joe14

1. Abi 2. Will 3. Jack

The way no one on this season has stage presence. Where is We Ani when you need her.

Her stance when she bends so far forward is so awkward to look at. I've noticed it will all of her uptempo songs. I guess she is still figuring out the stage presence thing. It was okay. Song has been done a million times and I won't remember this version by tomorrow.

Lmao not y'all coming at the judges for actualizing *gasp* judging – especially since everyone complains about how the blow smoke up everyone's ***. Y'all are funny on here.

Go Will...give us nothing!

Cringy movements but the vocals are good.

Meh...I could barely hear her in parts

A top 5 hit that had no longevity so definitely an underperformance for her. Her popularity was not translating to actually sales in 2017 and her career has never really recovered since then. I'm just saying Taylor Swift, Lady Gaga, and Adele are at much bigger and better place in there career compared to Katy Perry in 2017 so using her signing as an example or supporting evidence doesn't really make sense tbh. It's kind of delusional to think that any of those people would join the show. Add in the fact that the popularity, novelty, and ratings for Idol has decreased overtime. Idol was for all intents and purposes a new show back in 2017.

Lol let's not rewrite history. Katy had pretty much fallen off by this point. The last full length album she released before she was announced as a judge was in 2013. She released Rise and Chained to the Rhythm which both underperformed compared to her earlier singles and then Bon Appetit which pretty much flopped. Top artists in the world would not be entertaining a show like Idol.

1. Abi 2. Jack 3. Will 4. Emmy 5. Triston

Eh – She has tougher songs tbh. I feel like the performances of it I've seen on these shows have been fine (none have been remarkable). I feel like if you are a decent belter, you could probably get through the song fine. Now Easy on Me...good luck Triston.

There is 3 judges. From what I hear, I don't think she is missing out. It sounds a mess already, now imagine adding Emmy to the mix.

That was amazing. She handled that song much better than I thought she would (apart of that was she kept in her comfort range which was smart) I remember thinking my immortal > bring me to life a couple weeks ago, but my immortal would have just been similar to the performances she has already been doing. This allowed her to show a different side of herself.

It was hard to follow that song. Felt like three separate songs in one. Idk...

Lol she is always shouty. She need Shania to reign her in again. It was the perfect song on paper, but the execution was very meh.