Cookie73

1. Team Kelly

1. Holly Brand

2. Cait Martin

3. Neil Salsich

4. D. Smooth

5. ALI

2. Team Blake

1. NOIVAS

2. Grace West

3. Rachel Christine

4. Mary Kate Connor

5. Kylee Dayne

3. Team Niall

1. Gina Miles

2. Ryley Tate Wilson

3. Ross Clayton

4. Tasha Jessen

5. Michael B

4. Team Chance

1. Kala Banham

2. Manasseh

3. Sorelle

4. Jamar Langley

5. Ray Uriel

It was very clear what the order of the teams was going to be for me

Rachel was good but Holly set the bar so high.

I’d pick her over some of the other winners tonight though

Discuss

Just now, Teraginn said:

SLAY MISS HOLLY!

 

Between the country girls, I like Holly better, she just has a much brighter tone and I like how she projects more.

Yeah, I prefer Holly over Grace too. I guess it’s because I like her theatrics

Holly is so good!

I didn’t really mind that Sorelle performance. It’s fine at least compared to the rest of the team in Knockouts

1 minute ago, British Man said:

Everyone here dogging on Team Chance must be forgetting 

 

1) Who is currently sitting on the balcony

2) Who just got stolen last week

The only 2 members I care about

Maybe that’s why people forgot about them though

Hamza must be excited right now

Ross did well tonight

Neil killed it tonight. Glad he got stolen by Kelly, but that is a stacked team (3 of my current Top 5 artists are there)

Neil and Grace are the two best of the episode so far. Team Kelly is still stacked with her stealing Neil. I personally preferred Neil here but a steal was necessary regardless of who lost

Jamar was pretty good, but not Zaxai good.

Just now, Ptones2010 said:

This guy is taking on John Legend...those are some big shoes to fill.

At least John Legend isn’t coaching him this season

Michael was good, but I though his battle was better 

Yeah, I agree this season wasn’t very strong in terms of Blind Auditions. I enjoyed Week 1, but then the auditions took a dip in quality, and Week 2 was possibly the weakest that I can remember (not to mention the infamous Episode 4). Some of the contestants that weren’t good stepped it up in the battles but yeah, this season was never going to be a good one. It felt like Blake said he wanted to retire and they threw something together last minute and are trying to get it over-with as quickly as possible without any care.

So to recap

It looks like we get Holly, Rachel, Ross, Jamar, Grace, Neil, Sorelle and Michael today, and Magnus, Jerome, EJ and Tiana go home

5 minutes ago, jarmon said:

Could you imagine if my #1 is Someone's #1 as well 

I mean, that’s the audition I preferred of the two, so I’d take it

15 minutes ago, jarmon said:

okay slay at this Top 2, both were involved in my #1 battle

And one of them had your #1 audition too

1 hour ago, QueenCami said:

on the topic of american idol everyone go laugh at my best post of all time in that thread i need validation bc i worked hard on that edit

 

Interesting

12 minutes ago, nytsch said:

Hmmm I’m not sure why everyone has JB so high either (given that people here generally prefer female voices)? He was upper half of the auditions in that episode imo, but overall ehhh…

 

Well we all know Cait is my clear favorite left but I wouldn’t be too mad to see NariYella either 

Agreed. I thought JB’s audition was good, but it’s not in my Top 10 overall

5 minutes ago, allistr said:

Remaining to be ranked

Cait Martin (1)
Allie Keck (5)
JB Somers (TBA)
NariYella (5)
Kate Cosentino (3)
Jerome Godwin (TBA)
Kason Lester (5)
Grace West (TBA)

[NO CHAIR]

 

I’m pulling for Cait, Grace and NariYella

It looks like my favorite battle pairing had your Top 2 auditions this season

I’m excited to finally see another full performance from him tonight. The last time a full performance of his aired, none of the other contestants had been shown yet

Something else I need to mention, a lot of contestants that made it very far had great Knockouts (Chris, Lauren, Hunter, Brennley, Vanessa and Lilli were some of the best Knockouts that season)

Just now, FloorWax said:

Should I reserve my thoughts on Lauren until after the Chris review drops or... 

I think it would add to the suspense, because it would make your Chris review more of a surprise