Who sang it best: Poll Edition (Nutbush City Limits, love me like a man, My Church)

[Hsamid]

Nutbush City Limits

 

 

 

 

 

 

My church

 

 

 

 

 

24:28 timestamp

 

 

 

 

Love Me like a man

 

 

 

 

[nytsch]

1. Dana is the easy winner here, I'd put Luna second (how they didn't invite her for the comeback is beyond me, did she piss someone off behind the scenes or something?) I love Kimberly but that audition was forgettable imo.

 

2. Cara, I liked her attitude in the song more. Cassidy was great too

 

3. I would've voted for Mandi but I thought the video was blocked for me and it actually wasn't lol, Christina is second, overall a weak group of performances

[Persy]

1. Dana of course but Kimberly is a close second.

2. Cara

3. Christina. 

[Hsamid]

10 hours ago, nytsch said:

1. Dana is the easy winner here, I'd put Luna second (how they didn't invite her for the comeback is beyond me, did she piss someone off behind the scenes or something?) I love Kimberly but that audition was forgettable imo.

 

2. Cara, I liked her attitude in the song more. Cassidy was great too

 

3. I would've voted for Mandi but I thought the video was blocked for me and it actually wasn't lol, Christina is second, overall a weak group of performances

Yeah I agree with mostly everything here.

 

Kimberly's audition is probably in her bottom 3 performances, it honestly shows little indication of what was to come lol.

 

Mandi's 30 seconds were exceptional but it doesn't feel right to vote for a montage (the rest could of been eh), so went with Christina.

[Hamza Tufail]

Dana

Cara

Mandi

[StarWalker1]

1. Kimberly - her energy and voice sounded more effortless to me wheras Dana was close but she def pushed some of those notes more. Also her PO >>>

2. Cara, though Cassidy was great as well

3. Mandi

[QueenCami]

Christina voters did not watch s18 that's for sure

[AliXRose]

Kimberly

Cara

Mandi

[TeamAudra]

Why always a public poll? I went ahead and voted this time, but I usually skip it when I see that. 

[QueenKalie]

I just randomly chose someone some people for the first two categories because yolo I didn't care either way. For the last one it was either going to be Christina or Mary Sarah because the other performances are not it. And I preferred Christina to Mary Sarah's. 

[Misirlou]

Kimberly

 

Cassidy

 

Sundance 

[QueenKalie]

People complain about Minivan having bad taste but 8 people voted for a montaged peformance of My Church as the best performance. One being a montage performance kinda disqualies it. But also it was montaged for a reason because it was terrible.

[StarWalker1]

7 minutes ago, QueenKalie said:

People complain about Minivan having bad taste but 8 people voted for a montaged peformance of My Church as the best performance. One being a montage performance kinda disqualies it. But also it was montaged for a reason because it was terrible.

I mean theres not many options of good performances with that song 

[nytsch]

I mean I guess it’s speculation but I thought it was the case that Mandi was montaged moreso to protect Anaya because her performance was supposedly not good?

[QueenKalie]

19 minutes ago, nytsch said:

I mean I guess it’s speculation but I thought it was the case that Mandi was montaged moreso to protect Anaya because her performance was supposedly not good?

Maybe they both sucked I don't know?

[Hamza Tufail]

On 11/18/2024 at 3:14 AM, TeamAudra said:

Why always a public poll? I went ahead and voted this time, but I usually skip it when I see that. 

I hate it when the polls are public. It seems that this has become a trend. Most polls these days are public.