mrsvaledictorian2017

Maybe this is why we don't have our Top 24 confirmed yet?

Do you know what the contestant’s name is? Or are you only giving the clue that it’s a girl?

Wait does this mean they’re going to restart the competition? (I’m kidding)

Yeah and to get a reaction since it’s a spoilers thread.

Yeah exactly. If we knew the Top 24, we would know everyone that made it or least more than one person that made the semi finals.

I guess we need to look at these contestants once again to figure it out lol. I don’t think the other person is going to say who it is or give a clue so.

Can you at least tell us if it's a man or woman lol? I mean you should give us some sort of clue since you decided to tell everyone in this thread that you know who the first Top 24 contestant is.

I think I didn't realize that the Showstopper Episode after round 3 of Hollywood Week last season was Green Mile. That's why I thought it was going to be all of the 64 contestants. Not just the 41 for Green Mile. But you explained it perfectly. 23 Singers were cut off camera.

Yeah the last time they did Hawaii was for Season 18 and then they didn't do Hawaii last season because of COVID.

They had this many people for last season's showcase season too I believe.

When do we think we'll get the Top 24 spoilers? I kind of thought we would get them by now.

Why do I feel like that last season was the only season where the judges were that extreme with last year's semi finalists and the other seasons they weren't as extreme with every contestant that made the final judgement. I don't remember the judges acting like everyone was bad except for last season.

Is it just me or does it look like he lost weight? He looked great before too. I'm just saying it looks like he's been working out.

I just feel it would make it too obvious if every person that got a standing ovation made it. As the judges have said in the past, they base it on every performance that contestant has done.

I don’t know if Jacob Moran will win or if he will even make the Top 24. Assuming he makes the Top 24, I think it’s possible he could be this season’s Willie Spence.

So who's the 59th contestant/unidentified female?

It also would be a representation of our world today if one day someone who was gay, bisexual, or transgender won. Also, if someone wasn’t a female or male and just referred to themselves as they/them (Like Demi Lovato) won American Idol.

It wasn’t totally tragic in my opinion. I mean one of the Top 2 was a soulful black singer (Willie Spence).

Actually, I remember Allegra from The Voice. I know she had a great voice, but her name sounding like a medication is what made me remember her.

I don't know if anyone else can relate, but I tend to remember the former American Idol contestants more who try out again for future seasons than The Voice contestants who try out for The Voice and then try a different singing show after like American Idol. Maybe it's because with American Idol, the judges are watching the contestants the whole time and with The Voice you have to get the judges to turn their chairs to look at you.

It makes me wonder if that was all to get a conversation going among the general public.

When it was said that a fan favorite was returning, is Jacob Moran from Season 17 of American Idol the “fan favorite”?

Also, I vaguely remember Jacob. I liked that he was a nurse with a great singing voice. Also, I remember not expecting his rendition of that Ariana Grande song to be as good as it was.

Am I counting correctly when I'm getting 48 names for the Top 59?

A few returnees. I remember how much I liked Jade.