Sound alikes (Part 1)

[Hamza Tufail]

I don't think they all sound really similar but still you could tell that they do have (kind of) similar tones. P.S. I've seen many people comparing their voices before so....

 

Also, Joshua doesn't sound like Jordan he just had that "Shock Factor" that Jordan had. I think Carter's Tone is more similar to Jordan than Joshua's.

Edited December 22, 2022 by Hamza Tufail

[Hamza Tufail]

1. Mathew - I love "Summertime" but overall Mathew had a better run. Cough Syrup, Light em' up, Cosmic Love, Wrecking Ball and the lost goes on. I think at his best he's one of the best ever.

 

2. Todd - Josh is one of the best male vocalists of all-time. Some here Would even argue that he's THE best. But Todd has my favorite Tone out of the two. Anymore is one if my favorite KOs and his Finale set is one of my favorite sets of all-time.

 

3. Jordan - Carter is really talented singer. "You Say" clearly shows he can SING. But with that said, Jordan's performances are some of the best we've ever seen. I pick him.

 

[erik g]

1. Matthew

2. Todd

3. Jordan (and how do him and Carter sound alike lol)

[Hamza Tufail]

4 minutes ago, erik g said:

3. Jordan (and how do him and Carter sound alike lol)

They do. lol 

 

Both have (kind of) similar Tones.

Edited December 27, 2021 by Hamza Tufail

[Dai]

People like Todd more than Josh?? That’s a surprise (I’m guessing most users who voted didn’t watch S6)

[Misirlou]

Josh and Todd  are similar in the fact that they are bearded grown men with glasses that also happen to be fathers and MJ snowflakes. Plus they won.

 

Vocally though, there's nothing remotely similar about their tones. Josh's is light and lends itself into more R&B/Soul, and he has a great falsetto to boot. Todd's is gravelly and grainy with a strong rasp, way more fit for country and soft rock, plus gospel, obviously. 

 

Out of the two I prefer Josh, but I really like Todd as well.

 

As for the other options, I actually kinda see the similarilty on tones but I wouldnt call them sound-alikes. I'll go with TStorm and Jordan.

 

If you want sound-alikes, go for Cole Vosbury(S5) and Chris Kroeze (S15). Tell me they dont sound similar. Not the same, but really close.

[TeamAudra]

Thunderstorm 

 

Josh. Todd never song live. It’s not his fault, but there will forever be an asterisk for me. 
 

Jordan, but this is not a fair matchup. 
 

 

[Someone648]

Matthew Schuler. Not picking the one who got edits.

Todd Tilghman - TA’s point aside, I wasn’t a fan of Josh during his run.

Jordan - easy.

[Hamza Tufail]

37 minutes ago, TeamAudra said:

 

 

Jordan, but this is not a fair matchup. 
 

 

This is not a matchup where you are supposed to pick the one who is superior vocally or technically. You're just supposed to pick the one who you prefer.

Edited December 27, 2021 by Hamza Tufail

[Cookie73]

Matthew vs Thunderstorm is very difficult. As for Thunderstorm, he never declined like Matthew, but Matthew was on a much longer season with actual Live performances. Plus he was in a more competitive season than Thunderstorm. And Matthew had a lot of moments before his declined, which happened right when Thunderstorm’s season ended. I guess I can make a stronger argument for Matthew, so he wins.

Josh. I felt like I enjoyed him more throughout the season than Todd. Yeah, they’re more similar based on look and age, their voices are very different

 

Jordan. He was more technically skilled than Carter and more developed. Plus he was more consistent throughout his run