American Idol S22 Judge's Song Contest Discussion

[rockerannah]

Emmy brought me to tears.

[NGL2008]

15 hours ago, Anythingcanhappen said:

Thoughts:

 

KB shoulda picked take a bow. I don’t think it would have saved her from b2 necessarily, but a better performance to go out on if she had to go. I don’t think she should have gone though but this is the reality of this stage of the comp

 

Triston is a subpar singer. I just don’t get it. Will is boring but at least he can sing on key… 

 

Abi killed it. She’s been consistent throughout her run. I wish they’d stop doing platinum tickets because it creates too much pressure to “live up to the hype” 

 

Julia’s SOTR was gorgeous! I wasn’t a fan of her in the earlier rounds but man. She is good. There really are some shades of Adele and Kelly in her tone

 

Jack is giving Phillip Phillips and could win. He needs to keep being strategic to pull it off tho. I wouldn’t be mad at a Jack win.

Man, I'm thinking this word for word. Except I always liked Julia.

[ShortstopVM]

Since I didn't see a "Rank the Performances" thread for Top 8, I'll just leave this here:

 

1. Abi

2. Emmy

3. Julia

4. KB

5. Jack

6. Will

 

7. Triston

8. McKenna

 

 

Duets:

1. Triston/Will

2. Abi/Julia/McKenna/KB

3. Emmy/Jack