Dai

1. Halley 2. Corey (big gap) 3-6. Gihanna/Gean/Ryleigh/Kenzie 7. JD

Overrated = not as good as most people claim her to be. I don’t think calling someone overrated but admit they deserved finale are incompatible. She’s still good in my eyes, but most IDF users think she had an amazing run, which I personally disagree with.

I really enjoyed it the first time I watched it, but after rewatching I started to hear the pitch issues. Another opinion I have to add to the list is that Cami was the most overrated contestant last season (S19), even if I like her. She deserved finale and all, she was lowkey robbed of a PV on the Playoffs, but I still don’t think she ever “knocked it out of the park”.

C-/D+ This week has been brutal imo, even if no one was technically bad.

Ok 1. Gihanna (Tone lands you here, but this wasn’t great. I don’t see the hype yet) Meh 2-5. Everyone else. #FodderWeek

Agreed. Love her tone but something was off.

I love Adele (who doesn’t?), and she’s also one of my favorites, but the covers of her songs usually fall flat for me. Idk if it’s because her songs are hard or because maybe I have high standars, but they never work for me. I think I would be fine with some of her more obscure songs tho (I Miss You, Love In The Dark, most of 19...)

Love the subtle autocorrect, really effective

I would actually be more than happy if they sing some Stapleton as long as is not Tennessee Whiskey (which I should have added to my list). As for Sheeran, Thinking Out Loud can burn.

I’ll add these for now: It's a Man's Man's Man's World (James Brown) A Natural Woman (Aretha Franklin) I Have Nothing (Whitney Houston) All By Myself (Celine Dion) I Don’t Want To Miss A Thing (Aerosmith) Ain’t No Way (Aretha Franklin) When A Man Loves A Woman (Micheal Bolton) These need no explanation, lol. Bruno Mars’ entire discography. Most modern country songs (unless it’s for bussing purposes ) Queen in general (unless you’re Jordan Smith) Adele in general Chandelier (Sia)

Either because you are tired of them being covered again and again, or because you just don’t like them, even if they aren’t particularly overdone.

One of the weirdest runs on the show. At the start of the live shows, it seemed like they were trying to get rid of her (she got awful performance spots and pretty meh song choices) and then out of the blue they decided to pimp her and bus Brennley instead. Personally I really liked her voice, but her song choices held her back and she wasn't as good as Vanessa, Lauren, Hunter or Chris.

Kim and Amanda say hi

Amanda’s biggest feat is Dream On still being considered as this show’s best performance 17 seasons later. Queen

I think Julian King closed an episode? He was a block tho. Corey Kent White from S8 also closed.

https://giphy.com/ Do us all a favor and find some new GIFS to use

Yeah, and even when we had rock singers they didn't usually make it far. I wish someone like Juliet would audition again.

You nailed it

One of my least favorite auditions so far. Not sure why he got 3 chairs.

C again.

Great 1. Halley (In a boring episode, she was the only one who managed do something different, so easy #1) Good 2. Durell (Solid, but uninspired song choice) 3. Pia (I know she can do better than what we saw here) 4. Ciana (I don’t hate the song as much as other people here, but it didn’t do her any favors. 5. Ryleigh (I like her voice, but I need to hear more. Edit: I started to hear pitch issues after a rewatch, so I changed her placement) Meh 6. Avery (I don’t like his voice and this was pretty plain) 7. Jose (I don’t think there were that many runs, but I wasn’t a fan of the ones that he did) 8. Andrew (Basic) 9. Emma (Love Kacey but this wasn’t it)

You are too nice

I still think that’s a great performance, I just wouldn’t classify it as a moment. Same with Cryin’ (which I really enjoyed as well).

So this is what happens when I forget to vote

Matt vs Will Amy vs Madi Koryn vs Kim Sarah vs Warren