Where Would You Rank Asher Havon Among Past Winners? (And male winners)

[Hsamid]

Winner list in order.

 

Javier Colon

Jermaine Paul

Cassadee Pope

Danielle Bradbery

Tessanne Chin

Josh Kaufman

Craig Wayne Boyd

Sawyer Frederick

Jordan Smith

Alisan Porter

Sundance Head

Chris Blue

Chloe Kohanski

Brynn Cartelli

Maelyn Jarmon

Jake Hoot

Todd Tilghman

Carter Rubin

Cam Anthony

GNT

Bryce Leatherwood

Gina Miles

Huntley

Asher Havon

Edited May 22 by Hsamid

[QueenKalie]

Hmm I dunno maybe in the 18 to 19 range and 10th or 11th? 

[Hsamid]

9 minutes ago, QueenKalie said:

Hmm I dunno maybe in the 18 to 19 range and 10th or 11th? 

Well, at least it's not last ig.

 

Wait lemme guess for fun. 

 

the ones below Asher are Chris, Jermaine, Huntley, Carter and... Gina? Since apparently you have 1 female winner in your bottom 5. The shock of it all.

[QueenKalie]

23 minutes ago, Hsamid said:

Well, at least it's not last ig.

 

Wait lemme guess for fun. 

 

the ones below Asher are Chris, Jermaine, Huntley, Carter and... Gina? Since apparently you have 1 female winner in your bottom 5. The shock of it all.

I wouldn't put a female in the bottom 5 but it's possible that I can't add or do math at 6 in the morning since I'm almost never up this early lol. So that probably caused some confusion lol. Carter is definitely last Jermaine would have be to in the bottom 3. Bryce would also be in the bottom 3. Then maybe Craig or Sundance and or Asher in that group of 3.

Edited May 22 by QueenKalie

[Hsamid]

59 minutes ago, QueenKalie said:

I wouldn't put a female in the bottom 5 but it's possible that I can't add or do math at 6 in the morning since I'm almost never up this early lol. So that probably caused some confusion lol. Carter is definitely last Jermaine would have be to in the bottom 3. Bryce would also be in the bottom 3. Then maybe Craig or Sundance and or Asher in that group of 3.

2 out of 4.. not bad.

 

Didn't realize you dislike Carter THAT much though lol.

 

Surprised Chris isn't in your bottom 3 either and that you dislike Sundance and Craig more. 2 of the most respected male country singers on here no less lol.

 

[QueenKalie]

13 minutes ago, Hsamid said:

2 out of 4.. not bad.

 

Didn't realize you dislike Carter THAT much though lol.

 

Surprised Chris isn't in your bottom 3 either and that you dislike Sundance and Craig more. 2 of the most respected male country singers on here no less lol.

 

I think most of the male country singer winners are pretty interchangeable except Bryce he is by far the worst lol. Chris isn't bottom 3 he's just apart of the biggest robbery ever. 

[Hamza Tufail]

Hmm...

 

He's probably between 14-16.

 

I need to rewatch his performances though. They may grow on me because I've only listened to his performances 1 time.

 

#10 among males.

Edited May 22 by Hamza Tufail

[Anybody354]

When I see people ranking Asher between 11-19 I feel like that’s low but then I remember the show has been on for 25 seasons.

 

I haven’t watched all of the seasons in full so I can’t judge too much, but while I slightly prefer Huntley, I am more than ecstatic to have seen Asher win.

[Kenneth96]

Bottom 5 for me. I know he's a talented singer, just my personal preference, he's not my cup of tea. I only rank him higher than Javier, Jermaine, Bryce and Craig/Todd.

[allistr]

I ranked him among 14-16 most likely because there were much better winners in the past, I missed the golden era of The Voice. I don't think any of his performances has a memorable factor like other does. Not to take away from his talent of hitting low notes or sth, he's also incredible. Still a deserving winner though!

 

Place him 8th among the male winners.

Edited May 22 by allistr

[Persy]

Asher would definitely be the top 2 best winner of all time for me honestly. He and Maelyn are my top 2 favorite winners and now he's the best male vocalist I have ever heard in my life on The Voice. 

[AliXRose]

7th winner

2nd male winner

[Hsamid]

Winners I have ahead of him.

 

Javier Colon

Jermaine Paul

Cassadee Pope

Danielle Bradbery

Tessanne Chin

Josh Kaufman

Craig Wayne Boyd

Sawyer Frederick

Jordan Smith

Alisan Porter

Sundance Head

Chris Blue

Chloe Kohanski

Brynn Cartelli

Chevel Shepard

Maelyn Jarmon

Jake Hoot

Todd Tilghman

Carter Rubin

Cam Anthony

GNT

Bryce Leatherwood

Gina Miles

Huntley

 

So he's just outside my top 10. 

Though a few I'm not so sure on like Huntley and Cam.

 

I think if his song selection during lives were better, he would definitely be higher. All his "moments" happened prelives, and the one time they tried to replicate that live was with a freaking Whitney Houston song, which is a tall task for anyone, even more so for a male singer.

Edited May 24 by Hsamid

[QueenCami]

asher is above:

Javier Colon

Jermaine Paul

Carter Rubin

Gina Miles

Cam Anthony

 

asher is on par with:

Josh Kaufman (sorry, i don’t like the texture of his voice)

Bryce Leatherwood

 

asher is below:

Cassadee Pope

Danielle Bradbery

Tessanne Chin

Craig Wayne Boyd

Sawyer Frederick

Jordan Smith

Alisan Porter

Sundance Head

Chris Blue

Chloe Kohanski

Brynn Cartelli

Maelyn Jarmon

Jake Hoot

Todd Tilghman

GNT

Huntley

[QueenCami]

season 16 and before had much stronger winners than season 17 onward imo

[Hsamid]

5 minutes ago, QueenCami said:

 

asher is above:

Javier Colon

Jermaine Paul

Carter Rubin

Gina Miles

Cam Anthony

 

asher is on par with:

Josh Kaufman (sorry, i don’t like the texture of his voice)

Bryce Leatherwood

 

asher is below:

Cassadee Pope

Danielle Bradbery

Tessanne Chin

Craig Wayne Boyd

Sawyer Frederick

Jordan Smith

Alisan Porter

Sundance Head

Chris Blue

Chloe Kohanski

Brynn Cartelli

Maelyn Jarmon

Jake Hoot

Todd Tilghman

GNT

Huntley

LOL so much for liking RnB/soul male contestants when all the winners that fit that mold are in your bottom 10 except Chris

Edited May 24 by Hsamid

[QueenCami]

1 minute ago, Hsamid said:

LOL so much for liking RnB/soul male contestants when all the winners that fit that mold are in your bottom 10 except Chris

don’t like Javiers tone, idk enough about Jermaine i think he’s more pop rock (?), Cams tone bothers me, Asher’s habit of cutting off his vocals bothers me

 

tbe ones i like don’t make it far. season 15 had tons of excellent ones for example (Tyshawn, Franc, Patrique, i didn’t like DeAndres tone but he could turn out a strong performance…)

[QueenCami]

3 minutes ago, Hsamid said:

LOL so much for liking RnB/soul male contestants when all the winners that fit that mold are in your bottom 10 except Chris

speaking of which Chris is so exceptional and deserves his flowers, he’s easily a stronger vocalist than everyone else i mentioned except for maybe Asher 

[Hsamid]

4 minutes ago, QueenCami said:

don’t like Javiers tone, idk enough about Jermaine i think he’s more pop rock (?), Cams tone bothers me, Asher’s habit of cutting off his vocals bothers me

 

tbe ones i like don’t make it far. season 15 had tons of excellent ones for example (Tyshawn, Franc, Patrique, i didn’t like DeAndres tone but he could turn out a strong performance…)

There's quite a bit of soul/gospel in Jermaine's vocals even when he wasn't singing in that genre imo.

 

But fair enough.

 

I just found it funny that's the list of someone that's  arguably the biggest supporter of RnB/male contestants on here 

Edited May 24 by Hsamid

[nytsch]

Javier Colon

Jermaine Paul

Cassadee Pope

Danielle Bradbery

Tessanne Chin

Josh Kaufman

Craig Wayne Boyd

Sawyer Fredericks

Jordan Smith

Alisan Porter

Sundance Head

Chris Blue

Chloe Kohanski

Brynn Cartelli

Chevel Shepard

Maelyn Jarmon

Jake Hoot

Todd Tilghman

Carter Rubin

Cam Anthony

GNT

Bryce Leatherwood

Gina Miles

Huntley

 

Bolded are above, so I guess 13 ish?

It’s hard to impress me as much with these shorter formats, although I guess Cam did it

[QueenKalie]

Cami only flopped on Gina otherwise I don't really have any complaints.

[QueenKalie]

Now the person who just posted their list flopped a lot more than Cami did.

Edited May 24 by QueenKalie

[Hsamid]

5 minutes ago, QueenKalie said:

Cami only flopped on Gina otherwise I don't really have any complaints.

 

4 minutes ago, QueenKalie said:

Now the person who just posted flopped a lot more than Cami did.

So, you? 

[QueenKalie]

Just now, Hsamid said:

 

So, you? 

No I'm incapable of flopping.

[QueenCami]

11 minutes ago, QueenKalie said:

Cami only flopped on Gina otherwise I don't really have any complaints.

omg maybe we r in our era of agreement …