Rainbow_of_greys

And yet Carly Smithson went home this week....... that pains me to even think about.

I wish idol would just release the voting order every week, or at least give hints about the placements. Idk why they don’t.

I wish Nicolina could sneak in there somehow lol

Fr, I hate this. Gotta wait til mjsbigblog or kingtalenthd upload them (non HD) and then they get 1k views and next to no comments. I always love reading the comments on my favs.

The fact that in the fox era, someone could be completely safe one week (not in B3) and then the lowest vote-getter the next makes me think anything is possible with certain contestants lol. The only people who I’d 100% bet won’t go anywhere before top 5/3 are Noah and HG

Idk, other than Dan the eliminations tonight made sense based on that order. But IA with the poster above who was saying it’s unlikely that a producer would just leak results like that

Season 9 was horrible omfg. Like really really bad. The only person I liked other than crystal was didi benami and she was what 10th?

That person was never gonna win IMO. It’s gonna come down to #1 and #2 (and always was). Those two would have to reallyyyyy mess up not to make the finale IMO.

I was thinking today how cool it would be to have a Canadian winner, and how maybe it would open idol/TPTB up to doing a Toronto audition stop next year/moving forward. We deserve something here in Canada, we really don’t have any singing shows people can easily try out for lol. Plus Nicolina is a queen and deserves the W (I know Noah and Hunter will be impossible to beat but I can dream of a Nicolina win!)

Fr! People are getting so heated over her. Relevant queen

She can play guitar, there are videos online of her doing that lol. Idk why she didn’t on the show. I do agree that she wasn’t ready. But that doesn’t discount the fact that people were probably hating on her because she was beautiful and had a “famous”/well off family. Reddit comes to mind, they dragged her every week and the hate was so OTT and it was obvious that it went far beyond the fact that she wasn’t performing that well. on another note... I would love to see Nicolina sing some Celine this week. She has a tiktok of herself doing “it’s all coming back to me now” and she sounds fantastic.

hot take but Cadence has the Kat McPhee effect. People hate her because she’s beautiful. that’s what I choose to believe queen Cadence supremacy

I fvkng WISH.

He’s ridiculously handsome.

She’s also young, gorgeous and has an actual country accent. She’d have a shot for sure lol

Thank you for putting into words what I was trying to express. (also, her audition proves that she absolutely CAN sing whitney.......if she switches it up and puts an acoustic/countrypop twang to it.)

Yes.

Nicolina holding her own with only the country ppl above her, yes queen

singing starts at 0:48 Her voice is better suited to country IMO.

It pains me to think how far Cadence could (would) have gotten if she’d gone the country route.

Slay. She needs to do country. Anything else of note? Hope she’s doing well

Cardin supremacy

Omg finally someone who remembers Cardin! She is still just as beautiful all these years later too https://www.instagram.com/p/CXHrFVBLFIo/?igshid=YmMyMTA2M2Y=

HunterGirl is unoriginal and not marketable. I can think of many country singers who have been on idol before her who were way better but had way less hype. Skylar Laine from S11 comes to mind. She’s gonna be a massive flop winner if she ends up winning. Lady K had my second favourite audition of the season but hasn’t impressed me since. Cadence had the best Hawaii performance over everyone in the top 24 and it’s very underrated. Jay is terrible. I don’t get the Fritz hype but I can see why people like him. Nicolina IS that good. And I think people forget she’s only 18. If she was in her early 20s (give her a few more years to develop vocally) she would be a BEAST. That’s all for now.

This. He’s out to lunch also what was he rambling on about with Cadence after her “train wreck” performance? Something about grabbing the mic and taking it out? It seemed like he wanted to tell her he didn’t like it but since these judges aren’t allowed to actually critique, he said something stupid about leaving the mic in the stand instead. Garbage.