Rank the Premiere Closing Auditions

[David68]

Season 1 --- Beverly McClellan ~ Piece of My Heart

Season 2 --- Tony Lucca ~ Trouble

Season 3 --- Trevin Hunte ~ Listen

Season 4 --- Judith Hill ~ What a Girl Wants

Season 5 --- James Wolpert ~ Love Interruption 

Season 6 --- Bria Kelly ~ Steamroller Blues

Season 7 --- James David Carter ~ Nobody Knows

Season 8 --- Sawyer Fredericks ~ I'm a Man of Constant Sorrow

Season 9 --- Barrett Baber ~ Angel Eyes

Season 10 --- Alisan Porter ~ Blue Bayou

Season 11 --- Christian Cuevas ~ How Am I Supposed to Live Without You

Season 12 --- Felicia Temple ~ All I Could Do Was Cry

Season 13 --- Brooke Simpson ~ Stone Cold

Season 14 --- Justin Kilgore ~ Tomorrow

Season 15 --- Kennedy Holmes ~ Turning Tables

Season 16 --- Matthew Johnson ~ I Smile

Season 17 --- Kyndal Inskeep ~ Never Been to Spain

Season 18 --- Joanna Serenko ~ All My Loving

Season 19 --- This isn't completely confirmed yet, but I'll put it here

 

Tamara Jade ~  Cuz I Love You

Edited August 29, 2020 by David68

[Hamza Tufail]

Edited January 30, 2021 by Hamza Tufail

[antikid]

Kennedy, Brooke, Alisan and Judith!

[Someone648]

Loved:

1. Alisan Porter

2. Kennedy Holmes

3. James Wolpert

4. Felicia Temple

5. Judith Hill

6. Bria Kelly

 

Liked:

7. Brooke Simpson

8. Trevin Hunte

9. James David Carter

10. Beverly McClellan

11. Joanna Serenko

 

Indifferent:

12. Sawyer Fredericks

13. Barrett Baber

14. Tony Lucca

 

Disliked:

15. Kyndal Inskeep

16. Matthew Johnson

17. Justin Kilgore

18. Christian Cuevas

 

Watch us be wrong on the S19 premiere closer though looool

[VintageVoice]

All-around excellence:

• Judith Hill
• Bria Kelly
• Sawyer Fredericks
• Alisan Porter
• Brooke Simpson

 

Still solid but not quite as good as ones listed above:

• Trevin Hunte
• James Wolpert
• Barrett Baber
• Christian Cuevas
• Felicia Temple
• Kennedy Holmes
• Kyndal Inskeep

[QueenCami]

11 hours ago, David68 said:

 

Season 19 --- This isn't completely confirmed yet, but I'll put it here

  Reveal hidden contents

Tamara Jade ~  Cuz I Love You

You say this isn't completely confirmed - is there any indication at least or is it just based on the fact that we know it's gonna be good? @Someone648

[Someone648]

17 hours ago, ashwinner said:

You say this isn't completely confirmed - is there any indication at least or is it just based on the fact that we know it's gonna be good? @Someone648

I mean we just don't know how they'll air it. They very well could be the closer but we'll just have to wait and see how NBC decides to edit the premiere - I do think it's the most likely candidate at the moment.

[QueenCami]

2 minutes ago, Someone648 said:

I mean we just don't know how they'll air it. They very well could be the closer but we'll just have to wait and see how NBC decides to edit the premiere - I do think it's the most likely candidate at the moment.

Do you have any other speculations? (If so, possibly that you could mention in the S19 Spoilers section)

[Someone648]

5 minutes ago, ashwinner said:

Do you have any other speculations? (If so, possibly that you could mention in the S19 Spoilers section)

Based on the placing of the other 4-chairs in the lineup and how they'll have to spread them out due to blocks, etc. DeSz is the only fitting alternative I see. If they need a surprising closer, John Holiday could very well be bumped up to the premiere.