Jump to content

Seasons 23, 24, 25 as a regular format(Live Playoffs and more weeks of live shows)


QueenMae16

Recommended Posts

Don't remember seeing this, but have fun discussing how this could have gone. S23, S24, S25 as S21/S22 formats.

 

If the recent seasons had more weeks of lives and of course voting in the Playoffs, how differently do you think it could have gone? Would Winners and Finalists be different? Who would rise and fall with more time to showcase themselves? Go crazy tbh. 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

S23 

Playoffs 

Team Blake 

PV1: Grace 

PV2: NOIVAS 

PV3: Mary Kate 

 

Team Niall

PV1: Gina 

PV2: Ryley 

CS: Ross 

 

Team Chance 

PV1: Kala 

PV2: Sorelle 

CS: Ray 

 

Team Kelly

PV1: D. Smooth 

PV2: Holly

CS: Honestly, no idea here. Cait?? 

 

Just for more fun, 

Wildcard 

TB: Rachel 

TN: Michael 

TC: Jamar 

TK: Neil 

 

IS winner: Neil 

 

Top 13:

Bottom 3 

Ray (duh)

Cait (just not audience bait)

Mary Kate (she would have most likely flopped)

 

IS winner: Cait (pimp spot with big song)

 

Top 11 

Bottom 2 

Cait 

Sorelle 

 

IS winner: Sorelle (*insert meltdowns*) 

 

Top 10 

Bottom 3 

Sorelle 

Ross (*insert bus here*) 

Kala 

 

IS winner: Kala 

 

Top 8 (this is hard)

Bottom 4 

Kala  

D. Smooth  (his modern R&B style is way to unconventional for the viewers, so i assume i a normal PV he loses to Holly) 

Ryley (assuming Gina would have still had her breakout moment with Wicked Game, which would have carried her to the finale, plus Ryley is just more inexperienced, remember he flopped with "Vienna") 

I want to say NOIVAS but idk if Blake voters would have carried him over Neil. Let's say that unfortunately yes, they would have, so Neil 

 

IS winner: Neil 

 

Top 5 

5th place: NOIVAS (he would have flopped as hard as he actually did, so 5th easily 

4th place: Neil 

3rd place: Holly 

2nd place: Grace 

Winner: Gina, assuming she still had her finale pimp spot with Nothing Compares 2 U in this scenary

 

 

 

 

  • Like 1
  • Confused 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

That was fun, let's do S24 

 

Team Reba  

PV1: Ruby 

PV2: Noah 

CS: Jacquie 

 

Team Niall 

PV1: Huntley 

PV2: Mara 

CS: Nini 

 

Team Gwen 

PV1: Lennon 

PV2: i don't remember how hard BIAS flopped, tbh. But he is a country male so him 

CS: I want to think Gwen wouldn't have given it to Tanner, but nah, let's be realistic, him. 

 

Team Legend 

PV1: Kaylee 

PV2: Mac 

CS: Lila?? Let's say Lila 

 

Wildcard 

TR: Jordan 

TN: Alexa 

TG: Rudi 

TL: Kristen 

 

WC winner: Alexa  

 

Top 13 

Bottom 3 

Tanner  

Lennon 

Lila (Yep, in this scenary she is not a finalist) 

 

IS winner: Lennon 

 

Top 11 

Bottom 2 

Lennon 

Jacquie 

 

IS winner: Jacquie 

 

Top 10 

Bottom 3 

Jacquie 

BIAS 

Alexa, just because Niall having four in the semifinal would be to much even for his great coaching

 

IS winner:  

Jacquie (bye, Team Gwen) 

 

Semifinal 

Bottom 4 

Jacquie 

Nini 

Mac 

Noah 

 

IS winner: Noah

 

Top 5 

5th place: Noah 

4th place: Mara 

3rd place: Kaylee 

Runner-up: Ruby 

Winner: Huntley 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Let's do S25. 

 

Team Reba 

PV1: Asher 

PV2: Josh 

CS: L. 

 

Team Chance 

PV1: Maddie 

PV2: Serenity 

CS: Nádege 

 

Team Dan and Shay 

PV1: Karen 

PV2: Madison 

CS: Tae 

 

Team Legend 

PV1: Bryan 

PV2: Nathan 

CS: Zoe 

 

Wildcard 

TR: Jackie 

TC: Kyle 

TDS: Anya 

TL: Mafe 

 

WC winner: it could be anyone except Anya, tbh. Let's say Jackie just because Reba. 

 

Top 13 

Bottom 3 

L. 

Zoe 

Nádege 

 

IS winner: Zoe 

 

Top 11 

Bottom 2 

Zoe 

Tae 

 

IS winner: Tae 

 

Top 10

Bottom 3: 

Tae 

Jackie 

Serenity 

 

IS winner: Jackie 

 

Semifinal 

Bottom 4 

Maddie 

Madison 

Bryan 

Jackie 

 

IS winner: Bryan 

 

The finale would have gone pretty much as it did.

 

 

 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

This will be fun! For S23

Playoffs

Team Blake

PV1: NOIVAS

PV2: Grace

CS: Kylee

 

Team Niall

PV1: Gina

PV2: Ryley

CS: Ross

 

Team Kelly

PV1: D. Smooth

PV2: Holly

CS: Neil

 

Team Chance

PV1: Sorelle

PV2: Kala

CS: Ray

 

Wildcard

Team Blake: Mary Kate

Team Kelly: Cait

Team Chance: Manasseh

Team Niall: Michael B

 

IS Winner: Cait

 

Top 13

Bottom 3

Ray

Kylee

Cait

 

IS Winner: Cait with a big song

 

Top 11

Bottom 2

Cait

Neil

 

IS Winner: Neil

 

Top 10

Bottom 3

Neil

Ross

Holly

 

IS Winner: Holly

 

Top 8

Bottom 4

Holly

Ryley

Kala

NOIVAS

 

IS Winner: NOIVAS

 

Top 5

5th place: NOIVAS

4th place: Sorelle

3rd place: D. Smooth

Runner Up: Grace

Winner: Gina

Link to comment
Share on other sites

S24

 

Playoffs

Team Reba

PV1: Ruby

PV2: Jacquie

CS: Jordan

 

Team Legend

PV1: Kaylee

PV2: Mac

CS: Lila

 

Team Niall

PV1: Huntley

PV2: Nini

CS: Mara

 

Team Gwen

PV1: Kara

PV2: BIAS

CS: Tanner

 

Wildcard

Team Niall: Alexa

Team Legend: Kristen

Team Reba: Noah

Team Gwen: Lennon

 

IS Winner: Noah

 

Top 13

Bottom 3

Tanner

Kara

Jordan

 

IS Winner: Jordan

 

Top 11

Bottom 2

Jordan

Lila

 

IS Winner: Lila

 

Top 10

Bottom 3

Lila

BIAS

Nini

 

IS Winner: Nini

 

Top 8

Bottom 4

Mac

Jacquie

Nini

Noah

 

IS Winner: Jacquie

 

Top 5

5th place: Jacquie

4th place: Mara

3rd place: Ruby

2nd place: Huntley

Winner: Kaylee

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

S25

Playoffs

Team Reba

PV1: Asher

PV2: Josh

CS: L.

 

Team Legend

PV1: Nathan

PV2: Bryan

CS: Zoe

 

Team Dan & Shay

PV1: Karen

PV2: Madison

CS: Tae

 

Team Chance

PV1: Maddi

PV2: Kyle

CS: Nadege

 

Wildcard

Team Reba: Jackie

Team Legend: Mafe

Team Dan & Shay: Anya

Team Chance: Serenity

 

IS Winner: Mafe

 

Top 13

Bottom 3

Nadege

L. 

Zoe

 

IS Winner: L. 

 

Top 11

Bottom 2

L.

Kyle

 

IS Winner: Kyle

 

Top 10

Bottom 3

Kyle

Mafe

Tae

 

IS Winner: Mafe

 

Top 8

Bottom 4

Mafe

Bryan

Madison

Maddi

 

IS Winner: Mafe

 

Top 5

5th place: Mafe

4th place: Karen

3rd place: Nathan

2nd place: Josh

Winner: Asher

Link to comment
Share on other sites

S23

 

Team Blake:

PV1: NOIVAS

PV2: Grace

CS: Mary Kate

WC: Rachel

 

Niall:

PV1: Gina

PV2: Ryley

CS: Ross?

WC: Michael B.

 

Chance:

PV1: Kala

PV2: Sorelle

CS: Ray

WC: Jamar

 

Kelly:

PV1: D.Smooth

PV2: Holly

CS: Neil

WC: Cait

 

WC Winner: Cait

 

Top 13 B3:

Ray, Cait, Mary Kate

Winner: Cait

 

Top 11 B2:

Cait and Ross

Winner: Ross

 

Top 10 B3:

Ross, Kala, Sorelle

Winner: Sorelle, honestly

 

Top 8 B4:

Sorelle, Neil, Holly, Ryley (I wanna say NOIVAS, but I actually think he would’ve been able to get a PV)

Winner: Ryley

 

5th: NOIVAS

4th: Ryley

3rd: D. Smooth

2nd: Gina

1st: Grace 

 

Without the one-vote rule, Grace wins.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Posted (edited)

S24

 

Team Reba:

PV1: Ruby

PV2: Noah

CS: Jordan

WC: Jacquie

 

Team Niall:

PV1: Huntley

PV2: Mara

CS: Nini

WC: Alexa

 

Team Gwen:

PV1: BIAS

PV2: Kara (she would have been able to pull it off after that performance, it was kinda undeniable)

CS: Tanner

WC: Lennon

 

Team Legend:

PV1: Mac

PV2: Kaylee (I’m not as convinced as others are, but sure I’ll go with this)

CS: Lila

WC: Kristen

 

WC winner: Jacquie

 

Top 13 B3:

Kara, Tanner, Jordan

Winner: Jordan

 

Top 11 B2:

Jordan and Lila

(Note: Lila’s placement is so heavily dependent on song choice. She made the finale because of an excellent song choice in the pimp spot. But i’m not convinced that she would have made the finale in a longer format. And she’s not the type of contestant to do well in an IS.)

Winner: Jordan

 

Top 10 B3:

Jordan, Jacquie, BIAS

Winner: Jacquie

 

Top 8 B4:

Jacquie, Nini, Mac, Kaylee

Winner: Kaylee

 

5th: Kaylee (she was not beating Huntley or Ruby, sorry)

4th: Mara

3rd: Noah

2nd: Ruby

1st: Huntley

 

Edited by MusicBuff101
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Posted (edited)

S25

 

Team Reba:

PV1: Asher

PV2: Josh

CS: L.

WC: Jackie

 

Team Chance:

PV1: Maddi

PV2: Serenity

CS: Nadege

WC: Kyle

 

Team D + S

PV1: Karen

PV2: Madison

CS: Tae

WC: Anya

 

Team Legend

PV1: Nathan

PV2: Bryan

CS: Zoe

WC: Mafe

 

WC Winner: Close between Mafe and Jackie, but I’m going Jackie

 

Top 13 B3:

L., Zoe, Nadege

Winner: Zoe

 

Top 11 B2:

Zoe and Jackie

Winner: Jackie

 

Top 10 B3:

Jackie, Serenity, Tae

Winner: Tae

 

Top 8 B4:

Tae, Maddi, Bryan, Madison

Winner: Bryan

 

Assuming, song choices and performance orders are the same, the results would have played out exactly as they did.

 

Ultimately, there would have been very little difference to the actual results, other than Jackie or Mafe making it a little bit further.

Edited by MusicBuff101
  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...