S23 Premiere: Polls

[Misirlou]

Choose.

Edited March 7, 2023 by Misirlou

[FloorWax]

1. My man Salsich did not disappoint.

 

2. Wanted to say D, but I'll be generous and give it a C.

 

3. Chance

[StarWalker1]

1. Voted Holly, but also really liked NOIVAS and Tasha

 

2. I'd say a B

 

3. Chance

[Cookie73]

1. NOIVAS

2. Neil Salsich

3. Holly Brand

4. Tasha Jessen

5. Alex Whalen

6. Ross Clayton

7. D. Smooth

8. Michael B.

9. Sorelle

Good night. There were some that didn’t live up to expectations, but NOIVAS was excellent and Neil, Holly and Tasha were also very good. The ones in the middle weren’t really that bad either

Chance is more promising so far

 

 

[Teraginn]

WHY THAT SONG

9. D. Smooth

 

Y'all cool.... but I need to hear more

8. Sorelle

7. Alex Whalen

6. Tasha Jessen

 

Solid AF

5. Holly Brand

4. NOIVAS

 

They're hot AND can sing?

3. Michael B.

2. Ross Clayton

 

GOLDEN SNOWFLAKE™ ALERT!

1. Neil Salsich - I enjoyed this so much, I didn't expect him to show off as much of his range as he did here! I'm glad he got casted for this season because he's absolutely in my wheelhouse and I don't know how I would've discovered him otherwise.

[TeamAudra]

I voted for Neil in this one. 

[Dai]

I hate to be that guy but what a lackluster premiere.
 

Good job

1. Tasha

2. Holly

 

Ehhhhhh

3-6. NOIVAS, Neil, Alex and Sorelle.

 

Zzzzzz

7. Ross

8. D. Smooth

9. Michael

 

This is probably the most stereotypical IDF ranking ever 

[Misirlou]

1 hour ago, Daillon said:

This is probably the most stereotypical IDF ranking ever 

Nah, a stereotypical IDFer would have Alex, Neil and Ross fighting for the bottom.

[Cookie73]

If I had to grade the teams so far, based on my ranking

 

1. Blake

2. Chance
3. Kelly

 

4. Niall

[erik g]

Loved it

1. NOIVAS

 

Great

2. D Smooth (overhated imo)

3. Michael B (underrated)

4. Holly

 

Really good

5. Ross

6. Tasha

 

Good

7. Neil

8. Sorelle

9. Alex 

 

 

[Misirlou]

The premiere was nothing otherworldy, but I probably enjoyed it more than most. B for me.

 

My horse of the season

1. Neil

 

Great job

2. NOIVAS

3. Alex

 

Very good, but I felt a certain timidness from both, they gotta let loose.

4. Tasha

5. Holly

 

Interesting, it was a bit of a mess but I´m intrigued. Props for song choice.

6. Sorelle

 

Good voice, but I felt the performance was missing grit, it felt a bit too plain.

7. Ross

 

They can sing, but I was honestly let down by the performances themselves, I expected way more from both.

8. Michael

9. D.Smooth

 

 

[Gustavo527]

The last two seasons taught me to not set my expectations very high for a premiere, which resulted in me enjoying it more than usual this time. I'll give it a B. 

 

1. Holly 

2. NOIVAS' 

3. Tasha 

4. Neil 

5. Alex 

6. Ross 

7. Sorelle 

8. Michael 

9. D. Smooth

[Anybody354]

Favorite: NOIVAS

Grade: B-; not bad but I more so respect than like a lot of these artists

Preferred New Coach: Not sure yet but I voted for Niall lol.