Elliott

Look I’m excited over a second season with my British twink

All I’m saying is there are too many theatrics in here and that statement is coming from me of all people.

We don’t even know how it’ll play out or what effect it’ll have on the show yet.

Pers Blankens

ugh I hate Shallow so much.

That doesn't really have any bearing on whether she could return or not. As long as she has a visa (which she had last year), she's fine. Vancouver to Los Angeles is a common [direct] flight, and she'd be allowed to travel since it's work/media-related and she'd be quarantining in LA for the required duration anyway. She either wasn't asked or turned the offer down.

Jovin is past the age limit now, and Sophia might have some sort of publishing deal that prevented her from returning. Jonny probably just didn’t want to.

I don’t think the basis audience is going to remember *checks notes* Cyniah Elise.

Fixed

George only having two performances in the final vote is disgusting and will be noted for future seasons.

Well it’s not exactly like they knew the world would be in a global pandemic and their live shows would get shortened to The Voice levels when they audition in the summer of 2019.

Maybe they’re not involved until the second week of the shows so they’re waiting to promote it.

King

No, S19 would be the final season before he hit the age cut-off. He and I are only a month apart so I’m well aware that I’m almost too old for Idol.

Also - didn’t Arthur turn down an offer from Hollywood? Seems weird to bring him back when he didn’t want the rescue deal.

Makayla and Louis returning is just *chef’s kiss*

Louis has been in LA since the 14th of February. I didn’t think anything of it until just now lol.

Arthur’s back?

If it’s that the contestants are voting who to save from the B3, I stg...

I’m surprised @1234567890 didn’t just use her modly powers to edit Tom’s cut.

Not to sound like a hater but for more personally, I could never get past the tone of her voice so it made it hard to enjoy her performances otherwise. I did like DCOL (the original) but her other “moments” I found it hard to get into.

George was my favourite during S3 so I’m naturally not rooting for Diana DeGarmo in this after IDF Diana cut of one of his best S3 performances.

I would’ve voted for her if the sister’s didn’t cut Suzy Vulaca.