Overdone Songs: Choose your favorite performance!

[Hamza Tufail]

Discuss.

Edited May 5, 2023 by Hamza Tufail

[Hsamid]

Matt, Keisha, Chris.

 

That was easy.

[Hamza Tufail]

• The only versions that I like are Matt, Cam, and Tasha. I choose Matt bc he performed it the best. Cam's performance was Pitch perfect, the best technical of the three tho.

 

• Jaquie, Chris, and NOIVAS all had stellar versions. I liked Cami's blind, battle, and PO, but her KO was my least fav performance from her. I think I'm gonna go with NOIVAS here. Jaquie's vocals were Insane, but there were some parts that weren't pleasant to my ears.

 

• The easiest of them all, John Holiday. Hated Keisha's version a lot. It was so draggy, slow-yy, I was about to fell a sleep. The only part that I liked was the last part. Not a fan of others as well.

Edited April 18, 2023 by Hamza Tufail

[Hsamid]

6 minutes ago, Hamza Tufail said:

• The only versions that I like are Matt, Cam, and Tasha. I choose Matt bc he performed it the best. Cam's performance was Pitch perfect, the best technical of the three tho.

 

• Jaquie, Chris, and NOIVAS all had stellar versions. I liked Cami's blind, battle, and PO, but her KO was my least fav performance from her. I think I'm gonna go with NOIVAS here. Jaquie's vocals were Insane, but there were some parts that weren't pleasant to my ears.

 

• The easiest of them all, John Holiday. Hated Keisha's version a lot. It was so draggy, slow-yy, I was about to fell a sleep. The only part that I liked was the last part. Not a fan of others as well.

Agreed with almost everything.

 

Awesome how good all 3 of those IPASOY covers are. All very different vibes and excellent in their own ways.

 

But Keisha's cover is the closest in length to the original? Anyways, didn't you say she was an overrated vocalist? Boy bye. 

Edited April 18, 2023 by Hsamid

[Cookie73]

I’m going to have to watch all of these again to make my decision

 

I’d say TMTC is the weakest group though, also because the worst performances of it were really bad

[Hamza Tufail]

5 minutes ago, Hsamid said:

Agreed with almost everything.

 

Awesome how good all 3 of those IPASOY covers are. All very different vibes and excellent in their own ways.

 

But Keisha's cover is the closest in length to the original? Anyways, didn't you say she was an overrated vocalist? Boy bye. 

She is.

[Hsamid]

3 minutes ago, Hamza Tufail said:

She is.

[Hamza Tufail]

Just now, Hsamid said:

I'm Out of reactions lol.

 

[nytsch]

Cam 

Jacquie

John H

 

Fwiw, since this discussion is starting again, I’ll put in my two cents: I don’t think Keisha’s version was bad, although I also don’t think it was great as everyone else says. B+ for me probably. What bothered me about Keisha was her clogging up simple songs with so many runs and overdone things, this was a problem in her BA and I maintain her SF performance was terrible. Not sure how much I can say that objectively, but it wasn’t a pleasant listen at all.

[Hsamid]

34 minutes ago, Hamza Tufail said:

I'm Out of reactions lol.

 

Must have been cause NOIVAS was at his most well received yesterday

 

I didn't know you could run out of reactions though..

[Hsamid]

35 minutes ago, nytsch said:

Cam 

Jacquie

John H

 

Fwiw, since this discussion is starting again, I’ll put in my two cents: I don’t think Keisha’s version was bad, although I also don’t think it was great as everyone else says. B+ for me probably. What bothered me about Keisha was her clogging up simple songs with so many runs and overdone things, this was a problem in her BA and I maintain her SF performance was terrible. Not sure how much I can say that objectively, but it wasn’t a pleasant listen at all.

 

See I get that. I didn't mind it most of the time  (probably cause she actually executed her runs, unlike some contestants..) and at least she tried to bring her own spin to the songs she covered.

 

but I can definitely see why that would bother most people. 

 

Unlike Hamza over here who's slandering Keisha's actual vocal abilities!

 

 

Edited April 18, 2023 by Hsamid

[AliXRose]

1. Christiana

2. Cami

3. Keisha

 

[QueenKalie]

I picked Matt, Jacquie and John.

[StarWalker1]

Cam Anthony

 

Jacquie Lee

 

Keisha Renee, cannot stand John Holiday's voice AT ALL

[Gustavo527]

Just now, StarWalker1 said:

cannot stand John Holiday's voice AT ALL

Same 

[allistr]

1 hour ago, StarWalker1 said:

cannot stand John Holiday's voice AT ALL

Love Misty though, other than that I agree