Jump to content

S17 Top 4 Performance Rankings: Detailed Progress Report!

dirActing

By dirActing
in The Voice

 Share

Recommended Posts

dirActing  

dirActing

Posted
Posted

We didn't get a "Road to the Lives" type episode this season. Nobody likes those, except me! :haha: Actually, while I personally appreciate a recap of the journey so far, I do agree it's a waste of episode space in the context of a broadcast season. Much rather we get more performances in full, rather than filler. I have thought, however, that they could or should produce a concise digital version of the recap episode, maybe one for before the playoffs, and another before the finale, and post those online to drum up interest among casuals. Anyway, since they didn't do that obviously, here's my own of sorts! :D

 

The purpose is mainly for fun. The finale is Monday, so if you want to review or relive the season, every video featuring the Top 4 this season (minus group performances, because those generally suck, imho) can be found here, conveniently under one thread. They can be found below, immediately following this post. So watch them all this weekend, watch just the ones you want, or none. Click, or don't click, but before that, here's a Top 4 progress report of sorts. I tend to view the show as part reality competition, part music performance based entertainment. My interest is more with the latter. The focus here is on performances. The data is not predictive, since performances are subjective, and many don't even vote so much based on performance, are tone deaf, etc. The data is organized to help gauge the performance progress of the Top 4, who's peaking or has peaked, etc., but take it any way you want...

 

Top 4 Ranked by Average Score (Based on YouTube Performance Videos)

 

1. Rose Short 98.02% (avg. of all 10 performances incl. the Top 8 IS and duet w/Katie.)

2. Ricky Duran 97.61% (avg. of all 9 performances incl. the Top 8 duet w/Will.)

3. Katie Kadan 97.49% (avg. of 8 performance incl. the Top 8 duet w/Rose, **KO video with Max Boyle omitted from avg. W/Max = 97.58% avg.)

4. Jake Hoot 97.32% (avg. of all 9 performances incl. the Top 8 duet w/MaryBeth.)

 

Top 4 Ranked by Average Views (Based on YouTube Performance Videos)

 

1. Katie Kadan 904,682.63 (views per video, **KO video with Max Boyle omitted from avg.)

2. Rose Short 596,148.38 (views per video, *Top 11 geo-locked video omitted from avg.)

3. Ricky Duran 430,602.88 (views per video, *Top 11 geo-locked video omitted from avg.)

4. Jake Hoot 333,612.75 (views per video, *Top 11 geo-locked video omitted from avg.)

 

Top 4 Solo Performances Ranked by Scores/(Views), Top 15:

 

1. Rose Short – Knockouts (11/04/19): "Big White Room" 99.10% (703,003)

2. Ricky Duran – Blinds (10/07/19): "River" 98.64% (1,492,922)

3. Jake Hoot – Knockouts (10/29/19): "Cover Me Up" 98.64% (594,931)

4. Ricky Duran – Top 8 Solo (12/09/19): "Let It Be" 98.61% (177,062)

5. Rose Short – Top 8 Save (12/10/19): "(You Make Me Feel Like) a Natural Woman" 98.50 (122,088)

6. Rose Short – Top 13 (11/18/19): "I Turn to You" 98.37% (251,867)

7. Katie Kadan – Blinds (09/20/19): "Baby I Love You" 98.23% (2,465,150)

8. Rose Short – Blinds (09/23/19): "Preach" 98.15% (1,541,240)

9. Rose Short – Top 11 (11/25/19): "Maybe I'm Amazed" 98.12% (169,626*)

10. Ricky Duran – Top 13 (11/18/19): "You Are the Best Thing" 98.03% (195,216)

11. Rose Short – Top 8 Solo (12/09/19): "I Want To Know What Love Is" 97.88% (371,747)

12. Ricky Duran – Top 10 (12/02/19): "Born Under a Bad Sign" 97.87% (165,369)

13. Jake Hoot – Blinds (10/07/19): "When It Rains It Pours" 97.60% (777,726)

14. Katie Kadan – Top 13 (11/18/19): "I'm Going Down" 97.60% (523,545)

15. Rose Short – Top 20 (11/11/19): "What Have You Done for Me Lately?" 97.60% (225,818)

 

Top 4 Collaborations (Duets/Battles) Ranked by Scores/(Views), Top 5:

 

1. Katie Kadan & Rose Short – Top 8 Duet (12/09/19): "Express Yourself" 98.37% (181,688)

2. Jake Hoot (vs. Steve Knill) – Battles (10/18/19): "Always on My Mind" 98.25% (507,185)

3. Katie Kadan (vs. Destiny Rayne) – Battles (10/18/19): "Tiny Dancer" 98.22% (1,824,490)

4. Ricky Duran (& Will Breman) – Top 8 Duet (12/09/19): "Your Love" 97.88% (81,351)

5. Jake Hoot (& MaryBeth Byrd) – Top 8 Duet (12/09/19): "Up Where We Belong" 97.63% (75,730)

 

Blind Auditions Ranked:

 

1. Ricky Duran – "River" 98.64%

2. Katie Kadan – "Baby I Love You" 98.23%

3. Rose Short – "Preach" 98.15%

4. Jake Hoot – "When It Rains It Pours" 97.60%

 

Battle Round Ranked:

 

1. Jake Hoot (vs. Steve Knill) – "Always on My Mind" 98.25%

2. Katie Kadan (vs. Destiny Rayne) – "Tiny Dancer" 98.22%

3. Ricky Duran (vs. Marina Chello) – "Valerie" 97.35%

4. Rose Short (vs. Jessie Lawrence) – "Can't Feel my Face" 97.13%

 

Knockout Round Ranked:

 

1. Rose Short – "Big White Room" 99.10%

2. Jake Hoot – "Cover Me Up" 98.64%

3. Katie Kadan – "Piece of my Heart" 98.27%**

4. Ricky Duran – "She Talks to Angels" 97.02%

 

Top 20 Playoffs Ranked:

 

1. Rose Short – "What Have You Done for Me Lately?" 97.60%

2. Katie Kadan – "Always Remember Us This Way" 97.31%

3. Jake Hoot – "You Lie" 96.87%

4. Ricky Duran – "Small Town" 96.62%

 

Top 13 Round Ranked:

 

1. Rose Short – "I Turn to You" 98.37%

2. Ricky Duran – "You Are the Best Thing" 98.03%

3. Katie Kadan – "I'm Going Down" 97.60%

4. Jake Hoot – "Danny's Song" 96.61%

 

Top 11 Round Ranked:

 

1. Rose Short – "Maybe I'm Amazed" 98.12%

2. Katie Kadan – "Without You" 97.37%

3. Jake Hoot – "Every Light in the House" 97.10%

4. Ricky Duran – "Downtown Train" 96.48%

 

Top 10 Round Ranked:

 

1. Ricky Duran – "Born Under a Bad Sign" 97.87%

2. Rose Short – "God's Country" 96.96%

3. Katie Kadan – "Rolling in the Deep" 96.52%

4. Jake Hoot – "That Ain't My Truck" 95.81%

 

Top 8 Semifinals Ranked:

 

1. Ricky Duran – "Let It Be" 98.61%

2. Rose Short – "I Want To Know What Love Is" 97.88%

3. Jake Hoot – "Desperado" 97.34%

4. Katie Kadan – "Lady Marmalade" 96.33%

 

Top 4 FINALE:

 

1. ???????? – ????????

2. ???????? – ????????

3. ???????? – ????????

4. ???????? – ????????

Link to comment
Share on other sites
dirActing  

dirActing

Posted
  • Author
Posted (edited)

Team John Legend

 

Katie Kadan – 38 – Chicago IL

1. Blinds (09/20/19): "Baby I Love You" 98.23% (28,122|498//2,465,150)

2. Battles (10/18/19): "Tiny Dancer" 98.22% (21,805|395//1,824,490)

3. Knockouts (10/29/19): "Piece of my Heart" 98.27% (16,620|292//1,247,179**)

4. Top 20 (11/11/19): "Always Remember Us This Way" 97.31% (14,934|413//759,726)

5. Top 13 (11/18/19): "I'm Going Down" 97.60% (10,670|262//523,545)

6. Top 11 (11/25/19): "Without You" 97.37% (12,153|328//532,233)

7. Top 10 (12/02/19): "Rolling in the Deep" 96.52% (11,414|411//613,602)

8. Top 8 Solo (12/09/19): "Lady Marmalade" 96.33% (6,722|256//337,027)

9. Top 8 Duet (12/09/19): "Express Yourself" 98.37% (3,623|60//181,688)

Q4dQyLz1lH4 -24EZ9gR0Zo

Nfz1sTNWquU OQlLKDqjB_c

MYnjlgciGUY UWkHUtRDTo0

6Qt3qSxc7ZQ koA8O4jjYVk

aPTpUhxNC6I

 

Team Kelly Clarkson

 

Jake Hoot – 32 – Cookeville TN

1. Blinds (10/07/19): "When It Rains It Pours" 97.60% (6,634|281//777,726)

2. Battles (10/18/19): "Always on My Mind" 98.25% (5,714|102//507,185)

3. Knockouts (10/29/19): "Cover Me Up" 98.64% (6,807|94//594,931)

4. Top 20 (11/11/19): "You Lie" 96.87% (2,940|95//212,499)

5. Top 13 (11/18/19): "Danny's Song" 96.61% (2,563|90//167,528)

6. Top 11 (11/25/19): "Every Light in the House" 97.10% (1,742|52//107,913*)

7. Top 10 (12/02/19): "That Ain't My Truck" 95.81% (2,197|96//151,050)

8. Top 8 Solo (12/09/19): "Desperado" 97.34% (3,361|92//182,253)

9. Top 8 Duet (12/09/19): "Up Where We Belong" 97.63% (1,565|38//75,730)

10A2fHwjV5g H_94v_7U7tM

A2vXPDbZ3VQ uBequw4Ikjw

L0-lB03fBXQ e00WPKF8OQo

y8E3T9Sfi5E jhcsJPtmmTQ

npTUyvC_tWE

 

Team Blake Shelton

 

Ricky Duran – 30 – Worcester MA

1. Blinds (10/07/19): "River" 98.64% (21,688|298//1,492,922)

2. Battles (10/18/19): "Valerie" 97.35% (8,003‬|218//763,988)

3. Knockouts (10/29/19): "She Talks to Angels" 97.02% (3610|111//365,838)

4. Top 20 (11/11/19): "Small Town" 96.62% (2,944|104//203,077)

5. Top 13 (11/18/19): "You Are the Best Thing" 98.03% (3,278‬|66//195,216)

6. Top 11 (11/25/19): "Downtown Train" 96.48% (1,974|72//151,025*)

7. Top 10 (12/02/19): "Born Under a Bad Sign" 97.87% (3,312|72//165,369)

8. Top 8 Solo (12/09/19): "Let It Be" 98.61% (4405|44//177,062)

9. Top 8 Duet (12/09/19): "Your Love" 97.88% (1,850|40//81,351)

ynRUykxX_fM 5Qz3zaemj4M

neB4rH6hBeA UlgOaFSqZns

S3-TqVyahmI 8oiAzOMSt48

RKkltl-3IjA DDzTEVkeIfA

6SQhZMl6VIs

 

 

Team Gwen Stefani

 

Rose Short – 34 – Killeen TX

1. Blinds (09/23/19): "Preach" 98.15% (17,641|332//1,541,240)

2. Battles (10/22/19): "Can't Feel my Face" 97.13% (7,269|224//793,796)

3. Knockouts (11/04/19): "Big White Room" 99.10% (13,604|123//703,003)

4. Top 20 (11/11/19): "What Have You Done for Me Lately?" 97.60% (3,827|94//225,818)

5. Top 13 (11/18/19): "I Turn to You" 98.37% (5,604|93//251,867)

6. Top 11 (11/25/19): "Maybe I'm Amazed" 98.12% (3,503|67//169,626*)

7. Top 10 (12/02/19): "God's Country" 96.96% (9,096|294//700,028)

8. Top 8 Solo (12/09/19): "I Want To Know What Love Is" 97.88% (6,381|138//371,747)

9. Top 8 Duet (12/09/19): "Express Yourself" 98.37% (3,623|60//181,688)

10. Top 8 Save (12/10/19): "(You Make Me Feel Like) a Natural Woman" 98.50 (3,488|53//122,088)

wMM0ORsUAqE _ZNMQtxIzZ0

3HGaCIGUkOA VIkxtJspGc4

JTGRHd3IuaA c-nwHpjA_Vg

Rcj6lZy38L0 QBW4tI3N_Qg

aPTpUhxNC6I RivxbMQv7RY

Edited by dirActing
Link to comment
Share on other sites
dirActing  

dirActing

Posted
  • Author
Posted

So yes, in other tangentially related news, some of you might be happy to note that two of our Voice coaches have hit #1 on iTunes just earlier today, and no it's not the rewritten Christmas classic (in other other news, both coach pairings' respective Xmas duets are at #145 and #166, also on the all-genre iTunes Top 200). So, anyway, what's another video, eh? Wasn't sure where to post this, but this here is a video thread anyways, so here's the new #1 tune:

 

W6KhutkJRlU

Link to comment
Share on other sites
rimalaw

rimalaw

Posted
Posted (edited)

We didn't get a "Road to the Lives" type episode this season. Nobody likes those, except me! :haha: Actually, while I personally appreciate a recap of the journey so far, I do agree it's a waste of episode space in the context of a broadcast season. Much rather we get more performances in full, rather than filler. I have thought, however, that they could or should produce a concise digital version of the recap episode, maybe one for before the playoffs, and another before the finale, and post those online to drum up interest among casuals. Anyway, since they didn't do that obviously, here's my own of sorts! :D

 

The purpose is mainly for fun. The finale is Monday, so if you want to review or relive the season, every video featuring the Top 4 this season (minus group performances, because those generally suck, imho) can be found here, conveniently under one thread. They can be found below, immediately following this post. So watch them all this weekend, watch just the ones you want, or none. Click, or don't click, but before that, here's a Top 4 progress report of sorts. I tend to view the show as part reality competition, part music performance based entertainment. My interest is more with the latter. The focus here is on performances. The data is not predictive, since performances are subjective, and many don't even vote so much based on performance, are tone deaf, etc. The data is organized to help gauge the performance progress of the Top 4, who's peaking or has peaked, etc., but take it any way you want...

 

Top 4 Ranked by Average Score (Based on YouTube Performance Videos)

 

1. Rose Short 98.02% (avg. of all 10 performances incl. the Top 8 IS and duet w/Katie.)

2. Ricky Duran 97.61% (avg. of all 9 performances incl. the Top 8 duet w/Will.)

3. Katie Kadan 97.49% (avg. of 8 performance incl. the Top 8 duet w/Rose, **KO video with Max Boyle omitted from avg. W/Max = 97.58% avg.)

4. Jake Hoot 97.32% (avg. of all 9 performances incl. the Top 8 duet w/MaryBeth.)

 

Top 4 Ranked by Average Views (Based on YouTube Performance Videos)

 

1. Katie Kadan 904,682.63 (views per video, **KO video with Max Boyle omitted from avg.)

2. Rose Short 596,148.38 (views per video, *Top 11 geo-locked video omitted from avg.)

3. Ricky Duran 430,602.88 (views per video, *Top 11 geo-locked video omitted from avg.)

4. Jake Hoot 333,612.75 (views per video, *Top 11 geo-locked video omitted from avg.)

 

Top 4 Solo Performances Ranked by Scores/(Views), Top 15:

 

1. Rose Short – Knockouts (11/04/19): "Big White Room" 99.10% (703,003)

2. Ricky Duran – Blinds (10/07/19): "River" 98.64% (1,492,922)

3. Jake Hoot – Knockouts (10/29/19): "Cover Me Up" 98.64% (594,931)

4. Ricky Duran – Top 8 Solo (12/09/19): "Let It Be" 98.61% (177,062)

5. Rose Short – Top 8 Save (12/10/19): "(You Make Me Feel Like) a Natural Woman" 98.50 (122,088)

6. Rose Short – Top 13 (11/18/19): "I Turn to You" 98.37% (251,867)

7. Katie Kadan – Blinds (09/20/19): "Baby I Love You" 98.23% (2,465,150)

8. Rose Short – Blinds (09/23/19): "Preach" 98.15% (1,541,240)

9. Rose Short – Top 11 (11/25/19): "Maybe I'm Amazed" 98.12% (169,626*)

10. Ricky Duran – Top 13 (11/18/19): "You Are the Best Thing" 98.03% (195,216)

11. Rose Short – Top 8 Solo (12/09/19): "I Want To Know What Love Is" 97.88% (371,747)

12. Ricky Duran – Top 10 (12/02/19): "Born Under a Bad Sign" 97.87% (165,369)

13. Jake Hoot – Blinds (10/07/19): "When It Rains It Pours" 97.60% (777,726)

14. Katie Kadan – Top 13 (11/18/19): "I'm Going Down" 97.60% (523,545)

15. Rose Short – Top 20 (11/11/19): "What Have You Done for Me Lately?" 97.60% (225,818)

 

Top 4 Collaborations (Duets/Battles) Ranked by Scores/(Views), Top 5:

 

1. Katie Kadan & Rose Short – Top 8 Duet (12/09/19): "Express Yourself" 98.37% (181,688)

2. Jake Hoot (vs. Steve Knill) – Battles (10/18/19): "Always on My Mind" 98.25% (507,185)

3. Katie Kadan (vs. Destiny Rayne) – Battles (10/18/19): "Tiny Dancer" 98.22% (1,824,490)

4. Ricky Duran (& Will Breman) – Top 8 Duet (12/09/19): "Your Love" 97.88% (81,351)

5. Jake Hoot (& MaryBeth Byrd) – Top 8 Duet (12/09/19): "Up Where We Belong" 97.63% (75,730)

 

Blind Auditions Ranked:

 

1. Ricky Duran – "River" 98.64%

2. Katie Kadan – "Baby I Love You" 98.23%

3. Rose Short – "Preach" 98.15%

4. Jake Hoot – "When It Rains It Pours" 97.60%

 

Battle Round Ranked:

 

1. Jake Hoot (vs. Steve Knill) – "Always on My Mind" 98.25%

2. Katie Kadan (vs. Destiny Rayne) – "Tiny Dancer" 98.22%

3. Ricky Duran (vs. Marina Chello) – "Valerie" 97.35%

4. Rose Short (vs. Jessie Lawrence) – "Can't Feel my Face" 97.13%

 

Knockout Round Ranked:

 

1. Rose Short – "Big White Room" 99.10%

2. Jake Hoot – "Cover Me Up" 98.64%

3. Katie Kadan – "Piece of my Heart" 98.27%**

4. Ricky Duran – "She Talks to Angels" 97.02%

 

Top 20 Playoffs Ranked:

 

1. Rose Short – "What Have You Done for Me Lately?" 97.60%

2. Katie Kadan – "Always Remember Us This Way" 97.31%

3. Jake Hoot – "You Lie" 96.87%

4. Ricky Duran – "Small Town" 96.62%

 

Top 13 Round Ranked:

 

1. Rose Short – "I Turn to You" 98.37%

2. Ricky Duran – "You Are the Best Thing" 98.03%

3. Katie Kadan – "I'm Going Down" 97.60%

4. Jake Hoot – "Danny's Song" 96.61%

 

Top 11 Round Ranked:

 

1. Rose Short – "Maybe I'm Amazed" 98.12%

2. Katie Kadan – "Without You" 97.37%

3. Jake Hoot – "Every Light in the House" 97.10%

4. Ricky Duran – "Downtown Train" 96.48%

 

Top 10 Round Ranked:

 

1. Ricky Duran – "Born Under a Bad Sign" 97.87%

2. Rose Short – "God's Country" 96.96%

3. Katie Kadan – "Rolling in the Deep" 96.52%

4. Jake Hoot – "That Ain't My Truck" 95.81%

 

Top 8 Semifinals Ranked:

 

1. Ricky Duran – "Let It Be" 98.61%

2. Rose Short – "I Want To Know What Love Is" 97.88%

3. Jake Hoot – "Desperado" 97.34%

4. Katie Kadan – "Lady Marmalade" 96.33%

 

Top 4 FINALE:

 

1. ???????? – ????????

2. ???????? – ????????

3. ???????? – ????????

4. ???????? – ????????

 

Honestly thank you for your time on the stats. For me, I prefer your other post with the simple numbers of Total Views Likes and comments. I think in the end that is the best indicator! All the rest is to show the details of statistics within that subset of viewers but I think the simple 3 rankings (View, Likes, Comments) says it all. Thank you for giving us both and the serious time it took!!

Edited by rimalaw
Link to comment
Share on other sites
rimalaw

rimalaw

Posted
Posted

If it's any comfort, the video recap IS arranged in order of my best guess as to how the finale results will turn out, if we're being predictable. B)

Let’s hope so. I’m still concerned with all the Streams for Jake, who appears to be a nice guy with a really nice voice. But... Katie is the one I want, so I hope the Social media stats here make the difference to push her to win!!

Thanks again for your stats!!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share
Go to topic listing
×
×
  • Create New...