ClebastianFan

So Luke Combs is just Caleb in 20 years.

So are the guys just Fall Out Boy's backup singers?  

Vocally, Grace and Willie were the best and should be the Top 2, but we all know that America doesn't always vote that way (See: Reinhart, Haley).

What the heck is this? 

3 minutes ago, Steven_ said:

 

The superior C. Beckham 

I don't know if anyone's ever topped Latoya London on this song. 

Here we go! I don't know why I'm humming Change Nothing (Jessica Sanchez's winner's single) right now, but I am. 

Also, why does DeShawn get to be in both group performances?

When Alyssa, Arthur and Cassandra get duets and Casey doesn't

Grace trying to singlehandedly break the record for most overdone songs in one night 

I keep expecting Graham to show up on one of the family shots 

4 minutes ago, Elliott said:

What kind of S3 Top 5 realness

S3 was the first full season I watched. 

I was 14 then. I'm 31 now. 

Justin Guarini did it better. 

5 minutes ago, 1234567890 said:

The official American Idol YouTube channel has already removed all of Caleb’s videos.

He's been scrubbed from the official AI Instagram account too 

6 minutes ago, Shasta357 said:

Oh yay a top 4 I am now completely satisfied with. 

Swap Chayce with Anilee List and I would be happy, but yeah 

1 minute ago, Elliott said:

If you’re limiting it to people made it past the green mile, yeah. 

Yeah, I was thinking of only Top 12/10 and beyond.

If my memory is correct, this makes Caleb the third finalist to be disqualified (after Corey Clark and Jermaine Jones). Funny how all three have first and last names starting with the same sound.

Not sure what bearing this might have (if any), but I was just looking at the YouTube views for the Top 7's Disney performances:

1. Grace - 388K
2. Arthur - 353K
3. Casey - 342K
4. Willie - 303K
5. Hunter - 200K
6. Caleb - 152K
7. Chayce - 132K

Make of that what you will.

Jason OUT

Casey IN

Ava IN 

Chayce and Caleb IN

Sending out massive good vibes for Beane and Ava...

Cassandra IN, Cecil OUT

Between Cassandra and Cecil for the last spot?