In the old 'Bloodbath' format, what would the S19 Top 9 results be?

[example1011]

If you used the Top 9 Bloodbath format from S9 (T3, M3, B3 and no team quotas), how might things pan out for the S19 Top 9?

 

My thoughts:

T3: Carter, Jim, Desz

M3: Cami, John, Ian

B3: Tamara, Bailey, Ben

IS: Cami

[FloorWax]

T3: Carter, Ian, Desz

M3: John, Jim, Ben

B3: Cami, Tamara, Bailey

 

IS: John Holiday

[Dai]

T3: Carter, Ian, Ben

M3: Desz (IS), John, Jim

B3: Tamara, Cami, Bailey

[Hamza Tufail]

Top 3 => Carter Rubin, John Holiday and Ben Allen.

Middle Three => DeSz, Ian and Jim.

Bottom Three => Cami, Tamara and Bailey.

The locks are Carter and John. The third one would really depend on song choices. Ben has the best chance but Ian or Jim can sneak in off they have better song choice and deliver.

[VintageVoice]

PV: Carter, Ian, DeSz

M3: Ben, Jim, John

B3: Cami, Tamara, Bailey

 

DeSz overcame questionable song choice + sound mixing to get the PV and is well-liked online, so she'd likely move on given her coach is well-liked as well. Carter and Ian are both locks.

 

Ben is the one in the Middle 3 likeliest to swap places with DeSz as he's also well-liked online, but I can't see Gwen getting two in the finale via PV. John's a great vocalist but song choice is crucial for him, especially as a non-country vocalist on the show. Jim, while likable enough, is up against Ian and has gotten less buzz online than Ben and Ian.

 

Cami's genre likely eliminates her since even though she was one of the stronger (if not the strongest) on Kelly's team Monday night she needed the save to move on, Tamara needed the coach save to move on, and Bailey has already been in an "instant save" situation once.

 

From the Middle Three, I'd put the odds of moving on at Ben = Jim > John, but it'd be close. Ben's the better-liked country act, but Jim has the Blake stans in his pocket; John might benefit from two country acts splitting the vote but considering Bailey won an Instant Save that was 75% country, I wouldn't count on that.

[Misirlou]

PV: Carter, Ian, Desz

Middle 3: Ben, Jim, John H.(winner)

B3: Cami, Bailey, Tamara

[QueenMae16]

Top 3: Carter/Ian/Desz 

IS: Ben, doesn't matter who's with him, I think he wins it. 

 

Watch Gwen actually get Ben in with a PV, Lmao. 

Gwen is slaying this season like crazy, she's gonna get 2 finalists and the winner.