nigelsimon

Forgot to mention country star Lainey Wilson was turned down 7 times on Idol. Someone should comprise a list of "Idol rejects" (didn't make it far at all) that became stars. I'm really interested to see that comprehensive list. I mean, I could try. Just unsure where the cut off should be. Top 24? 36? Top 12? Top 10?

I recall reading a blog on tumblr a long time ago (season 12 or 13?) from a singer that got a ticket to Hollywood. They said a bunch of singers got standing ovations (Hollywood week, round not mentioned?) from the judges & the crowd. However, watching the show when it aired, they said they were surprised those people didn't/barely got shown on TV. I don't think that type of stuff is made up. People have seen a partial list of famous singers that were rejected from Idol; Colbie Caillat, Bebe Rexha, Hillary Scott, & Maren Morris didn't even get a ticket to go to Hollywood. While I don't think the producers have the top 12-24 set on a piece of paper. I do think they have a general idea who they want to cast on the season. Idol winners Candice Glover & Caleb Johnson auditioned multiple times. They weren't shown very much besides the season they won i believe (correct me if i'm wrong). Haley Reinhart auditioned twice (maybe 3 times?). I might have seen her face on season 9, but no name or singing that I can remember besides S10 of course. Pia Toscano said she auditioned 4 times, but I recall only seeing her face on season 10. In conclusion, there's a lot of talent in Hollywood week & beyond lol. I'm glad some singers that get rejected/shafted by Idol push even harder to pursue their dreams. However, not everyone's the same. I can imagine some being so discouraged being rejected &/or barely shown that one who gives up trying to break into this tough industry.

Great news for her! It's really tough for pop girls to make it far on Idol w/ that sexy beautiful fierce look. The main demo much prefers that wholesome girl next door look. I'm glad that Idol disappointment didn't discourage her dreams at all.

Never heard of Benson until recently. I'm usually at least a yr behind in knowing who the hot rising star names are in the industry, especially the guys. His name popped up a number of times in Idol discussion on reddit so i've checked him out. I was quite impressed by his audition. The backstory of a good looking athletic/jock type growing up & all of the sudden falling in love w/ singing is not an uncommon one on American Idol type shows. They usually have nice pleasant voices, but nothing special so they get cut in Hollywood week. Benson definitely stands out from that lot. He does have a distinct voice & his phasing is quite unique. He really felt his audition song so I do believe he would've connected w/ the Idol audience easily. I would say in most Idol seasons he would come in no worse than 3rd & in at least half of Idol's history (of seasons), I could see him winning it all. Sometimes, in these types of shows, they don't stack "the best" talent in one season. So, if the judges/producers really believe they've found a star, they would "reserve" some singers for future seasons. The mature sounding, polished male country singer might be his biggest competitor. Kennedi Anderson- I think her placement is not as clear cut as Benson. It will fluctuate quite a bit depending on the cast. Kennedi definitely has great qualities to appeal to the Idol public; Big voice, pretty, but not that model unapproachable type, nice smile, seems like a nice humble young girl. She definitely had potential to grow on the show, but from her Idol performances i've seen, it's not quite there in the connection department. Some of her body movements & facial expressions seem a bit planned. Mentor Bebe Rexha mention eye contact w/ Kennedi & I agree that definitely needed improvement. I remember Carrie had very good eye contract w/ the camera when she was on Idol a million yrs ago. With all that being said, if the judges/producers felt she was "IT" & they cast a good, but not great group girls, then maybe 3rd at best. I just don't think she's polished enough to win. If the overall cast is stacked, anywhere between 7th-5th place is my guess.

You seem like a level headed fan. Continue being a big Abi fan & keep supporting her. Just don't ever become one of those fans that think other's opinions are wrong. Probably back in the day there were people that didn't like Whitney, Mariah, or Celine; And today, there's plenty of people that don't like Adele, Ariana, or T.Swift.

I think this is reasonable expectations for Abi. I'm reading general Idol topics on Reddit & some people are REALLY passionate about Abi. Fans saying she has one of the best Idol voices ever & she'll be as big as (or 3rd behind) Kelly Clarkson & Carrie is a bit rich. As someone who is just recently catching up w/ her performances, I think Abi is a great singer. However, I'm not quite connected w/ her emotionally as I expected given the sizable buzz around her. I have not watched her backstory or searched for it; Only stumbling on bits & pieces of it. Watching it certainly could influence my emotions. Rewatching dance show performances w/ backstory & their journey did change my emotions before. Just watching Abi's performances, I just get this Disney princess feel about it. Nothing wrong that style; Just doesn't scream hip relevant recording artist to me. I see Abi having a career similar to Idina Menzel; Some Broadway, part recording artist, some singing in commercials, & tv/movie soundtracks/background. If Abi was on season 11 (perhaps even 12?) or earlier, I think she'll be as successful as a recording artist as Jordin Sparks. However, in season 22 w/ around 6 million viewers, this would be tough. Regardless, Abi will have a very solid career in the industry.

Hey m1key. That's a name I remember from old IDF days. Good to hear from ya. Here's some of my thoughts on your insightful summary: -You have season 18 as the worst in the ABC era huh? I guess I picked the wrong season to give Idol a chance then. Season 18 was the one I watched the most early on. Lauren Spencer-Smith was my favorite from auditions & her elimination was pretty much the nail in the coffin. It wasn't a shocking elimination & I saw it coming based on her song choice. It was just so disappointing to see yet another promising young pop singer not knowing how to play "the singing competition game". I did also like Makayla Phillips. However, given that Lauren was cut so early & I thought she would really appeal to the Idol demo w/ her tone, big voice, sweet smile, & overall likeability, I gave up on Makayla & the rest of that season. -Season 19- I heard that Arthur Gunn was brought back for season 19 after coming in 2nd the previous season. I thought this was a terrible look. This just defeats the purpose of the show for me. This isn't Big Brother or one of Gordon Ramsay's cooking shows. Arthur had many weeks to showcase himself the prior season. If he hasn't gotten signed or hit it big from that, that's just tough. It was actually unfair even to have him in the pool of candidates given how far he made it the previous season.

In a few words (or more) describe each of the seasons of ABC's American Idol (16-22). Rate them too if you like (1-10 scale). Example from a random season of Fox's AI: Season 7- Likable cast w/ diverse genres; Each w/ different looks & personalities. Hard to mistake one for another. The cast lacks a relevant, hip female pop singer, but still a very enjoyable & entertaining season. Easily in my top 3 favorite Idol seasons. Rating -9-

I respect male singers. I just prefer female voices much much more. Most of the time, if i really like a song & it's sung by the original male recording artist, that male version is usually good enough for me.

Ah, 'ptebwwong'. That's a familiar name from old IDF days. Good to hear from ya. I wasn't sure what the elimination method were at that stage. If the lowest vote getters were automatically cut & the judges had no say, I can understand why she was sent home early. Having a loyal fanbase is important in these shows. The teen girl/young girl vote is not the strongest, but it's substantial. I can see girl voters not connecting w/ Ava; Her look, voice, & styling is so much older than 15. Moving on from Idol, i believe she'll do fine.

Very good voice, polished, but lacking that extra special something that sets them apart. Most singers in the top 24ish on these type of shows will fit into this category. I'm surprised she was runner-up.

Season 1- Can't remember that season Season 2- Charlotte Sometimes, Lindsey Pavao Season 3- Cassadee Pope- very good voice, looks like a star. Season 4- Savannah Berry- felt her heart when she sang. Season 5- Holly Henry- ethereal, haunting voice; Caroline Pennell- sweet, unique yet natural voice. Season 6- Christina Grimmie- one of my fav YT cover singers before the Voice; Passion, heart, head voice. Season 7- Luke Wade- unique cool voice. Season 8- Brooke Adee- stunning beauty, very nice voice. ---- *Season 9 to 25- is based on light research & partial playback (work in progress). * Season 9- ? Season 10- Lacy Mandigo- great name Season 11- ? Season 12- ? Season 13-? Season 14- Brynn Cartelli- Pretty eyes, pretty voice; *Not a fan of her new blonde hair tho. She looked like a star on the show, but now looks like common girl USA. Season 15- Chevel Shepherd (placeholder for now) Season 16- Maelyn Jarmon- (placeholder for now) Season 17- ? Not Ricky Braddy for sure; That's the only name that rings a bell because he was on Idol season 8 semi-finals round. Season 18- ? Season 19- Cami Clune- (placeholder for now) Season 20-? Season 21- Girl named Tom- (placeholder for now). Not Jeremy Rosado for sure. I remember his name from an early season of Idol. Season 22- ? Season 23- ? Season 24- ? Season 25- ?

She's very good. I'm surprised she won though. She doesn't feel like the type of artist that wins these type of shows or gets pimped.

Ah, thank you for this! Jaclyn has a really lovely cover of "Fix you". It's not quite FIRE, but it is sizzling. I'll replace Youtuber Lucy's version w/ Jaclyn's. She also performed "Thinking out loud" on the show, but it was a duet. No offense to the guy she was singing w/, as he's.... a lovely singer as well. However, I do prefer that song to be sung as a solo.

mistake