mrsvaledictorian2017

I think I was thinking to the first season he mentored where sometimes he was there before they performed and talked to them a bit about their performance. I remembered him doing it for certain ones.

I understand, but she was right about the first person and the tik tok post made it obvious. I don’t know what her source is though.

Okay now I get where you’re coming from.

For Kenedi Anderson, can you give us a clue if we have to look on Instagram or Tik Tok for confirmation of making Top 24?

I understand, but if they were right about the first person, which they were and they are giving us “hints”, then it makes sense they are right about Kenedi.

I’m confused why that’s not good enough for evidence lol? Why would they lie about who is in the Top 24?

Well is the person who guessed Christian Guardino right?

I think we're ready for the hint for the 3rd contestant that made the Top 24. We already figured out the two of the three that you knew.

Congrats to Kenedi Anderson for being the second contestant to make the Top 24.

They did when the one user said Mikey was correct for guessing the first contestant to make the Top 24. Since they said most of us were correct with one guess, the answer then would be Kenedi Anderson.

So are you going to leave us hanging on the hint you gave us for the second Top 24 contestant?

So is it Kenedi Anderson or Ciasia Nicole? Or is it someone else?

So is Kenedi Anderson the second person who made the Top 24?

Beyoncé would be great as a in house mentor too, but it’s never gonna happen.

Hanson would be awesome to have as an American Idol mentor in house mentor and it would be a trio of mentors not just one person.

If we are talking about people who never were in house mentors on American Idol, I would recommend Adam Lambert, Demi Lovato, Chris Daughtry, Randy Jackson, Mary J. Blige, or Bebe Rexha.

Jimmy Iovine? He was such a good mentor and the first in house mentor the American Idol show had. He was definitely better than Bobby Bones. I would love to see him mentor contestants on American Idol again. Scott Borchetta on the other hand I couldn’t stand. I hated him as a mentor for American Idol. Bobby Bones was okay, but came off very corny with his jokes.

Thank you for the hint of the second Top 24 contestant. Then, you can give us the one for third since you said you know 3 of them that are confirmed. You already confirmed our guest for the first person.

So is there a different mentor for this season?

With Bobby Bones leaving, does that mean we get Jimmy Iovine back in Bobby Bones role? I always liked Jimmy better than Bobby.

The question is who is replacing Bobby Bones if they have someone replace him.

I’m not quoting every post lol. Only a couple because I had a response to them.

You still didn't tell us who the contestant is that this regards to.

Someone writing something like this, "Source anonymous. 3 confirmed Top 24 so far. Will post first hint in 10 minutes" (This actually happened) is a perfect example of trolling and playing mind games with other uses who look in the spoilers thread. Also, this person went silent after writing this post and after people were asking them what they knew.

I don’t have a problem with getting spoilers. My problem is people saying they have spoilers and then don’t say what the spoiler is. They are basically trolling when they do that.