Jump to content

KelseyW

Members
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    2,524

  • Joined

  • Last visited

 Content Type 

Posts posted by KelseyW

    Best Audition 3 Contestant

    in American Idol

    Posted

    2 hours ago, CarmenSandiego said:

    From the rejected auditions:

     

    1.  Donahue -- he was entertaining but he's nowhere near good enough.

    2.  Avery -- Simon would have eviscerated him, believe me.

     

    And now for the ones who made it:

     

    1.  Scarlett -- it's a pity that she didn't get into the Top 24.

    2.  Jennifer -- best of those who got into the Top 24.

    3.  Aniston -- I liked her country sound.

    4.  Will -- best of the guys and the one most likely to get to the finale.

    5.  Kyra -- I liked her more the first time I heard her than the second time around.  Still very good though.

    6.  Max -- he was better than his sister but not by much.

    7.  Laela -- she was good enough to get to Hollywood, even if Max was a little better.

    8.  Kimi --  he began slow but improved enough to go to Hollywood.

    9.  Madzia -- she has a fine voice but might have more personality than talent at this point.

    10.  C.J. -- he was doing well for me until he had to look at his screen for the lyrics.

    11.  Nick -- second time around, I cringed a little when I heard him try to go for more runs in his song.

    He didn't come into the room to audition with a song he wrote literally the day before!

    They took him by surprise and wanted an original as opposed to whatever he originally would've sung... imo

    I like him a ton. My fave guy of the night!

    American Idol Season 22 Spoilers - Presented By The Idol Pad

    in American Idol

    Posted

    7 hours ago, Carrie_On said:

    Scarlet is a bit too theatrical when she sings. I think she’d be great for Broadway. The judges/producers decided to go with Julia and Nya as the belters, I’m assuming. 

    THANK YOU.

     

    I barely paid attention to her, but she definitely is an over singer who was trying to impress or whatever. lol

     

    I wouldn't put the phone down for Jennifer J just yet. I think some folks would like her and find her refreshing compared to the 1000th blonde fake twangy country pop female... But that's just me!!

    • Confused 1

    Katy Perry replacement

    in American Idol

    Posted

    On 2/29/2024 at 9:57 AM, Solaris said:

    In my opinion the reboot of the series lost when they didn't put some of their most successful stars of the series at the judging table initially.

     

    Put Kelly or Carrie, Adam Lambert and Jennifer Hudson on.

    Kelly. Busy as heck. Carrie also usually busy.

    Adam? He apparently is working at The Voice overseas.

    Jennifer is cool but she has a talk show too.

    Why does it have to be a alumni star or someone well known?

    I don't care what ya'll think. I think Melinda Doolittle needs to teach some lessons here. Her judgement I would take to heart if I were a singer!

    Katy Perry replacement

    in American Idol

    Posted

    17 hours ago, Adam_S said:

    Good riddance imo. I lost respect for her after her pettiness towards Heather Russel- who somehow mysteriously never made it to the live shows (neither did Olivia Grace from that season surprisingly). I HATE how Katie always puts on that fake ass country accent anytime a country singer comes on. She just seems so fake and conceited at this point. But interestingly, many people don't even seem to agree with me. So to each their own!

    Wrong forum??? lol

×
×
  • Create New...