I think a bigger "What if" is what if Sharon never made S4?
She wouldn't have been the runaway fan favourite (at the time), Ru then wouldn't have cast Alaska on S5. Without Alaska on S5 telling the queens about Sharon's message re: playing up feuds for airtime and to have the show keep them sa long as possible for maximum drama. Without Alaska there, the CoCo/Alyssa "feud" is non-existent. How does Jinkx fair against Roxxxy and Detox with no Alaska in the mix? Then that brings us to AS2... Since there's no Alaska, there's already a different dynamic between Roxxxy and Detox there. Then you have no one winning so many lip syncs undeservingly and robbing Tatianna... does Alyssa still go home in fifth, or does she make the finale? IN the finale, does Katya's Read U Wrote U verse give her the win since there's no production favourite there?
So in short, Sharon being cast on S4 is the reason Tatianna was robbed and Katya didn't win AS2, thank you for coming to my TED Talk.