Dai

I have mixed feelings about Megan’s take on AFM. While it was technically good, that particular song needs a more nuanced vocal and I don’t think that was it. I get the praise tho

1 hour ago, FloorWax said:

Zachariah shot up after this week.

He had my second favorite performance last night, and I ranked him 11th a week ago 

Favs
1. Wé

2. Iam

Ok
4-9. Everyone else except…
 

Too green
10. Haven

One thing I will say about this cast is that 9 people out the Top 10 had at least one great performance (only Wé and Iam have been consistently good though, imho)

12 minutes ago, Misirlou said:

I'd argue her cover of The Dance has to be my favorite of her. Gorgeous.

Her two finale solos are my favorites. I thought she had it in the bag after Deja Vu

Top 10 Questions

1. Which 7 singers will advance to the Top 7? (100 points)

- Wé

- Colin

- Iam

- Warren

- Megan

- Zachariah

- Haven

2. Which 2 singers will be eliminated from the competition? (60 points)

- Oliver (30 pts)

- Tyson (20 pts)

- Marybeth (10 pts)

3. If there’s a Judge’s Save or Wildcard, which singer will be saved? (20 pts)

- Marybeth

4. Which singer will be announced last by Ryan Seacrest to move forward to Top 7? (50 points)

- Zachariah

5. Which female singer will be announced first by Ryan Seacrest to move forward to Top 7? (50 points)

- Megan

6. Which male singer will be announced first by Ryan Seacrest to move forward to Top 7? (50 points)

- Iam

7. What will be the ratio of male and female singers in the Top 7? (Without the Judge’s Save/Wildcard) (20 points)

- 4M/3F

Bonus Question 

8. Which number of the performance order that one of the eliminated singer will be assigned to? From 1st (Opening the show) to 10th (Closing the show). (50 pts)

- 7th

Tomorrow should be interesting, not really sure who’s in danger.

Having the “girl next door” look is enough to get you voted through.

Just now, erik g said:

Haven through. side eye

Yep 

Haven’t been posting but Nutsa really surprised today, she did great

30 minutes ago, thevoicespoilers said:

How many minivan members y’all think is actual not going to watch the show anymore ?

If you are asking if the demo will change after Blake leaves, the answer is probably no. Idol doesn’t have Blake and it has similar voting patterns to The Voice (always a country guy in the Top 2, guys doing better than girls…)

8 minutes ago, Misirlou said:

Yeah, Jackie was either on the good side (Never Tear Us Apart,Alone, Gravity), or the Bad side (Toxic, Love Reign O'er Me, Here I Go Again)

I remember liking this one  Might have to watch it again

Edit: I can see why you it on the bad side but at the same time I’m pretty sure it was one of the best performance that night. The ending was great

38 minutes ago, FloorWax said:

After watching S13 as my first season, I remember being so disappointed when S14 lives came around, especially after a bunch of faves got cut/flopped in the Playoffs. Kyla was the only contestant I consistently liked week after week, with Jackie (Foster) being the only other one I was interested in.

Jackie was a fun contestant, each week she was either one of the best or one of the worst, there was no in between 

What did people like about S14? Genuinely asking

S4, S5 and S13 are my Holy Trinity. S8, S10 and S21 are great too. 

10 minutes ago, Hsamid said:

Zachariah kind of reminds me of Omar on the voice last season in regards to how people feel about him 

 

You either love him or think he's cringy, corny karaoke.

Omar was an insane vocalist though (not really a fan but at his best he was undeniable)

Zachariah is ok, but I don’t think he’s as good as some people say he is (same thing with Nutsa)

3 minutes ago, nytsch said:

This comparison is an offense to Omar lol

 

/lh cause you know it’s never that serious (at least with me lol) but I can see that accusation about some of Omar’s performances, but there are some others  like STL, ITNOL, and honestly his battle and KO too that I don’t see how it’s corny or karaoke.

 

I know that wasn’t your opinion per se but I’m just saying in general.

Off-topic but I lowkey hate this performance due to how corny it is  

1. Which 10 singers will advance to the Top 10? (100 points)

- Tyson

- Oliver

- Megan

- Marybeth

- Colin

- Zachariah

- Warren

- Wé

- Haven

- Iam

2. Which 2 singers will be eliminated from the competition? (50 points)

- First choice (30 pts) Nutsa

- Second choice (20 pts) Lucy

3. Which singer will be announced last by Ryan Seacrest to move forward to Top 10? (50 points)

- Tyson

4. Which female singer will be announced first by Ryan Seacrest to move forward to Top 10? (50 points)

- Marybeth

5. Which male singer will be announced first by Ryan Seacrest to move forward to Top 10? (50 points)

- Iam

6. What will be the ratio of male and female singers in the Top 10? (20 points)

- 6M/4F

Bonus Question 

7. How many wildcards (Lucy Love & Nutsa) will move forward to Top 10? 2 or 1 or 0 (50 pts)

- 0

8. Which number of the performance order that one of the eliminated singer will be assigned to? From 1 (Opening the show) to 12 (Closing the show). (80 pts)

- 4th

7 minutes ago, IdolFan117 said:

 

She did that as her Showstoppers song

Oops. Didn’t watch that round 

Tina Turner is in it so I wouldn’t be surprise me if Nutsa sings Proud Mary.

8 hours ago, Hsamid said:

Any performances you guys would nominate in this new era of Idol?

Hmmm…

Leah Marlene - Heal, Separate Ways, Sanctuary

Maddie Poppe - Nothing Compares 2 U

Jay Copeland - Lilac Wine

Casey Bishop - Over The Rainbow, Live Wire

Willie Spence - Stand Up

I’m sure there are others but these are the ones that came to mind

1 minute ago, istersay said:

nice acting job carebear, buh bye...again 

  #exposed

Favorites

1a. We

1b. Iam

(gap)

Cool tones

3. Marybeth

4. Oliver

Great vocalist, not much else

5. Warren

Wasn’t impressed before but they were great last night (still not a fan)

6. Lucy

7. Megan

8. Colin

9. Tyson

Too extra for me

10. Nutsa (I don’t get it)

11. Zachariah

Nope

12. Haven

Maybe I should just take a break from watching singing competitions, what a sh*tshow   

Glad IDF is happy with the saves but personally I would have saved other people