Who sang Faith Hill's "Cry" the best?

[Vinyl]

Cassadee Pope (season 3)

 

Andrea Thomas (season 12)

https://www.metatube.com/en/videos/343606/The-Voice-2017-Knockout-Andrea-Thomas-Cry/

 

Reagan Strange (season 15)

 

Taryn Papa (season 19)

 

Edited November 25, 2020 by Vinyl

[Rodney]

Andrea, and only because of the stratospheric whistle tone she hit.

 

Taryn's was okay, but not great.

 

The less said about Reagan's, the better.

 

And I have yet to see season three, and the show seems unwilling to release any of their seasons on DVD, so I probably won't see it.  So I can't comment on Cassadee.

[Hamza Tufail]

I'm gonna go with Cassade.

[Bouli]

1 hour ago, Rodney said:

The less said about Reagan's, the better.

 

I voted for Cassadee.

 

But you HAVE to give Reagan some credit. No matter how you feel about that performance, it was the spark that set Season 15 on fire. It started RobeGate. That was the greatest drama this show has EVER had.

 

Dang it, I should've voted for Reagan.

[sydneysam]

Just now, Bouli said:

But you HAVE to give Reagan some credit. No matter how you feel about that performance, it was the spark that set Season 15 on fire. It started RobeGate. That was the greatest drama this show has EVER had.

 

I'd never think of that! the show had been more interesting because of that drama

[TeamAudra]

They were all bad. The song should probably be taken out of the rotation for good. It’s probably challenging for a Faith to sing live and make it sound close to the studio, with all the engineering and background vocals. 
 

Bad song choice for all of them. 

Edited November 25, 2020 by TeamAudra