The Voice S17 Poll: Worst Elimination So Far, Best Save/Steal, Worst Save/Steal

[dirActing]

From battles to playoffs, including the wildcard. (sorry, no blinds). Discuss, rant, commiserate, celebrate, etc.. Get all that out of your system before we move on to the live competition proper.

[rp3598]

Undeserved eliminations:

Injoy and pretty much everyone in the playoffs

 

Most Deserved Saves:

Lauren, Max, Joana, Myracle

 

Most Undeserved Saves:

Shane

[xfactor22]

Undeserving elimination

Zoe Upkins (should’ve been stolen)-great improvements

HM goes to Dane & Stephanie due to their uniqueness and good voices and same for Mendeleyev for his unique tone and possibility of actually winning. Also Injoy for being a vocal beast and still being eliminated

 

 

Deserving savE/steal

Will Breman-gotta rep my #1 snowflake

HM goes to Myracle- she’s good and her save was totally deserved

 

Undeserving save /steal

Shane Q-even Hello Sunday manages to show more emotion than he does.

Edited November 17, 2019 by xfactor22

[ATX29]

I almost have to give Kelly a pass for saving Shane bc she really had 0 good options at that point. The most undeserving save was Cali simply bc there was a much better choice for Blake

 

The most robbed was obviously Gracee.

[ShadowGuy1]

Undeserved Elimination: Marina - Ik most people here are gonna say Kyndal, but Marina was eliminated for probably her best performance while Kyndal had one of her worsts. Plus, Marina could of been safe, but sadly she had a later taping.

 

Most Deserved Save/Steal- Joana Martinez/Max Boyle (voted Joana on the poll) - Both (imo) won there knockouts and both had some of he best knockouts this season (and both are also in my top 3 of the season)

 

Worst Save/Steal - Zoe Upkins - I didn't really like Zoe in the battle or in the blinds. Felt Khalea was much better. And Zoe being John's save here made him unable to save people like Matt New/Mendeleyev (both who I preferred much more to Zoe)

[QueenMae16]

Undeserved Elimination: Marina/Kyndal/Injoy/Steve.

 

Most Deserved Save/Steal: Joana/Max, HM to Lauren.

 

Worse Save/Steal: Will/Shane.

[TeamAudra]

Underserved elimination - none of them. They weren’t going to win anyway, so it’s irrelevant. The sooner they get to go home, the less reality show stench they have to overcome. Good for them. Seriously

 

Best steal - Probably Max, even though I’m not a fan.

 

Worst save/steal - Hard to choose between HS, Cali and Shane.

[Bouli]

Underserved elimination - none of them. They weren’t going to win anyway, so it’s irrelevant. The sooner they get to go home, the less reality show stench they have to overcome. Good for them. Seriously

Really didn't think of it like this, but now that you mention it, you have a good point. But I'm gonna play along anyway, as if it matters.

 

Undeserved Eliminations (IN ORDER): Marina Chello, Khalea Lynee, Injoy Fountain, Mendeleyev, Gracee Shriver, Dane & Stephanie, Kyndal Inskeep

This just made me realize how many awful eliminations there have been. I forgot about so many of these. I'll always be a little sore about Marina Chello and Khalea Lynee.

 

Deserved Saves/Steals (IN ORDER): Max Boyle, Myracle Holloway, Joana Martinez, Will Breman, Gracee Shriver, Kiara Brown, Cali Wilson

I’d also add that Gracee never should’ve lost her knockout, but I guess it doesn’t matter anymore. Max Boyle’s save never should’ve happened because he won his Knockout IMO. Myracle’s save was literally a miracle (pun intended) and I wanted it, but I didn’t expect it at all; it was 100% the right choice. Will Breman is a treat and deserves to still be on the season, and I’m glad John chose him, although I miss Khalea. Kiara will be forever underrated and forgotten.

 

Undeserved Saves/Steals: Shane Q, Hello Sunday

I guess Kelly didn’t have another better choice there, considering who she had to work with. Shane was the best singer she had to choose from. Funnily enough, these both came from her team. Hello Sunday brought it during their Instant Save performance, but I think Gracee and Jake (but especially Gracee) were much stronger contestants overall.

[Archanium]

Undeserving Elim = Cory :'( and Braddy :'( (and Mendeleyev too)

 

Best Save = Max

 

Worst save = Hello Sunday

[dirActing]

Undeserved Eliminations

1. Kyndal (My #1 snowflake bites the dust well ahead of schedule ... :x )

2. Gracee (She had the best WC performance, imo, and a great song choice to boot. Yes, someone has to go first I get that, but does that person additionally deserve the disadvantage of being on the wrong end of a poorly placed commercial break?)

3. Mendeleyev (He was unique, and could have been a contender on another team.)

 

Most deserved Saves/Steals

1. Myracle (Saving her may not have been the best "strategic" choice, plus it put Kyndal in peril, but Myracle outperformed Kyndal and was probably the best or 2nd best of the night on her team, so the save was well deserved, imo)

2. Max (Very close 2nd to above.)

3. Joana (Worthy 3rd most deserved save of the season thus far.)

 

Undeserved Saves/Steals

1. Shane Q (Also, overall the most undeserving contestant to make the Top 13 this season. Imagine being the least deserving of a save out of a trio that includes Damali and Hello Sunday. )

2. Cali Wilson (Gracee should rightfully feel aggrieved.)

3. Hello Sunday (As above.)