Jump to content

Which batch of winners do you prefer?


Which batch of winners do you prefer?  

25 members have voted

  1. 1. From Season 2 on

    • Spring Batch
    • Fall Batch

Recommended Posts

Starting in Season 2:
Batch 1 Spring: Jermaine Paul, Danielle Bradbury, Josh Kaufman, Sawyer Fredricks, Alisan Porter, Chris Blue, Brynn Cartelli, Maelyn Jarmon, Todd Tilghman, Cam Anthony

Batch 2 Fall: Cassadee Pope, Tessanne Chin, Craig Wayne Boyd, Jordan Smith, Sundance Head, Chloe Kohanski, Chevel Shepherd, Jake Hoot, Carter Rubin, Girl Named Tom


Next Question: If you were to choose only one winner per year from 2012 on; who would you choose?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'll start, I lean towards spring. My lineup would be as follows

Season 1:Javier Colon (Default)

Season 2: Cassadee Pope

Season 3: Tessanne Chin

Season 4: Josh Kaufman

Season 5: Jordan Smith

Season 6: Alisan Porter

Season 7: Chloe Kohanski

Season 8: Brynn Cartelli

Season 9: Maelyn Jarmon

Season 10:Carter Rubin

Season 11: Cam Anthony

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think I’d go with Spring winners because Alisan, Maelyn and Cam are all in that batch (though I generally prefer the fall seasons)


Season 1- Javier Colon (default)

Season 2- Cassadee Pope

Season 3- Tessanne Chin

Season 4- Josh Kaufman

Season 5- Jordan Smith

Season 6- Alisan Porter

Season 7- Chris Blue

Season 8- Chevel Shepherd

Season 9- Maelyn Jarmon

Season 10- Todd Tilghman

Season 11- Cam Anthony

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Season 1: Javier Colon - By default.

Season 2: Cassadee Pope - Easy choice. I didn't like Jermaine much.

Season 3: Tessanne Chin - I love Danielle but Tessanne is my favorite female contestant of all time.

Season 4: Craig Wayne Boyd - Like Josh as well and "Stay with me is one of the best vocals by a male contestant but I just have a special place for CWB in my heart. He's probably my favorite country act of all time.

Season 5: Jordan Smith - Love love Sawyer but can't go against Jordan.

Season 6: Sundance Head - Close but his run was more enjoyable. He had so many great song choices throughout. He took a lot of risks singing, Alicia, Miley, Etta,...

Season 7: Chris Blue - Like Chloe as well but prefer Chris more.

Season 8: Chevel Shepherd - Both good but I enjoy her run more.

Season 9: Maelyn - "Fields of Gold" is one of my all-time favorite auditions.

Season 10: Todd Tilghman - Adore Carter but Todd was more Consistent.

Season 11: Cam Anthony - Love Bekah but Josh and Caleb weren't consistent OTOH, Cam was one of the most consistent performers of all-time.


Had to go with the fall option since both Jordan and Tessanne were in it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hard, but I'll go with the spring batch on this one because it has Sawyer, Maelyn and Cam


Year 2- Cassadee Pope

Year 3- Tessanne Chin

Year 4- Josh Kaufman

Year 5- Sawyer Fredericks

Year 6- Alisan Porter

Year 7- Chloe mk 

Year 8- Chevel Shepherd

Year 9- Maelyn Jarmon

Year 10- 😬

Year 11- Cam Anthony

Edited by Gustavo527
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Year 2 : Cassadee Pope 

Year 3: Tessanne Chin

Year 4: Josh Kaufman (I liked Craig as well)

Year 5: Sawyer Fredericks (Enjoyed Jordan too) 
Year 6: Sundance Head 

Year 7: Chloe Mk

Year 8: Chevel Shephard 

Year 9: Maelyn

Year 10:Todd Tilghman

Year 11: Girl Named Tom (Really close, I love Cam as well)


Spring: 4 

Fall: 6 


I´m team Fall I guess, although my favorite winner (Sawyer) won in a spring season. 


I definitely tend to prefer the fall seasons as well.

Edited by Misirlou
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Create New...