Best American Idol Finalists based off of WNTS scores by seasons

[thevoiceisthetop]

Season 1 - Average: 45.31

10. AJ Gil - 16.7 

9. Jim Verrastros - 17.0

8. EJay Day - 36.5

7. Ryan Starr - 38.8

6. RJ Helton - 43.3

5. Nikki McKibbin - 45.8

4. Justin Guarini - 52.5

3. Christina Christian - 55.0

2. Tamyra Gray - 71.9

1. Kelly Clarkson - 75.6

 

Season 2 - Average: 48.78

12. Carmen Rasmussen - 28.9

11. Charles Grigsby - 36.3

10. Corey Clark - 37.3

9. Julia DeMato - 38.0

8. Rickey Smith - 39.8

7. Joshua Gracin - 42.6

6. Kimberly Caldwell - 44.8

5. Vanessa Olivarez - 58.0

4. Ruben Studdard - 62.9

3. Kimberley Locke - 63.8

2. Treynce - 64.8

1. Clay Aiken - 68.2

 

Season 3 - Average: 47.58

12. Camille Velasco - 24.2

11. Leah LaBelle - 26.0

10. John Stevens - 30.9

9. Jon Peter Lewis - 33.9

8. Matthew Rogers - 35.3

7. Jasmine Trias - 38.7

6. George Huff - 58.1

5. Diana DeGarmo - 58.6

4. Amy Adams - 61.0

3. Jennifer Hudson - 62.8

2. Fantasia - 64.9

1. LaToya London - 76.6

 

Season 4 - Average: 49.8

12. Mikalah Gordon - 26.0

11. Scott Savol  - 34.0

10. Lindsey Cardinale - 35.3

9. Anthony Fedorov - 40.3

8. Constantine Maroulis - 51.7

7. Nikko Smith - 53.3

6. Anwar Robinson - 53.9

5. Jessica Sierra - 55.2

4. Vonzell Solomon - 55.6

3. Carrie Underwood - 57. 1

2. Nadia Turner - 64.3

1. Bo Bice - 70.9

 

Season 5 - Average: 49.65

12. Kevin Covais - 29.2

11. Kellie Pickler - 34.1

10. Ace Young - 35.3

9. Bucky Covington - 41.6

8. Melissa McGhee - 42.3

7. Lisa Tucker - 45.8

6. Katherine McPhee - 55.3

5. Paris Bennett - 57. 1

4. Taylor Hicks - 60.7

3. Chris Daughtry - 64.7

2. Eliott Yamin - 64.8

1. Mandisa - 64.9 

 

Season 6 - Average: 48.5

12. Sanjaya Malakar - 19.1

11. Haley Scarnato - 30.1

10. Brandon Rogers - 31.0 

9. Chris Richardson - 38.2

8. Phil Stacey - 51.6

7. Chris Sligh - 53.5

6. Gina Glocksen - 53.9

4(tie). LaKisha Jones - 55.7

4(Tie) Blake Lewis - 55.7

3. Stephanie Edwards - 57.4

2. Jordin Sparks - 58.8

1. Melinda Doolittle - 77.0

 

Season 7 - Average: 51.45

12. Kristy Lee Cook - 35.9

11. Amanda Overmyer - 37.4

10. Ramiele Malubay - 42.0

9. Jason Castro - 44.2

8. Chikezie - 49.8

7. Brooke White - 51.4

6. Syesha Mercado - 53.6

5. David Archuleta - 56.9

4. David Hernandez - 57.0

3. Carly Smithson - 61.9

2. Michael Johns - 62.0

1. David Cook - 65.3

 

Season 8 - Average: 50.69

13. Megan Joy - 30.8

12. Michael Sarver - 32.3

11. Scott Macintyre - 35.8

10. Jasmine Murray - 38.7

9. Lil Rounds - 42.4

8. Danny Gokey - 49.4

7. Jorge Nunez - 51.0

6. Matt Giraud - 51.8

5. Anoop Desai - 54.3

4. Kris Allen - 62.6

3. Alexis Grace - 67.3

2. Adam Lambert - 69.8

1. Allison Iraheta - 72.8

 

Season 9 -  Average:  47.4

12. Lacey Brown - 28.8

11. Paige Miles - 29.2

10. Tim Urban - 32.3

9. Andrew Garcia - 35.9

8. Aaron Kelly - 41.0

7.  Katie Stevens - 45.8

6. Didi Benami - 51.8

5. Casey James - 53.2

4. Michael Lynche - 55.9

3. Lee DeWyze - 57.6

2. Siobhan Magnus - 62.4

1. Crystal Bowersox - 74.9

 

Season 10 - Average: 52.65

13. Karen Rodriguez - 35.0

12. Ashthon Jones - 36.0

11. Paul McDonald - 43.3

10. Jacob Lusk - 45.4

9. Thia Megia - 46.6

8. Naima Adedapo - 46.7

7. Stefano Langone - 49.4

6. Scotty McCreery - 53.0

5. Casey Abrams - 56.8

4. Haley Reinhart - 61.6

3. Lauren Alaina - 62.4

2. James Durbin - 67.4

1. Pia Toscano - 80.8

 

Season 11 - Average: 53.17

13. Heejun Han - 35.4

12. Shannon Magrane - 38.7

11. DeAndre Brackensick - 41.8

10. Jermaine Jones - 45.0

9. Jeremy Rosado - 49.7

8. Philip Phillips - 52.3

7. Colton Dixon - 56.2

6. Joshua Ledet - 59.1

4(Tie)- Hollie Cavanugh - 61.2

4(Tie) - Skylar Laine - 61.2

3 - Elise Testone - 61.3

2 - Jessica Sanchez - 63.3

1 - Erika Van Pelt - 66.0

 

Season 12 - Average: 51.31

10. Lazaro Arbos - 22.1

9. Curtis Finch Jr - 46.0

8. Paul Jolley - 47.5

6(tie). Burnell Taylor - 50.2

6(tie). Janelle Arthur - 50.2

5. Devin Velez - 52.9

4. Amber Holcomb - 54.5

3. Angie Miller - 57.9

2. Kree Harrison - 60.1

1. Candice Glover - 71.7

 

Season 13 - Average: 48.92

13. Kristen O´Connor - 29.0

12. CJ Harris - 37.8

11. Dexter Roberts - 39.0

10. Ben Briley - 41.3

9. Sam Woolf - 44.1

8. MK Nobilette - 44.8

7. Malaya Watson - 49.7

6. Emily Piriz - 50.7

5. Majesty Rose - 51.5

4. Jessica Meuse - 60.4

3. Alex Preston - 61.6

1(Tie) - Jena Irene - 63.0

1(Tie) - Caleb Johnson - 63.0

 

Season 14 - Average: 49.42

12. Daniel Seavey - 12.6

11. Qaasim Middleton - 33.4

10. Maddie Walker - 34.2

9. Rayvon Ówen - 48.1

8. Adanna Duru - 49.2

7. Tyanna Jones - 55.1

6. Joey Cook - 57.5

4 Tie - JAX - 59.0

4 Tie - Nick Fradini - 59.0

3. Sarina Joi Crowe - 59.8

2. Clark Beckham - 61.5

1. Quentin Alexander - 63.7

 

Season 15 - Average: 50.56

9(Tie). Gianna Isabelle - 23.5

9(Tie). Lee Jean - 23.5

8. Tristian MacIntosh - 37.7

7. Dalton Rappatoni - 40.2

6. MacKenzie Bourg - 52.7

5. Sonika Vaid - 59.9

4. Avalon Young - 61.0

3. Olivia Rox - 61.7

2. Trent Harmon - 70.9

1. La´Porsha Renae - 74.5

 

Season 16 - Average: 54.01

10. Michelle Sussett - 36.5

9. Caleb Lee Hutchinson - 43.5

7(tie). Catie Turner - 46.8

7(tie). Cade Foehner - 46.8

6. Ada Vox - 53.8

5. Gabby Barrett - 54.2

4. Michael J. Woodward - 56.5

3. Jurnee - 64.0

2. Dennis Lorenzo - 64.8

1. Maddie Poppe - 73.1

 

Season 17 - Average: 53.4

10. Wade Cota - 33.8

9. Walker Burroughs - 41.3

8. Alyssa Raghu - 44.9

7. Dimitrius Graham - 49.0

6. Alejandro Aranda - 51.1

5. Laine Hardy - 55.7

4. Madison VanDenberg - 56.1

3. Laci Kaye Booth - 57.7

2. Uche - 64.3

1. Jeremiah Lloyd Harmon - 80.1

 

Season 18 - Average: 45.53

1

1- Lauren Spencer Smith	67
2- Dillion James	63
3- Makayla Phillips	60.5
4- Julia Gargano	58.8
5- Just Sam	56.7
6- Jonny West	56.5
7-Sophia James	55.5
8- Francisco Martin	54.8
9- Kimmy Gabriella	53
10-Grace Leer	52
11- Arthur Gunn	51.2
12- Cyniah Elise	48
13- Jovin Webb	40.5
14- Olivia Ximines	35
15- Louis Knight	31
16- Franklin Boone	31
17- Faith Becnel	30
18- Nick Merico	27
19 - Aliana Jester	26
20 - DeWayne Crocker Jr	13

[Bk1234]

8 minutes ago, thevoiceisthetop said:

1. Pia Toscano - 80.8

Queen! 

[Bk1234]

For Season 18, I thought the Top 11 were considered finalists? 

[thevoiceisthetop]

1 hour ago, Bk1234 said:

For Season 18, I thought the Top 11 were considered finalists? 

oh i didnt know so i just included all