillon James - The Times They Are A-Changin' (Bob Dylan)

REALLY GOOD (4/5)

  1. (X) Jordan Jones - Redbone (Childish Gambino)
  2. Jonny West - You Found Me (The Fray)

PRETTY GOOD (3/5)

  1. (X) Geena - Finesse (Bruno Mars)
  2. DeWayne Crocker Jr. - Old Town Road (Lil Nas X)
  3. (X) Amber Fiedler - Good Kisser (Lake Street Dive)
  4. Faith Becnel - Ain't Nobody (Chaka Khan)

NOT MY FAVORITES (2/5)

  1. (X) Makayla Brownlee - More Hearts Than Mine (Ingrid Andress)
  2. (X) Devon Alexander - Tell Me You Love Me (Demi Lovato)
  3. (X) Camryn Leigh Smith - Break Every Chain (Tasha Cobbs)
  4. Louis Knight - Castle On The Hill (Ed Sheeran)

ABSOLUTE LEAST FAVORITE (1/5)

  1. Nick Merico - When I Was Your Man (Bruno Mars)

 

 

 


 

 

Would you say that the talent on American Idol Season 18 is better than the Voice Season 18???

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
37 minutes ago, kenboy123 said:

 

Would you say that the talent on American Idol Season 18 is better than the Voice Season 18???

yes

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Wow!

Francisco Martin - Falling (Harry Styles)
Just Sam - Como La Flor (Selena Y Los Dinos)

 

Good

Amber Fiedler - Good Kisser (Lake Street Dive)
DeWayne Crocker Jr. - Old Town Road (Lil Nas X)

Jonny West - You Found Me (The Fray)

Jovin Webb - You Are The Best Thing (Ray Lamontagne)
Geena - Finesse (Bruno Mars)

 

Mixed Feelings/Neutral

Dillon James - The Times They Are A-Changin' (Bob Dylan)

Faith Becnel - Ain't Nobody (Chaka Khan)

 

Meh

Louis Knight - Castle On The Hill (Ed Sheeran)

Camryn Leigh Smith - Break Every Chain (Tasha Cobbs)

Jordan Jones - Redbone (Childish Gambino)
Devon Alexander - Tell Me You Love Me (Demi Lovato)

Nick Merico - When I Was Your Man (Bruno Mars)

 

Just no...

Jordan Jones - Redbone (Childish Gambino)
Makayla Brownlee - More Hearts Than Mine (Ingrid Andress)

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Are they saving all the good people for the 2nd episode? Or does everyone suck this season? :/

 

Geena and Amber were the only good ones and they went home. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Raphy said:

Are they saving all the good people for the 2nd episode? Or does everyone suck this season? :/

 

Geena and Amber were the only good ones and they went home. 

if you like the big/diva singers, next episode is it

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
45 minutes ago, holinessss said:

if you like the big/diva singers, next episode is it

Not usually. I like unique voices, even if they don’t have much range. Everyone is just mediocre this year. I remember seeing better people in Hollywood tho, this was just a terrible episode.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1. Just Sam

2. Jonny West

3. Dillon James

4. DeWayne Crocker Jr.

5. Francisco Martin

6. Geena

7. Jordan Jones

8. Louie Knight

9. Amber Fielder

10. Jovin Webb

11. Faith Becnel

12. Devon Alexander

13. Nick Merico

14. Makayla Brownlee

15. Camryn Leigh-Smith

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted (edited)
10 hours ago, Raphy said:

Not usually. I like unique voices, even if they don’t have much range. Everyone is just mediocre this year. I remember seeing better people in Hollywood tho, this was just a terrible episode.


I thought that Just Sam was great.

Edited by CarmenSandiego
  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
40 minutes ago, CarmenSandiego said:


I thought that Just Sam was great.

 

Yes. Sam, was the stand out performance.  Dewayne, was also excellent.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Francisco and Sam killed everyone else #slay

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Game changing/stand alone performances:

1. Just Sam 

2. Jovin Webb

3. Dillon James 

Top 10/Well enough peformances

1. Johnny West

2. Louis Knight 

3. Nick Merrico 

4. Dewayne 

5. Fransico 

Forgettable performances: 

1. Cameryon

2. Faith

3. Jordan 

4. Devon

Deserved to be cut:

1. Mackayla Brownlee 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1. Francisco

2. Just Sam

—gap

3. Louis

4. Nick

5. Makayla

6. Amber

7. Dillon
8. Geena

9. Dewayne

10. Devon

11. Jordan

12. Jonny

13. Camryn

14. Faith

15. Jovin

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Here’s how I ranked the singers after watching them perform three times:

 

1.  Just Sam — a sympathetic backstory + a Selena song + a transformative performance = a spot in the Top 20 and her being my favorite singer.
2.  Francisco — his best and most confident performance yet!  I wonder what caused him to become so insecure in the first place.
3.  Jonny — he got to shine on his own once his girlfriend was cut.
4.  DeWayne — putting a reggae spin on this song was a risk, but the risk paid off with a spot in the Top 20.
5.  Jovin — his vocals may not have been great this time, but he is a definite artist with a unique sound among the men.
6.  Dillon — he had better vocals but could have emoted more in this particular song.
7.  Louis — he is falling while Francisco is rising.  He needs to get out of his head if he wants to move on to the Top 10.  But he was good enough for the Top 20.
8.  Faith — she’s certainly an experienced performer but she’s the weakest singer among the girls who made it in this segment.
9.  Jordan — the only one who was cut in this segment that was probably good enough to move on, but Nick had the heartthrob factor going for him.
10.  Nick — he was good but not great.
11.  Geena — she was certainly enjoyable but she failed to do enough with the song to move on.
12.  Devon — he was good but rather forgettable.
13.  Amber — she was a little too screechy, and that cost her.
14.  Makayla Brownlee — sometimes drastically changing the arrangement of a particular song works, sometimes it doesn’t.  It didn’t work here.
15.  Camryn — you needed to take a risk (albeit a reasonable one) when you made it to the Top 40.  You played it safe.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

×
×
  • Create New...