QueenMae16 Posted June 6 Share Posted June 6 Don't remember seeing this, but have fun discussing how this could have gone. S23, S24, S25 as S21/S22 formats. If the recent seasons had more weeks of lives and of course voting in the Playoffs, how differently do you think it could have gone? Would Winners and Finalists be different? Who would rise and fall with more time to showcase themselves? Go crazy tbh. 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Gustavo527 Posted June 6 Share Posted June 6 S23 Playoffs Team Blake PV1: Grace PV2: NOIVAS PV3: Mary Kate Team Niall PV1: Gina PV2: Ryley CS: Ross Team Chance PV1: Kala PV2: Sorelle CS: Ray Team Kelly PV1: D. Smooth PV2: Holly CS: Honestly, no idea here. Cait?? Just for more fun, Wildcard TB: Rachel TN: Michael TC: Jamar TK: Neil IS winner: Neil Top 13: Bottom 3 Ray (duh) Cait (just not audience bait) Mary Kate (she would have most likely flopped) IS winner: Cait (pimp spot with big song) Top 11 Bottom 2 Cait Sorelle IS winner: Sorelle (*insert meltdowns*) Top 10 Bottom 3 Sorelle Ross (*insert bus here*) Kala IS winner: Kala Top 8 (this is hard) Bottom 4 Kala D. Smooth (his modern R&B style is way to unconventional for the viewers, so i assume i a normal PV he loses to Holly) Ryley (assuming Gina would have still had her breakout moment with Wicked Game, which would have carried her to the finale, plus Ryley is just more inexperienced, remember he flopped with "Vienna") I want to say NOIVAS but idk if Blake voters would have carried him over Neil. Let's say that unfortunately yes, they would have, so Neil IS winner: Neil Top 5 5th place: NOIVAS (he would have flopped as hard as he actually did, so 5th easily 4th place: Neil 3rd place: Holly 2nd place: Grace Winner: Gina, assuming she still had her finale pimp spot with Nothing Compares 2 U in this scenary 1 2 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Gustavo527 Posted June 7 Share Posted June 7 That was fun, let's do S24 Team Reba PV1: Ruby PV2: Noah CS: Jacquie Team Niall PV1: Huntley PV2: Mara CS: Nini Team Gwen PV1: Lennon PV2: i don't remember how hard BIAS flopped, tbh. But he is a country male so him CS: I want to think Gwen wouldn't have given it to Tanner, but nah, let's be realistic, him. Team Legend PV1: Kaylee PV2: Mac CS: Lila?? Let's say Lila Wildcard TR: Jordan TN: Alexa TG: Rudi TL: Kristen WC winner: Alexa Top 13 Bottom 3 Tanner Lennon Lila (Yep, in this scenary she is not a finalist) IS winner: Lennon Top 11 Bottom 2 Lennon Jacquie IS winner: Jacquie Top 10 Bottom 3 Jacquie BIAS Alexa, just because Niall having four in the semifinal would be to much even for his great coaching IS winner: Jacquie (bye, Team Gwen) Semifinal Bottom 4 Jacquie Nini Mac Noah IS winner: Noah Top 5 5th place: Noah 4th place: Mara 3rd place: Kaylee Runner-up: Ruby Winner: Huntley 2 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Gustavo527 Posted June 7 Share Posted June 7 Let's do S25. Team Reba PV1: Asher PV2: Josh CS: L. Team Chance PV1: Maddie PV2: Serenity CS: Nádege Team Dan and Shay PV1: Karen PV2: Madison CS: Tae Team Legend PV1: Bryan PV2: Nathan CS: Zoe Wildcard TR: Jackie TC: Kyle TDS: Anya TL: Mafe WC winner: it could be anyone except Anya, tbh. Let's say Jackie just because Reba. Top 13 Bottom 3 L. Zoe Nádege IS winner: Zoe Top 11 Bottom 2 Zoe Tae IS winner: Tae Top 10 Bottom 3: Tae Jackie Serenity IS winner: Jackie Semifinal Bottom 4 Maddie Madison Bryan Jackie IS winner: Bryan The finale would have gone pretty much as it did. 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Persy Posted June 7 Share Posted June 7 This will be fun! For S23 Playoffs Team Blake PV1: NOIVAS PV2: Grace CS: Kylee Team Niall PV1: Gina PV2: Ryley CS: Ross Team Kelly PV1: D. Smooth PV2: Holly CS: Neil Team Chance PV1: Sorelle PV2: Kala CS: Ray Wildcard Team Blake: Mary Kate Team Kelly: Cait Team Chance: Manasseh Team Niall: Michael B IS Winner: Cait Top 13 Bottom 3 Ray Kylee Cait IS Winner: Cait with a big song Top 11 Bottom 2 Cait Neil IS Winner: Neil Top 10 Bottom 3 Neil Ross Holly IS Winner: Holly Top 8 Bottom 4 Holly Ryley Kala NOIVAS IS Winner: NOIVAS Top 5 5th place: NOIVAS 4th place: Sorelle 3rd place: D. Smooth Runner Up: Grace Winner: Gina Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Persy Posted June 7 Share Posted June 7 S24 Playoffs Team Reba PV1: Ruby PV2: Jacquie CS: Jordan Team Legend PV1: Kaylee PV2: Mac CS: Lila Team Niall PV1: Huntley PV2: Nini CS: Mara Team Gwen PV1: Kara PV2: BIAS CS: Tanner Wildcard Team Niall: Alexa Team Legend: Kristen Team Reba: Noah Team Gwen: Lennon IS Winner: Noah Top 13 Bottom 3 Tanner Kara Jordan IS Winner: Jordan Top 11 Bottom 2 Jordan Lila IS Winner: Lila Top 10 Bottom 3 Lila BIAS Nini IS Winner: Nini Top 8 Bottom 4 Mac Jacquie Nini Noah IS Winner: Jacquie Top 5 5th place: Jacquie 4th place: Mara 3rd place: Ruby 2nd place: Huntley Winner: Kaylee 2 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Persy Posted June 7 Share Posted June 7 S25 Playoffs Team Reba PV1: Asher PV2: Josh CS: L. Team Legend PV1: Nathan PV2: Bryan CS: Zoe Team Dan & Shay PV1: Karen PV2: Madison CS: Tae Team Chance PV1: Maddi PV2: Kyle CS: Nadege Wildcard Team Reba: Jackie Team Legend: Mafe Team Dan & Shay: Anya Team Chance: Serenity IS Winner: Mafe Top 13 Bottom 3 Nadege L. Zoe IS Winner: L. Top 11 Bottom 2 L. Kyle IS Winner: Kyle Top 10 Bottom 3 Kyle Mafe Tae IS Winner: Mafe Top 8 Bottom 4 Mafe Bryan Madison Maddi IS Winner: Mafe Top 5 5th place: Mafe 4th place: Karen 3rd place: Nathan 2nd place: Josh Winner: Asher Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MusicBuff101 Posted June 7 Share Posted June 7 S23 Team Blake: PV1: NOIVAS PV2: Grace CS: Mary Kate WC: Rachel Niall: PV1: Gina PV2: Ryley CS: Ross? WC: Michael B. Chance: PV1: Kala PV2: Sorelle CS: Ray WC: Jamar Kelly: PV1: D.Smooth PV2: Holly CS: Neil WC: Cait WC Winner: Cait Top 13 B3: Ray, Cait, Mary Kate Winner: Cait Top 11 B2: Cait and Ross Winner: Ross Top 10 B3: Ross, Kala, Sorelle Winner: Sorelle, honestly Top 8 B4: Sorelle, Neil, Holly, Ryley (I wanna say NOIVAS, but I actually think he would’ve been able to get a PV) Winner: Ryley 5th: NOIVAS 4th: Ryley 3rd: D. Smooth 2nd: Gina 1st: Grace Without the one-vote rule, Grace wins. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MusicBuff101 Posted June 7 Share Posted June 7 (edited) S24 Team Reba: PV1: Ruby PV2: Noah CS: Jordan WC: Jacquie Team Niall: PV1: Huntley PV2: Mara CS: Nini WC: Alexa Team Gwen: PV1: BIAS PV2: Kara (she would have been able to pull it off after that performance, it was kinda undeniable) CS: Tanner WC: Lennon Team Legend: PV1: Mac PV2: Kaylee (I’m not as convinced as others are, but sure I’ll go with this) CS: Lila WC: Kristen WC winner: Jacquie Top 13 B3: Kara, Tanner, Jordan Winner: Jordan Top 11 B2: Jordan and Lila (Note: Lila’s placement is so heavily dependent on song choice. She made the finale because of an excellent song choice in the pimp spot. But i’m not convinced that she would have made the finale in a longer format. And she’s not the type of contestant to do well in an IS.) Winner: Jordan Top 10 B3: Jordan, Jacquie, BIAS Winner: Jacquie Top 8 B4: Jacquie, Nini, Mac, Kaylee Winner: Kaylee 5th: Kaylee (she was not beating Huntley or Ruby, sorry) 4th: Mara 3rd: Noah 2nd: Ruby 1st: Huntley Edited June 7 by MusicBuff101 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MusicBuff101 Posted June 7 Share Posted June 7 (edited) S25 Team Reba: PV1: Asher PV2: Josh CS: L. WC: Jackie Team Chance: PV1: Maddi PV2: Serenity CS: Nadege WC: Kyle Team D + S PV1: Karen PV2: Madison CS: Tae WC: Anya Team Legend PV1: Nathan PV2: Bryan CS: Zoe WC: Mafe WC Winner: Close between Mafe and Jackie, but I’m going Jackie Top 13 B3: L., Zoe, Nadege Winner: Zoe Top 11 B2: Zoe and Jackie Winner: Jackie Top 10 B3: Jackie, Serenity, Tae Winner: Tae Top 8 B4: Tae, Maddi, Bryan, Madison Winner: Bryan Assuming, song choices and performance orders are the same, the results would have played out exactly as they did. Ultimately, there would have been very little difference to the actual results, other than Jackie or Mafe making it a little bit further. Edited June 7 by MusicBuff101 2 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Kitty Sammy 463 Posted July 8 Share Posted July 8 (edited) S23 Live Playoffs Team Blake America saves Grace West and NOIVAS. Blake chooses Mary Kate Connor to move forward as well. Team Chance America saves Sorelle and Kala Banham. Chance chooses Ray Uriel (I know, I don’t like him either, but he’s who Chance would choose.) to move forward as well. Team Kelly America saves Holly Brand and D. Smooth. Kelly chooses ALI to move forward as well. Team Niall America saves Gina Miles and Ryley Tate Wilson. Niall chooses Michael B. to move forward as well. Wildcards: Rachel Christine Manasseh Samone Cait Martin Tasha Jessen Winner: Cait Top 13 Bottom 3: Ray Uriel Michael B. Mary Kate Connor Winner: Mary Kate Top 11 Bottom 2 Mary Kate Connor Cait Martin Winner: Cait Top 10 Bottom 3: Cait Martin ALI NOIVAS Winner: NOIVAS Top 8: Bottom 4: NOIVAS Holly Brand Ryley Tate Wilson Kala Banham Winner: NOIVAS Finale 5th Place: NOIVAS 4th Place: Sorelle 3rd Place: D. Smooth 2nd Place: Grace West Winner: Gina Miles Note: I would have had Gina, Sorelle, Cait, ALI, and NOIVAS as my Final 5, but I just stuck with the actual 5. Kala and Holly would have been my backup Finalists. Edited July 9 by Kitty Sammy 463 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Kitty Sammy 463 Posted July 28 Share Posted July 28 (edited) Season 24 Live Playoffs Team Niall America saves Huntley and Alexa Wildish. Niall chooses Mara Justine to move forward as well. Team Reba America saves Ruby Leigh and Jacquie Roar. Reba chooses Jordan Rainer to move forward as well. Team Gwen America saves Kara Tenae and Rudi. Gwen chooses BIAS to move forward as well. Team Legend America saves Lila Forde and Kaylee Shimizu. John chooses Mac Royals to move forward as well. Wildcards Nini Iris Noah Spencer (I would’ve chosen Ms. Monet, though.) Lennon VanderDoes Kristen Brown (I would’ve chosen Taylor Deneen, though.) Winner: Nini Iris Top 13 Bottom 3 BIAS Jordan Rainer Mac Royals Winner: Mac Royals Top 11 Bottom 2 Kara Tenae Mac Royals Winner: Mac Royals Top 10 Bottom 3 Mac Royals Rudi Alexa Wildish Winner: (I wish there could be 2) Rudi Top 8 Bottom 4 Rudi Nini Iris Jacquie Roar Kaylee Shimizu Winner: Kaylee Shimizu Finale 5th Place: Lila Forde 4th Place: Mara Justine 3rd Place: Kaylee Shimizu 2nd Place: Ruby Leigh WINNER: Huntley I had a hard time doing this because I knew that both the coaches and America would make choices I disagree with. My actual final 5 would be Ruby, Lila, Nini, Kaylee, and either Mara or Kara. Probably Kara. Edited August 13 by Kitty Sammy 463 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Kitty Sammy 463 Posted August 13 Share Posted August 13 (edited) Season 25 Live Playoffs Team Dan + Shay America chooses Madison Curbelo and Tae Lewis to advance. Dan + Shay choose Karen Waldrup to advance as well. Team Legend America chooses Zoe Levert and Bryan Olesen to advance. John chooses Nathan Chester to advance as well. Team Reba America chooses Asher HaVon and L. Rodgers to advance. Reba chooses Josh Sanders to advance as well. Team Chance America chooses Maddi Jane and Serenity Arce to advance Chance chooses Nadège to advance as well. Wildcards: Anya True Mafe Jackie Romeo Kyle Schuesler Winner: Mafe Top 13 Bottom 3 Zoe Levert Nadège L. Rodgers Winner: Nadège Top 11 Bottom 2 Nadège Tae Lewis Winner: Tae Top 10 Bottom 3 Tae Lewis Mafe Serenity Arce Winner: Serenity (This would be unlikely to happen, but since she got a higher place than Tae and Mafe, I put her in.) Top 8 Bottom 4 Maddi Jane Serenity Arce Madison Curbelo Bryan Olesen Winner: Bryan Finale 5th Place: Karen Waldrup 4th Place: Nathan Chester 3rd Place: Bryan Olesen 2nd Place: Josh Sanders WINNER: Asher HaVon The Live Playoffs Wildcard Winner was tricky because I would have probably voted for all three girls. My actual final five would be Madison, Bryan, Asher, Maddi, and Serenity. Edited August 13 by Kitty Sammy 463 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now