Had to omit Makenzie's IS, not enough options and I realized I didn't have break every chain on there so it's the last option. So if don't vote if that was your pick.
I've always wondered who IDF preferred at the time and who would IDF prefer now. Both very different approaches, but the 2 main powerhouse of the season eliminated in the SF.
Who was better?
Compilation of all their performances (no timestamps though)
The duet (also in the compilations)
If you're too lazy to go through a comp with no timestamps..
Kymberli Joye (in order)
Makenzie Thomas
I agree. This position is expected to have big names in music who has like 10+ years of experience. Back to 7 years ago people were furious that Miley was announced as a coach but they kept forgetting that Miley herself already had 10 years in the industry at the age of 24.
I remember Ellie Lawrence were salty that she had Selena Gomez as a Battle round mentor, and the Gwen season after that they had Celine Dion.
I think what they really care is ratings and also believe that sometimes those "low profile" celebrities' team has approached NBC for a possible spot, and TPTB can happily make a deal out of it. The celebrity can get a career revival (as Adam and Xtina experienced), and the show can cut budgets.