Which season had the best talent, other than S5, S13, and S18?

[QueenCami]

Hi All!

I wanted to make this poll mostly out of my own curiosity because I know in similar polls, everyone picks S13 with a large number also picking S5, and recently a lot of people have been saying that S18 is one of the best season as well. So, I wanted to see what you guys had to see about the other seasons, as it would also give me an idea of which seasons to watch on YouTube! 

Thanks!

 

 

Edited June 23, 2020 by ashwinner

[Dai]

IMO S4 and S8 had a better overall cast than S13 and S18 (S13 had better results than the ones I mentioned tho).

 

My answer to your question would be S4, it had a better T12 even if season 8 had more talent right after the blinds.

 

Finally, I enjoyed S18 but its cast isn’t among the best (specially since we didn’t hear them live)

[Dalton Eduardo]

Season 13 was by far the best season for me but Season 4 had also great casting especially the Live Shows line-up.  

[Someone648]

My vote here would have to go to season 9, but season 4, 10, 12,  14, and 17 have to be really close behind (7 & 8 as well!)

[sarkis]

voted for season 4 but season 9 also was good

[LilBrooklyn18]

Season 9

 

[becool]

why is season 4 not in this poll

 

[Misirlou]

Season 17. There were some really bad decisions but the talent was great. We had Katie, Khalea and Rose who are vocal beasts. The fantastic Will Breman that brought a lot of fun to the season, some great teenage power like Joana, Marybeth, and Kat. Jake was a classic sounding country singer who delivered a powerful KO and T8 performance. A creative and current sounding pop artist in Max, and my favorite, soulful, bluesy guitar slinging Ricky.

 

We also had Steve, Mendeleyev and Brooke, who were great even in their short run.

Edited June 24, 2020 by Misirlou

[QueenCami]

17 hours ago, Misirlou said:

Season 17. There were some really bad decisions but the talent was great. We had Katie, Khalea and Rose who are vocal beasts. The fantastic Will Breman that brought a lot of fun to the season, some great teenage power like Joana, Marybeth, and Kat. Jake was a classic sounding country singer who delivered a powerful KO and T8 performance. A creative and current sounding pop artist in Max, and my favorite, soulful, bluesy guitar slinging Ricky.

 

We also had Steve, Mendeleyev and Brooke, who were great even in their short run.

honestly looking back, that really was a talented season! and as much as I dont think Jake really deserved the win, his performance of desperado and even his KO were good to me (still not better than most of others in T8 for me). that truly was a great season. Brooke/brennan/joana/marybeth/kat were all good and could have gone farther possibly if that season wasn't as good as it was looking back.(Kat might not have gone father, cause even as someone who liked Kat, I realize she had some pitch issues).

 

I am still baffled by Joana's elimination and Marybeth's instant elimination though

[David68]

12, then 4, then 9, then 17

Edited July 24, 2020 by David68