I've been a huge fan of Gabby's since her audition, and after she's married Cade she has seemed to have really changed or maybe her true colors have come out, but I definitely am not feeling like a big fan of hers anymore. Her father alienating half her fanbase by bashing "snowflake liberals" when I am in fact a liberal. Yeah, I'm definitely not happy with Gabby right now.
Maddie overreacts and looks for drama constantly, but it really sounds like none of them really liked Cade and Gabby all that much and it seems like Gabby's family may have been a nightmare during Idol. Maybe that's why she was once the front runner, and ended up not even making the finale.