American Idol Season 21 Top 20 Reveal Poll

[jdanton2]

i thought group 2 was  much stronger.

 

group 1

 

1 Iam

2 Nailyah

3 Mariah

4 Haven

5 Matt

 

group 2

 

1 Olivia

2 Tyson

3 Nutsa

4 Wé

5 Hannah

[Dai]

Kaeyra was the standout for me. Loved We, Nailyah and Iam as well.

[iloveadam]

Megan Danielle actually did pretty well, I only remember her performance.

 

Kaeyra was on fire, but that song was already owned by Paula Dalla Corte for me.

[CarmenSandiego]

Kaeyra was the best from Group 1.

 

You can take a look at my signature and guess who was my favorite from Group 2.  

[Anythingcanhappen]

Wé is def overrated in this poll (in general) I mean cmon… Olivia outsold her vocally for sure

Edited April 24, 2023 by Anythingcanhappen

[hazuki]

Kaeyra/Olivia 

[*Wallace]

1.    Wé Ani - Skyfall
2.    Kaeyra - Bruises
3.    Nutsa - Un-Break My Heart
4.    Lucy Love - Boulders
5.    Olivia Soli - I Surrender
6.    Nailyah Serenity - Baby Love
7.    Iam Tongi - The Winner Takes It All
8.    Marybeth Byrd - People Pleaser
9.    Tyson Venegas - 180
10.    Hannah Nicolaisen - Somebody to Love
11.    Zachariah Smith - I Want to Know What Love Is
12.    Oliver Steele - Too Soon
13.    Paige Anne - Say Something
14.    Matt Wilson - Say You Won't Let Go
15.    Haven Madison - Mean Girls
16.    Mariah Faith - Cry to Me
17.    Warren Peay - Up There Down Here
18.    Megan Danielle - Holy Water
19.    Michael Williams - Lose You to Love Me
20.   Colin Stough - Pretty Heart
 

I voted for Kaeyra & Lucy on the first poll. Then I voted for Nutsa & Wé on the second poll.

[QueenKalie]

15 minutes ago, *Wallace said:

1.    Wé Ani - Skyfall
2.    Kaeyra - Bruises
3.    Nutsa - Un-Break My Heart
4.    Lucy Love - Boulders
5.    Olivia Soli - I Surrender
6.    Nailyah Serenity - Baby Love
7.    Iam Tongi - The Winner Takes It All
8.    Marybeth Byrd - People Pleaser
9.    Tyson Venegas - 180
10.    Hannah Nicolaisen - Somebody to Love
11.    Zachariah Smith - I Want to Know What Love Is
12.    Oliver Steele - Too Soon
13.    Paige Anne - Say Something
14.    Matt Wilson - Say You Won't Let Go
15.    Haven Madison - Mean Girls
16.    Mariah Faith - Cry to Me
17.    Warren Peay - Up There Down Here
18.    Megan Danielle - Holy Water
19.    Michael Williams - Lose You to Love Me
20.   Colin Stough - Pretty Heart
 

I voted for Kaeyra & Lucy on the first poll. Then I voted for Nutsa & Wé on the second poll.

I'm surprised that's I don't hate this ranking.

[*Wallace]

10 minutes ago, QueenKalie said:

I'm surprised that's I don't hate this ranking.

[QueenKalie]

Just now, *Wallace said:

Yeah I'm proud of your growth! 

[*Wallace]

4 minutes ago, QueenKalie said:

Yeah I'm proud of your growth! 

Nope I'm proud of YOUR growth! Your taste is improving now.  

[StarWalker1]

3 hours ago, Anythingcanhappen said:

Wé is def overrated in this poll (in general) I mean cmon… Olivia outsold her vocally for sure

ok then ...

[CarmenSandiego]

6 hours ago, Anythingcanhappen said:

Wé is def overrated in this poll (in general) I mean cmon… Olivia outsold her vocally for sure

I don’t really agree.  Also, it’s not just about the vocals.  She needs to show that she has a more current sound.  Celine, Mariah and Whitney songs aren’t current enough anymore and that’s what she’s mostly been doing.

Edited April 24, 2023 by CarmenSandiego