Comeback Stage S20 [Round 1]

[Noah57678]

I’ll be updating this with each round of the pre-lives (like the S16 format)
 

Which 6 of the 11 no-chair turners would you choose for the comeback stage if it was in season 20? 
 

Madison Curbelo - “Don’t Worry, Be Happy”

Madison Marigold - “If the World Was Ending”

Yellsmiles - “Midnight Sky”

James Tutson - “Beyond”

Jesse Desorcy - “Dust on the Bottle”

Kaitlyn Myers - “If You Really Love Me”

Almond&Olive - “Wildflowers”

Tyler Kohrs - “More Hearts Than Mine”

Nadianicole - “I Wanna Be Down”

Charlotte Boyer - “Love Is a Losing Game”

Connor Snow - “This City” 

 

*Disclaimer: I didn’t really like the comeback stage and I’d rather these artists just come back and turn a chair so it’s a good thing this is hypothetical*

Edited March 30, 2021 by Noah57678

[FloorWax]

I'd rather get the battle eliminations as Comeback Stage contestants.

[Noah57678]

1 minute ago, FloorWax said:

I'd rather get the battle eliminations as Comeback Stage contestants.

I liked that addition in S16 but even in that season they still had 6 from the BA so I figured I’d start there. 

[Noah57678]

Based on artistry and potential for improvement:

 

Madison Marigold

James Tutson

Kaitlyn Myers

Almond&Olive

Tyler Kohrs

Charlotte Boyer

 

Kaitlyn vs Charlotte

Madison vs James

Almond&Olive vs Tyler Kohrs (could go either way) 

[FloorWax]

I liked Madison Curbelo the best out of the no chairs

[thevoiceisthetop]

Madison c

madison m

charlotte 

Connor

tyler 

james

[jarmon]

Madison Curbelo

Madison Marigold

Nadianicole

Conner Snow

Tyler Kohrs

Kaitlyn Myers

 

Conner Snow vs. Tyler Kohrs

Madison Curbelo vs. Nadianicole

Kaitlyn Myers vs. Madison Marigold 

[QueenCami]

i'd want madison c. or nadianicole. madison c had a really pretty tone and nadianicole is obviously a super powerful singer but she was pitchy one time

[Sid Dean]

Madison Marigold

Conner Snow

Tyler Kohrs

Kaitlyn Myers

Jesse Desorcy

Madison Curbello

 

Madison Marigold Vs Jesse Desorcy

Conner Snow Vs Tyler Kohrs

Kaitlyn Myers Vs Madison Curbello

[AliXRose]

I think the most deserving one would've been Kaitlyn Myers, Madison Curbelo could've done some damage on team Gwen.

 

However, it's still a spoiler right now but there's one battle eliminee that would've crushed this thing and won the additional spot in the lives, so I'm really sad

[Feder]

I dont care about BA 

but the 3 people i would have selected from the Battles round would have been:

 

Bradley Sinclair

Lindsay Joan 

Aaron Konzelman 

 

with the 2 semifinalist being Bradley and Lindsay 

 

and probably Lindsay making the final vs KO comeback but I am not sure, I think Bradley’s Battle elimination was more shocking

Edited April 16, 2021 by Feder