American Idol Season 21 Top 12 Revealed! - Favorite Performances Poll

[StarWalker1]

Who stood out to you tonight?

Edited April 25, 2023 by StarWalker1

[m1key]

Lol seems like this thread kinda got buried amidst the aftermath of last night's episode   I just had the chance to watch/rewatch all the performances for the performances I missed and/or the performances I wasn't paying attention to. 

 

Kaeyra was my fave obviously. That performance felt like a true Idol moment to me. The outfit/gloves, the lighting, the dramatics  Tragic! Also, I never thought I'd be saying this but I actually loved Colin's performance! It was a really interesting take on the song.

 

Wé disappointed me a bit tbh. She sounded amazing (as always) but the song choice was uninspired and she did nothing new with it. Her worst is better than a lot of people's best though! 

 

I also loved Lucy, Matt, Oliver, and Ik y'all aren't gonna agree, but Haven  

[CarmenSandiego]

I chose Wé (obviously) and Nutsa, although Kaeyra would have been right behind them.

 

Incidentally, I think that Wé chose "This Is Me" just in case she had to sing for her life.  Obviously, she didn't realize that having to sing for her life was highly unlikely, but at least she was prepared.

[FloorWax]

First poll, I really only loved Matt’s performance.

 

In the second, the performances are overall much stronger but I liked Kaeyra and Megan the best. I didn’t vote for them but Lucy, Colin, Nutsa, Iam, and Marybeth all did great too.

Edited April 26, 2023 by FloorWax

[Raphy]

Kaeyra. 

 

I get why she didn't make it tho. Not what America likes.

[nytsch]

1. Kaeyra

2. Marybeth

3. Tyson

4. Lucy

[erik g]

Kaeyra

[jarmon]

2 minutes ago, erik g said:

Kaeyra

Can't believe she was eliminated after 2 KILLER performances!!!