End of the year poll

[Gustavo527]

Discuss. 

 

 

 

 

 

Edited December 31, 2024 by Gustavo527

[Misirlou]

25.

 

He´s an ass but Asher.

 

I´ll give it a C. Nothing spectacular, but I feel both these seasons got way too much hate.

[AliXRose]

Season 25

 

Asher

 

C (Average)

[StarWalker1]

Season 26

 

Asher

 

C overall

[QueenKalie]

If we are combining the two seasons it's probably an F. Both were pretty bad and while there might be a few seasons I might consider worse I'm not sure there were back to back seasons as bad as these two so I think they earned that grade.

[nytsch]

S25 (format makes a big difference imo even with just 1 extra lives week)

 

Asher, but it's pretty close imo (I probably liked Titanium and Last Dance more than any Sofronio performance so that gives the edge to Asher)

 

I'll be generous and go with C lol

[allistr]

S25

Asher

Average

[QueenMae16]

Easily S25.

 

Idc if he's shady, but Asher by far lmao. 

 

D overall, but by itself I'd say S25 was a B, and S26 was an E or even an F lol.

Edited January 1 by QueenMae16

[Gustavo527]

S25 for me. Ngl, i honestly feel some of the people that prefer S26 over S25 are just country haters.  

 

Asher's Titanium destroys any performance by Sofronio, so Asher would be my choice. 

 

It was honestly mediocre. The awful formats are one thing, but his show is reaching The Voice UK levels of mediocrity in terms of talent, like, every season gets closer and closer to that. 

[allistr]

45 minutes ago, Gustavo527 said:

S25 for me. Ngl, i honestly feel some of the people that prefer S26 over S25 are just country haters.  

 

 

S26 country artists were worse than S25 imo. Josh and Karen singlehandedly beat all of them. Even though I really really liked Katie O and her stage presence, she was gone too soon. Christina was good but her Lives exposed her a lot.

 

Also, Josh didn't win S25, so idk what IDF was expecting.

Edited January 1 by allistr

[StarWalker1]

1 hour ago, Gustavo527 said:

S25 for me. Ngl, i honestly feel some of the people that prefer S26 over S25 are just country haters.  

 

Asher's Titanium destroys any performance by Sofronio, so Asher would be my choice. 

 

It was honestly mediocre. The awful formats are one thing, but his show is reaching The Voice UK levels of mediocrity in terms of talent, like, every season gets closer and closer to that. 

for me S25 just felt ... boring

 

besides the winner, nothing really stood out wheras with S26 I felt there was more performances I liked more

[Hamza Tufail]

26

How about none of them?

E

[Kenneth96]

On 1/1/2025 at 8:15 AM, nytsch said:

S25 (format makes a big difference imo even with just 1 extra lives week)

 

Asher, but it's pretty close imo (I probably liked Titanium and Last Dance more than any Sofronio performance so that gives the edge to Asher)

 

I'll be generous and go with C lol

This. 1 extra week of lives impacted a lot. Maddi could have made it to the finale in the S26 format, while Sydney would have not make it that far in the S25 format.

 

I would pick S26 over S25 because it was less messy. Besides I like S26 panel more than S25.

[MusicBuff101]

13 hours ago, Kenneth96 said:

Maddi could have made it to the finale in the S26 format

I honestly doubt it. I think that Top 5 was locked once Playoffs were over. But I agree, the extra week of lives does make a big impact in numerous ways.

[QueenMae16]

7 hours ago, MusicBuff101 said:

I honestly doubt it. I think that Top 5 was locked once Playoffs were over. But I agree, the extra week of lives does make a big impact in numerous ways.

If we count it only as a Top 8, then assuming the coaches first two picks are the choices, Bryan's spot would be open since he was John's last pick.

Although maybe Madison gets that last spot, Maddi was pretty polarizing and her IS performance was something that you would think gets the vote.