Brick

Nooooo don't spend "She Used to Be Mine" this early in the live shows...

Leah's original is sooo cool. I hope she has other good originals too for later on. But she has the artistry to make every song her own, so I am not worried even if she only does covers from now on.

We are lucky the judges and producers only let less than a handful of country singers get to the voting rounds, otherwise... If you are country you really just need to show up and produce noise.

Has anyone ever sounded worse doing their audition song again? Because Cadence did. Katy with the straight goodbye line about "winning in life"

This is just not a good song, period. But she did sing the heck out of it. She might just get saved. The judges flat out admitting they had already counted her out

Would this girl stop screaming at me completely out of tune? She it by far the pitchiest contestant this season.

What happened near the end of that performance?? Someone bust the windows out of the arrangement and her pitch

Again Christian picking a song for the sole purpose of showboating and oversinging, with no connection. Then he says he "feels every word of the song" and proceeds to show how much of a lie that is by saying that the song is about thinking "hell no, I belong here", which this song is DEFINITELY not about And of course he says "thank Jesus" every time he speaks for pandering.

I'm sorry but Willie didn't even come close. Where was the emotion and the passion?

Oh he needs to go. Now.

Seriously, what Arthur did to "Remember Me" was a crime. He should've been expelled from the competion right away. I was going to say it was borderline disrespectful, but there was nothing borderline about it. Says he didn't watch the movie and proceeds to destroy the song and its meaning. "Coco" is probably the single best Pixar movie of all time, and it didn't deserve that.

America really is the WORST. I mean, what an amazing season that has just been turned into a boring WGWG snoozefest.

Makayla was the best so far, but the song was too big for her and she didn't arrange it in a smart way or tweak it to her strengths or make good vocal choices. Actually, scratch that, DeWayne was the best so far.

Why the f did we really have to do this. Now we are going to have a broken didgeridoo trying and failing miserably to sing actual words in the Top 10 for this season, after having been the runner-up last season, and he will start sending people home that are more deserving. If he wins it will be so so so awful it's beyond words.

So, if anyone is mad about Ava, just think that Arthur got her place in the Top10, that oughta cheer you up!

People online seem to be on Grace's side and pooping on the judge's criticism. I think tonight might've actually earned her a lot of votes. Her performance was actually pretty great too.

It will be fan to see Arthur and Chayce splitting votes. I wonder what would happen.

DeShawn earned it tonight. Alyssa and Caleb on the other hand....

Good job Katy getting Ava sent home. Completely undeserved.

Grace is through, screw you Katy!

Am I the only one who feels very little emotion from Willie? Even in this song, it was so middle of the road emotionally.

Mad respect for Willie for this song choice, knowing Idol's viewers this song is a big risk to pick.

Maybe today Willie will be able to emote?

He is absolutely correct here, on the other hand

Yeah, he seems to be out of his mind a little bit. Melinda, on the other hand, is on fire: