mrsvaledictorian2017

Just my guess, but maybe the judges told them to challenge themselves and sing something outside of their comfort zone. I remember they tried doing that with Alex Miller.

The first time I actually don't trust it as well. As you said, there are no country singers in this list.

Yes Jacob is in if this is legit.

I was wondering the same thing.

I brought up Laine because we brought up Alejandro (From Laine’s Season) saying that he did what Chayce is probably going to do this season during Hollywood Round. I was trying to ask why would they bring back last season’s winner and not the winner from Season 17? But that was answered after I asked and why I decided to drop it and move on.

I like Alejandro, but is the reason why they brought him for Hollywood Week and not Laine Hardy was because Alejandro is a songwriter? I would have expected them to bring the winner of the season for Hollywood Week. That’s why I’m asking.

What would he be doing there though? Is he going to mentor the contestants this season?

No, but at least most of it. I guess you make a good point.

I still don't understand how a contestant in the Top 59 is unidentified though. Don't they reveal who they are before they perform?

We know two of the Top 24. Most likely three if we include Christian Guardino. The two we definitely know are Nicolina Bozzo and Kenedi Anderson.

I thought she did at first because on one of Danielle's posts, Morgan commented I'm so happy for you. I think I was over analyzing the post and comment though. So for right now, it doesn't seem like this is enough evidence to confirm that.

I’m a little bit confused. Are you saying best one because you feel the contestant picked the right song?

It’s hard to tell though because we don’t hear them sing in the promo.

I just meant those are the only two we named in this thread that we considered as possibilities so far.

Well at least either her or Carrie Brockwell.

I saw on mjsbigblog that Zareh Isa who is the daughter of Season 4 Top 8 finalist Nadia Turner is auditioning for this season of American Idol. I wonder if she is the unidentified Top 59 female singer who we are trying to figure out.

Well it’s good for us because we get a lot of good entertainment. Bad for the judges because they are going to make some tough decisions/cuts.

I looked at the Danielle Finn/Morgan Gruber post again and now come to the conclusion that it’s a little premature to say that this is confirmation of making Top 24.

@ashleys@SheidovitsjajIs she right that Danielle Clavell or Danielle Finn made the Top 24?

So I want to know from AshleyS if we are right that Christian Guardino is the third contestant that made the Top 24 with Kenedi Anderson and Nicolina Bozzo.

If Kelly Clarkson or Jennifer Hudson weren’t coaches on The Voice, I would one of them should be a mentor. Even Carrie Underwood or Haley Reinhart too. Other good options of non American Idol Contestants include: Ryan Tedder, Andy Grammer, Lukas Graham, Gwen Stefani, Lady Gaga, or Mick Jagger. Even Rihanna would be good too.

Kris Allen would be a good mentor too. I think it was last season or this season when he was helping certain contestants before they auditioned for American Idol.

If you're going to give clues, you need to reveal if we're right or not. I think Christian Guardino is who you're talking about. Also, how do we know you have a valid source for your information?

Christian Guardino also possibly made the Top 24 if we are right with that person's clue.

Other great mentors for American Idol that the show won't be able to get: Stevie Wonder, Dr. Dre, Paul McCartney, Taylor Swift, Ed Sheeran, Carole King, or Tina Turner. Even Eminem would be great. He mostly raps, but he knows a talented singer/artist when he sees one and he's really good at using the dictionary when writing songs.