Jump to content

What if the 4-Chair Turns Were the Top Artists in Each Season?


Kyn65
 Share

Recommended Posts

This is just based on loose speculation so don’t take it too seriously lol and it’s hard to say whether the same steals would happen so I noted which teams each contestant was on. Also formats would have to change just for numbers. 

 

 

S21

Semifinals (Top 7)

PV: Girl Named Tom

PV: Wendy Moten

PV: Carson Peters

IS: Holly Forbes 

Eliminated: BrittanyBree 

Eliminated: Aaron Hines

Eliminated: Gymani

 

Finale

Winner: Girl Named Tom (Team Kelly)

Runner-up: Wendy Moten (Team Blake)

Third: Carson Peters (Team Blake) 

Fourth: Holly Forbes (Team Kelly/Ariana)

 

 

S20

Finale

Winner: Kenzie Wheeler (Team Kelly)

Runner-up: Zae Romeo (Team Nick/Kelly)

Third: Avery Roberson (Team Blake/Kelly)

Fourth: Anna Grace (Team Kelly/Blake)

 

 

S19

Finale

Winner: DeSz (Team Kelly)

Runner-up: Worth the Wait (Team Blake)

Third: Cami Clune (Team Legend/Kelly)

Fourth: Tamara Jade (Team Legend)

 

 

S18

Semifinals (Top 7)

PV:Todd Tighlman

PV:Toneisha Harris

PV: Thunderstorm Artis

IS: Joanna Serenko

Eliminated: Nelson Cade III

Eliminated: Mike Jerel

Eliminated: Mandi Castillo

 

Finale

Winner: Todd Tighlman (Team Blake)

Runner-up: Toneisha Harris (Team Blake)

Third: Thunderstorm Artis (Team Legend/Nick)

Fourth: Joanna Serenko (Team Nick/Legend/Blake)

 

 

S17

Semifinals (Top 8 )

PV: Ricky Duran

PV: Brennan Lassiter

PV: Katie Kadan

IS Winner: Marybeth Byrd

IS Eliminated: Preston C Howell

IS Eliminated: Shane Q

B2 Eliminated: Mendeleyev

B2 Eliminated: Khalea Lynee

 

Finale 

Winner: Ricky Duran (Team Blake)

Runner-up: Brennan Lassiter (Team Kelly)

Third: Katie Kadan (Team Legend)

Fourth: Marybeth Byrd (Team Legend)

Edited by Kyn65
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Season 16

Winner- Maelyn Jarmon

Runner Up- Dexter Roberts

Third Place- Shawn Sounds

Fourth Place- LB Crew

 

Definitely prefer this finale to real life. The Top 3 were actually my choices for PV 


Season 15

Winner- Kirk Jay

Runner Up- Kennedy Holmes

Third Place- DeAndre Nico

Fourth Place- SandyRedd 

 

I would have preferred this finale lineup overall, but not the winner

 

Season 14

Winner- Pryor Baird

Runner Up- Justin Kilgore

Third Place- Terrence Cunningham 

Fourth Place- Johnny Bliss

 

The artists in this finale really peaked in the Blinds for the most part. This could have been a really weak group, considering their performances after their auditions

 

Season 13

Winner- Brooke Simpson

Runner Up- Moriah Formica

Third Place- Keisha Renee

Fourth Place- Davon Fleming

 

I would have liked this finale as well

 

Season 12

Winner- Casi Joy

Runner Up- JChosen

Thirs Place- Anatalia Villaranda

Fourth Place- Troy Ramey

 

Yeah, this really wasn’t a good season for 4 chair turns.

 

Season 11

Winner- Billy Gilman

Runner Up- We McDonald

Third Place- Ali Caldwell

Fourth Place- Nolan Neal

 

Two contestants that absolutely hated each-other both making the finale could have caused a lot more drama.

 

Season 10

Winner- Alisan Porter

Runner Up- Mary Sarah

Third Place- Ryan Quinn

Fourth Place- Owen Danoff

 

Could have been a good Top 4. Blake’s base would have backed Mary Sarah to get her to 2nd.
 

Season 9

Winner- Jordan Smith

Runner Up- Barrett Baber

Third Place- Shelby Brown

Fourth Place- Viktor Kiraly
 

Would have been a solid group, but oddly enough this Top 4 fills similar roles to the people we actually got (Shelby/Emily, Viktor/Jeffery). 


I can’t really go much further

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

9 hours ago, Cookie73 said:

Season 11

Winner- Billy Gilman

Runner Up- We McDonald

Third Place- Ali Caldwell

Fourth Place- Nolan Neal

 

Two contestants that absolutely hated each-other both making the finale could have caused a lot more drama.

 

 

 

 

i was new to idf in s11. who hated each other lol

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

12 minutes ago, azwige said:

i was new to idf in s11. who hated each other lol

 


Billy and Nolan. There was drama between them when they were roommates (I think Billy reported something Nolan did) and Nolan tweeted something when Billy didn’t win, implying that he got karma 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

×
×
  • Create New...