Best Performance - Top 11 - Judges Song Contest

[thevoiceisthetop]

Rank Them

[Discovolcano]

1 Fritz

2 Lady K

3 Leah

4 Christian

5 Jay

6 Noah

7 Tristen

8 Emyrson

9 Nicolina

10 Mike

11 Huntergirl

[Dai]

Fantastic

1. Leah - Is there anything she can't sing? Give her the trophy already.

2. Jay - Gorgeous rendition of a song I love. No complaints.

 

Decent

3. Fritz - Bold song choice but he made it work.

 

Ok

4. Nicolina - Messy at times but overall it was fine.

5. Emyrson - A pleasant surprise! The last fourth of the performance was pretty weak but I really enjoyed the rest. Props.

6. Hunter - It was good karaoke.

7. Christian - Much better than his last two performances, I'll give him that.

8. Noah - If he learned how to use dynamics I would probably rank him higher, but it seems like that won't happen anytime soon.

 

Disappointing

9. Lady K - The song choice was perfect for her, but she missed the emotion and there were a few hiccups here and there. I'm glad she got the save though.

 

Zzzzzz

10. Mike - He's just so average.

11. Tristen

 

[Hamza Tufail]

Leah and Jay owned the night.

 

Will vote later after re-watching their performances again and again. Cz right now i can't decide.

[erik g]

1. Lady K

2. Jay

3. Fritz

4. Emyrson 

5. Leah

6. Christian

7. Nicolina

8. Noah

9. Mike

10. Huntergirl

11. Tristen

[avenue26]

Jay 

Leah 

Fritz 

Tristen 

Noah 

Nicolina 

Lady K 

Christian 

Mike 

Hunter 

Emyrson 

[Hamza Tufail]

2 hours ago, Hamza Tufail said:

Leah and Jay owned the night.

 

Will vote later after re-watching their performances again and again. Cz right now i can't decide.

Ended up voting for Leah.

[rockerannah]

Hands down Leah. She is incredible.

[MargoK]

1. Jay

2. Christian

3. Leah

4. Lady K

5. Nicolina

6. Tristen

 

Everyone else.

[iloveadam]

1. Fritz - I think he's on the personal preference level, I really can't get picky about his singing.

2. Leah - It was a pretty innocent version. I still remember the bull on the masked singers singing it and got me in tears

3. Jay - Okay, vocally he delivered but I almost fell asleep during the performance. 

4. Christian - Solid but too showmanship, not much true emotion.

5. Nicolina - I don't think anyone can do SUBG not a karaoke non-sense but Kelly Clarkson.

6. Huntergirl - At least I like this fun classic song.

7. Emyrson - She should never try to belt a note. Her upper register in chest voice just hurt my ears so fking hard.

8. Mike - Oh boy, you disappoint me too many times, it's time for you to go.

9. Noah - It just sounded really weird. lol at Katy, and Noah still didn't know what was going on. I can't at Straight boys.

10. Tristen - SIGH.

11. Lady K - BAD as hell, go hearing Hailey Mia rendition or the original one.

 

[ShortstopVM]

1. Jay
2. Christian
3. Emyrson
4. Lady K
5. Leah
6. Fritz
7. Mike
8. Tristen
9. Huntergirl
10. Noah
11. Nicolina
 

[JodiRose]

Hey, guys! I was having this conversation with one of my close college friends yesterday, and I remember he told me that he actually watched Season 20 of this show, and that he actually liked the Top 11 round that season. I also remember him talking to me about a contestant that performed “Lilac Wine” (he even sang to me just a line from it to help me remember!) and did a run somewhere in that performance. Even though I totally forgot Jay performed this song because I usually have trouble remembering things that happened in American Idol (unless it has to do with my favorite contestants), I decided that I’m now tying my decision with Jay’s and Noah’s performances.

Edited January 11, 2023 by JodiRose