Who Sang It Best - Semifinals Instant Save

[thevoiceisthetop]

Heart Like a Truck: Gilian Smith (s24), Karen Waldrup (s25), Christina Eagle

Pretty Wings: Stee (s24), Adam Bohanan

Gravity: Ryan Innes (S4), Chris Jamison (s7), Courtney Harrell vs Ethan Tucker (s11), Davon Fleming (s13), Mike Parker vs Natasia Greycloud (s15), Oliv Blu (s16), Andrew Marshall (s20), Jamar Langley vs Mariah Kalia (s23), Mac Royals (s24), Jan Dan

House of the Rising Sun: Pip (s2), Amy Whitcomb (s4), Jacquie Lee vs Briana Cuocco (s5), Kimberly Nichole (s8), Hannah Huston (S10), Kylie Rothfield vs Josh Halverson (S11), Ava August (s16), Jack Rogan (s21), Danny Joseph

[rockerannah]

Heart Like A Truck - Karen Waldrup

Pretty Wings - Adam Bohanan

Gravity - Jan Dan (and then Chris Jamison would be second for me)

House of the Rising Sun - Danny Joseph

[AliXRose]

Heart Like a Truck: Gilian Smith (s24), Karen Waldrup (s25), Christina Eagle

Pretty Wings: Stee (s24), Adam Bohanan

Gravity: Ryan Innes (S4), Chris Jamison (s7), Courtney Harrell vs Ethan Tucker (s11), Davon Fleming (s13), Mike Parker vs Natasia Greycloud (s15), Oliv Blu (s16), Andrew Marshall (s20), Jamar Langley vs Mariah Kalia (s23), Mac Royals (s24), Jan Dan

House of the Rising Sun: Pip (s2), Amy Whitcomb (s4), Jacquie Lee vs Briana Cuocco (s5), Kimberly Nichole (s8), Hannah Huston (S10), Kylie Rothfield vs Josh Halverson (S11), Ava August (s16), Jack Rogan (s21), Danny Joseph

[JodiRose]

Heart Like a Truck: Gilian Smith (s24), Karen Waldrup (s25), Christina Eagle (adding in Marybeth Byrd’s American Idol s21 Top 26 performance)

Pretty Wings: Stee (s24), Adam Bohanan

Gravity: Ryan Innes (S4), Chris Jamison (s7), Courtney Harrell vs Ethan Tucker (s11), Davon Fleming (s13), Mike Parker vs Natasia Greycloud (s15), Oliv Blu (s16), Andrew Marshall (s20), Jamar Langley vs Mariah Kalia (s23), Mac Royals (s24), Jan Dan

House of the Rising Sun: Pip (s2), Amy Whitcomb (s4), Jacquie Lee vs Briana Cuocco (s5), Kimberly Nichole (s8), Hannah Huston (S10), Kylie Rothfield vs Josh Halverson (S11), Ava August (s16), Jack Rogan (s21), Danny Joseph (this was my summer karaoke song! )

[nytsch]

Heart Like a Truck: Gilian Smith (s24), Karen Waldrup (s25), Christina Eagle

Pretty Wings: Stee (s24), Adam Bohanan

Gravity: Ryan Innes (S4), Chris Jamison (s7), Courtney Harrell vs Ethan Tucker (s11), Davon Fleming (s13), Mike Parker vs Natasia Greycloud (s15), Oliv Blu (s16), Andrew Marshall (s20), Jamar Langley vs Mariah Kalia (s23), Mac Royals (s24), Jan Dan

House of the Rising Sun: Pip (s2), Amy Whitcomb (s4), Jacquie Lee vs Briana Cuocco (s5), Kimberly Nichole (s8), Hannah Huston (S10), Kylie Rothfield vs Josh Halverson (S11), Ava August (s16), Jack Rogan (s21), Danny Joseph

[dirActing]

Heart Like a Truck: Gilian Smith (s24), Karen Waldrup (s25), Christina Eagle

Pretty Wings: Stee (s24), Adam Bohanan

Gravity: Ryan Innes (S4), Chris Jamison (s7), Courtney Harrell vs Ethan Tucker (s11), Davon Fleming (s13), Mike Parker vs Natasia Greycloud (s15), Oliv Blu (s16), Andrew Marshall (s20), Jamar Langley vs Mariah Kalia (s23), Mac Royals (s24), Jan Dan 

House of the Rising Sun: Pip (s2), Amy Whitcomb (s4), Jacquie Lee vs Briana Cuocco (s5), Kimberly Nichole (s8), Hannah Huston (S10), Kylie Rothfield vs Josh Halverson (S11), Ava August (s16), Jack Rogan (s21), Danny Joseph

[Someone648]

Heart Like a Truck: Gilian Smith (s24), Karen Waldrup (s25), Christina Eagle

Pretty Wings: Stee (s24), Adam Bohanan

Gravity: Ryan Innes (S4), Chris Jamison (s7), Courtney Harrell vs Ethan Tucker (s11), Davon Fleming (s13), Mike Parker vs Natasia Greycloud (s15), Oliv Blu (s16), Andrew Marshall (s20), Jamar Langley vs Mariah Kalia (s23), Mac Royals (s24), Jan Dan

House of the Rising Sun: Pip (s2), Amy Whitcomb (s4), Jacquie Lee vs Briana Cuocco (s5), Kimberly Nichole (s8), Hannah Huston (S10), Kylie Rothfield vs Josh Halverson (S11), Ava August (s16), Jack Rogan (s21), Danny Joseph

 

 

Gravity and THOTRS in the same night: 

[Bouli]

Heart Like a Truck: Gilian Smith (s24), Karen Waldrup (s25), Christina Eagle (loved Christina's too, though <3)

 

Pretty Wings: Stee (s24), Adam Bohanan (Adam sounded so nervous)

 

Gravity: Ryan Innes (S4), Chris Jamison (s7), Courtney Harrell vs Ethan Tucker (s11), Davon Fleming (s13), Mike Parker vs Natasia Greycloud (s15), Oliv Blu (s16), Andrew Marshall (s20), Jamar Langley vs Mariah Kalia (s23), Mac Royals (s24), Jan Dan (This wasn't very close for me, Chris Jamison's audition was brilliant - but I thought Jan Dan did a great job too)

 

House of the Rising Sun: Pip (s2), Amy Whitcomb (s4), Jacquie Lee vs Briana Cuocco (s5), Kimberly Nichole (s8), Hannah Huston (S10), Kylie Rothfield vs Josh Halverson (S11), Ava August (s16), Jack Rogan (s21), Danny Joseph (AND IT ISN'T EVEN CLOSE. I'm not even joking. Kimberly was one of the greatest contestants in the show's entire history IMO, and she put this song to rest, if you ask me.)

[rp3598]

 

Heart Like a Truck: Gilian Smith (s24), Karen Waldrup (s25), Christina Eagle

Pretty Wings: Stee (s24), Adam Bohanan

Gravity: Ryan Innes (S4), Chris Jamison (s7), Courtney Harrell vs Ethan Tucker (s11), Davon Fleming (s13), Mike Parker vs Natasia Greycloud (s15), Oliv Blu (s16), Andrew Marshall (s20), Jamar Langley vs Mariah Kalia (s23), Mac Royals (s24), Jan Dan

House of the Rising Sun: Pip (s2), Amy Whitcomb (s4), Jacquie Lee vs Briana Cuocco (s5), Kimberly Nichole (s8), Hannah Huston (S10), Kylie Rothfield vs Josh Halverson (S11), Ava August (s16), Jack Rogan (s21), Danny Joseph

 

[nytsch]

5 hours ago, Bouli said:

(AND IT ISN'T EVEN CLOSE. I'm not even joking. Kimberly was one of the greatest contestants in the show's entire history IMO, and she put this song to rest, if you ask me.)

 

Hannah was good but if I'm being honest I didn't really understand the preference for her version when Kimberly exists lol

[allistr]

Heart Like a Truck: Gilian Smith (s24), Karen Waldrup (s25), Christina Eagle

Pretty Wings: Stee (s24), Adam Bohanan

Gravity: Ryan Innes (S4), Chris Jamison (s7), Courtney Harrell vs Ethan Tucker (s11), Davon Fleming (s13), Mike Parker vs Natasia Greycloud (s15), Oliv Blu (s16), Andrew Marshall (s20), Jamar Langley vs Mariah Kalia (s23), Mac Royals (s24), Jan Dan

House of the Rising Sun: Pip (s2), Amy Whitcomb (s4), Jacquie Lee vs Briana Cuocco (s5), Kimberly Nichole (s8), Hannah Huston (S10), Kylie Rothfield vs Josh Halverson (S11), Ava August (s16), Jack Rogan (s21), Danny Joseph

 

This battle is really underrated and imo it was up there with the aforementioned versions.

 

 

Edited December 5, 2024 by allistr

[New but Old]

On 12/4/2024 at 9:52 PM, AliXRose said:

House of the Rising Sun: Kimberly Nichole (s8), Hannah Huston (S10)

Really? @AliXRose

[New but Old]

Heart Like a Truck: Gilian Smith (s24), Karen Waldrup (s25), Christina Eagle

Pretty Wings: Stee (s24), Adam Bohanan

Gravity: Ryan Innes (S4), Chris Jamison (s7), Courtney Harrell vs Ethan Tucker (s11), Davon Fleming (s13), Mike Parker vs Natasia Greycloud (s15), Oliv Blu (s16), Andrew Marshall (s20), Jamar Langley vs Mariah Kalia (s23), Mac Royals (s24), Jan Dan

House of the Rising Sun: Pip (s2), Amy Whitcomb (s4), Jacquie Lee vs Briana Cuocco (s5), Kimberly Nichole (s8), Hannah Huston (S10), Kylie Rothfield vs Josh Halverson (S11), Ava August (s16), Jack Rogan (s21), Danny Joseph

[Gustavo527]

16 hours ago, New but Old said:

Really? @AliXRose

Wow, it's like people can have different opinions