Top 5 (Finale) - Rank the performances

[Weirdoo]

No one bothered to create the thread so I took the chance with the polls. Discuss!

 

(I don't know which one is the up-tempo and ballad for some of those).

[Anythingcanhappen]

I love that Shye just isn’t an option for the last question. Valid. 

[Hamza Tufail]

 

10 minutes ago, Weirdoo said:

No one bothered to create the thread so I took the chance with the polls. Discuss!

 

(I don't know which one is the up-tempo and ballad for some of those).

 

this reminded me of a season 13 poll.

 

1. Who gave the best performance? several options were given.

 

2. Is Addison a flop? Only one option was given: YES.

[Weirdoo]

8 minutes ago, Hamza Tufail said:

 

 

this reminded me of a season 13 poll.

 

1. Who gave the best performance? several options were given.

 

2. Is Addison a flop? Only one option was given: YES.

That definitely sounds like like a poll I'd create

[Gustavo527]

Just now, Weirdoo said:

That definitely sounds like like a poll I'd create

You didn't need to add an "Is Sidney a flop" question. The results of the last question speak for themselves.

[allistr]

1 minute ago, Gustavo527 said:

You didn't need to add an "Is Sidney a flop" question. The results of the last question speak for themselves.

Hopefully she doesn't visit IDF and see this

[StarWalker1]

Uptempo:

1. Danny

2. Sofronio

3. Shye

4. Jeremy

5. Sydney

 

Ballad:

1. Shye

2. Danny

3. Jeremy

4. Sofronio

5. Sydney

[Discovolcano]

1 Danny- back to black

2 Jeremy- Dancing on my own 

3 Shye- falling 

4 Sofrino- a million dreams 

 

Edited December 10, 2024 by Discovolcano

[indii]

Uptempo

 

1. Sydney

 

2.Jeremy

3. Shye

4. Sofronio

5. Danny

 

Ballad

1. Sydney

2. Shye

3. Jeremy

 

4. Danny

5. Sofronio

[wgm]

Upbeat: 

1. Dany 

2. Sofronio 

3.Jeremy 

4. Sidney 

5. Shye 

 

Ballad: 

1. Danny

2. Sofronio 

3. Jeremy 

4. Sidney 

5. Shye

 

 

[allistr]

Shye's ballad

 

 

 

 

 

Shye's upbeat

Danny's upbeat

Danny's ballad 

Jeremy's ballad

Sofronio's ballad

Jeremy's upbeat

Sofronio's upbeat

Sydney's upbeat

Sydney's ballad

Edited December 10, 2024 by allistr

[Hsamid]

Damn, was the last question necessary? Lol.

[allistr]

Just now, Hsamid said:

Damn, was the last question necessary? Lol.

Weirdoo's exclusive

[Persy]

Uptempo;

1. Sofronio

2. Shye

3. Jeremy

4. Danny

5. Sydney

 

Ballad:

1. Shye

2. Sofronio

3. Danny

4. Jeremy

5. Sydney

[Gustavo527]

I'm in hater mood.

 

10. Sydney - "Chasing Cars": i can't believe nobody has been able to do this song justice. This was embarrasing. 

9. Sydney - "I Love You, I'm Sorry": i mean, you wouldn't expect much with a Gracie "nepo-baby" Abrams' song but i think this was probably bad even for Gracie's standards, which is a disgrace. 

8. Jeremy - "Dancing On My Own": Why?? Why make that to the arrangement?? I hated it and the vocals were honestly subpar. 

7. Danny - "Ain't No Love In Oklahoma": this wasn't nice to my ears other than the guitar playing, which was the only good part. 

6. Jeremy - "What The World Needs Now": Boring as and forgettable as hell.

5. Danny - "Back To Black": Ok i wasn't a fan at first but the after listening to the last minute i actually kind of enjoyed it?? It was an interesting choice for his voice and it somehow turned out fine. Good job. Not as good as other covers but still worked for me. 

4. Sofronio - "Unstoppable": i think he did what he could with that song, and the result was overall good, not great but pretty good. Kudos to him for singing something that was actually upbeat (or sort of). 

3. Shye - "One of Us": Good job. No Sarah Simmons' level but it was still really good, she did justice to that song. 

2. Sofronio - "A Million Dreams": After watching i'm a little surprised at the poor reception over here. Maybe the expectations were kinda high for him but i really enjoyed this and i thought his vocals were on point. That's his lane, big ballads, he does a great job with them. (though this song is probably more for Jeremy due to the musical thing). 

1. Shye - "Falling": if you manages to make me enjoy a Harry Styles' song, you did an absolute great job. You would think this song is not for a "moment" but it was for her. The vocals, the emotion, everything was perfect. She is brilliant.

[MusicBuff101]

Uptempo:

1. Sofronio (i really liked this, overall)

2. Jeremy (boring song, but he did the best he could with it)

3. Danny (love the song choice, but his voice bothered me more on this song than I expected)

4. Shye (boring as hell and it went nowhere)

5. Sydney (bad)

 

Ballad:

1. Shye (far and away the best of the night and the best performance she’s given in the competition. loved it)

2. Danny (on paper, this shouldn’t have worked, but I honestly quite enjoyed it)

3. Jeremy (his voice sounded tired, but I did connect with the emotional aspect of the performance. it was fine.)

4. Sofronio (i really didn’t like this, i’m sorry. the first half was very pitchy and the 2nd half didn’t move me in the way it needed to)

5. Sydney (bad, again)

 

Overall

1. Shye- ballad

2. Sofronio- uptempo 

3. Danny- ballad

4. Jeremy- uptempo

5. Jeremy- ballad

6. Danny- uptempo

7. Shye- uptempo

8. Sofronio- ballad

9. Sydney- uptempo

10. Sydney- ballad

 

Because I loved Shye’s ballad so much, I’m gonna pretend One of Us didn’t happen tonight 

 

EDIT: thought Back to Black was the ballad for Danny, so that’s the one I’m referring to here

Edited December 10, 2024 by MusicBuff101

[AliXRose]

Uptempo: Shye if I had to pick but honestly none of them

Ballad: Shye

Flop: Sydney but Jeremy was boring as hell I’m sorry