If you'd have to Pick 5 from the list of runner ups and winnes, who would you choose?

[Hamza Tufail]

I was going to make a few polls about the placements for some runner ups and some winners as well. But then I thought, why not combine all of them in one poll, instead of making multiple new polls?

 

If some of your favs aren't present above, you can just pick those who are in your top 5, and then mention the other one(s) who is/are not present above, in your post below.

 

Discuss.

Edited December 31, 2023 by Hamza Tufail

[Stacey.]

HOW DID YOU MISS OUT BRYCE 

[Stacey.]

1. Bryce Leatherwood

2. Emily Ann Roberts

3. Gina Miles

4. Cassadee Pope

5. Addison Agen

 

Danielle Bradbery would be closely following too.

[Hamza Tufail]

24 minutes ago, Stacey. said:

HOW DID YOU MISS OUT BRYCE 

Read the first post. I could only do 15 from both. That's why I had to left 8 of those contestants that aren't popular here. But like I said in my first post, if your fav isn't in the poll, only pick the ones that would be in your top 5, and mention that left over contestant in your post.

[MILO JAY]

39 minutes ago, Stacey. said:

HOW DID YOU MISS OUT BRYCE 

he is so forgettable lol

[AliXRose]

Runner-ups

1. Wendy
2. Grace
3. Ricky
4. bodie
5. Addison

Winners

1. Maelyn
2. Tessanne
3. Chloe
4. Alisan
5. Gina

[FloorWax]

1. Addison

2. Jacquie

3. Lauren

4. Matt

5. uhh… bodie maybe?

 

I really need to listen to Juliet lol she’s the only one on that list I’m unfamiliar with.

[Misirlou]

Runners Up (In chronological order)

1. Juliet Simms

2. Adam Wakefield

3. Ricky Duran 

4. Wendy Moten

5. bodie

 

Winners (In chronological order)

1. Josh Kaufman

2. Sawyer Fredericks

3. Chloe MK

4. Chevel Shepherd

5. Girl Named Tom

[Hamza Tufail]

9 minutes ago, FloorWax said:

1. Addison

2. Jacquie

3. Lauren

4. Matt

5. uhh… bodie maybe?

 

I really need to listen to Juliet lol she’s the only one on that list I’m unfamiliar with.

You're considering only first 16 seasons, right?

[nytsch]

Not sure I understand the question, do you mean top 5 total out of both groups or top 5 for each one?

 

I’ll answer the first question since it’s more fun lol

 

1. Alisan

2. Juliet

3. Addison

4. Jacquie

5. Sawyer

[Hamza Tufail]

4 minutes ago, nytsch said:

Not sure I understand the question, do you mean top 5 total out of both groups or top 5 for each one?

 

I’ll answer the first question since it’s more fun lol

 

1. Alisan

2. Juliet

3. Addison

4. Jacquie

5. Sawyer

It's separate for both, like AlixRose and Misirlou have done.

 

But you can do whatever you want. Lol

[nytsch]

Damn the winners list is really hard

 

Alisan

Sawyer

GNT

Josh

Chevel

Cam

Tessanne

 

Not sure how to narrow it down after this lol
 

Jordan and Maelyn are really good too but I just liked the others more.

 

Possibly even Cassadee or Craig in the mix?

Edited June 6, 2023 by nytsch

[FloorWax]

34 minutes ago, Hamza Tufail said:

You're considering only first 16 seasons, right?

 

I only did runner ups (and counted all seasons) because those don’t count as spoilers for my ranking.

Edited June 6, 2023 by FloorWax

[Hamza Tufail]

21 minutes ago, FloorWax said:

 

I only did runner ups (and counted all seasons) because those don’t count as spoilers for my ranking.

Either way, glad to see Matt in the top 5.

[Misirlou]

Also, by reading through this list, I think overall I like more runner ups than winners 

[Hamza Tufail]

Runner ups:

 

Juliet Simms

Matt McAndrew

Adam Wakefield 

Billy Gilman

Hard to choose between Wendy, Bodie, and Grace.

 

Winners:

Other than my obvious two favs, from the above list the contestants that would make my top 5 are: Sawyer, Cam, and Chris B.

Edited June 7, 2023 by Hamza Tufail

[StarWalker1]

Winners: Alisan, Tessanne, Maelyn, GNT, Gina

 

Runner-Ups: Wendy, Michelle, Lauren, Juliet, Jacquie

[Dalton Eduardo]

Runners Up

1. Lauren Duski

2. Addison Agen

3. Wendy Moten

4. Ricky Duran

5. bodie

 

Winners

1. Chloe Kohanski

2. Danielle Bradbery

3. Cassadee Pope

4. Cam Anthony

5. Maelyn Jarmon

 

 - Sundance Head is one of the most underrated winners here and I'm kinda sad he's not on the poll, maybe because he won and saved one of the worst seasons ever. 

[Hamza Tufail]

2 hours ago, Dalton Eduardo said:

Runners Up

1. Lauren Duski

2. Addison Agen

3. Wendy Moten

4. Ricky Duran

5. bodie

 

Winners

1. Chloe Kohanski

2. Danielle Bradbery

3. Cassadee Pope

4. Cam Anthony

5. Maelyn Jarmon

 

 - Sundance Head is one of the most underrated winners here and I'm kinda sad he's not on the poll, maybe because he won and saved one of the worst seasons ever. 

Poll has a limit of 15. Hence why I couldn't add him. 

 

But as I Mentioned above, if one of your fav isn't on the poll, just select 4 on the poll, and then mention that remaining contestant in your post.

 

Where would you have put him in your list?

[Dalton Eduardo]

1 hour ago, Hamza Tufail said:

Poll has a limit of 15. Hence why I couldn't add him. 

 

But as I Mentioned above, if one of your fav isn't on the poll, just select 4 on the poll, and then mention that remaining contestant in your post.

 

Where would you have put him in your list?

 

I know, because he's so unpopular here that's why he will surely be among those who cannot be included in the poll. But it's okay. 

 

I would have placed him 3rd behind Chloe and Danielle. I might have to drop Maelyn though if it's strictly Top 5. 

Edited June 8, 2023 by Dalton Eduardo

[Hsamid]

Runner ups

Wendy Moten

Grace West

Matt Mcandrew

Adam Wakefield

Juliet Simms

 

Winners

Tessanee Chin

Jordan Smith

Maelyn

Chris

Chloe MK

 

Runner ups was easy for me, but winners was a bit harder. Had to leave out Chevel, Alisan and GNT