Jump to content

The Voice 25 ● Live Finale Part 1 ● Discussion


istersay

Recommended Posts

9 minutes ago, thecarterfilez said:

how y'all gonna feel after all that and it's still a Josh/Karen top 2 ? 

 

Where were those voters then for Grace West? For Ruby Leigh?

 

They didn't pimp Asher for nothing if they didn't think he had a chance of winning. The one-vote-rule has changed the dynamics of the show. Move on and let's entertain the idea of a different kind of artist winning. If Gina Miles and Huntley can do it, so can Asher.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 minutes ago, Gustavo527 said:

Idk, this doesn't feel like another Bryce's situation at all. I'm confident that on of Asher or Nathan it's definitely winning.

I would be very, very shocked if either of Josh/Karen weren't in the final 2. I do think it's Asher but the chances that America votes 2 R&B-adjecent men into the top 2 are very very low IMO. The country voters are gonna bring someone to at least the Final 2 & it'll likely be Josh. I think there's been like 1 season in the last 10 where a country artist hasn't made the Final 2

 

I honestly don't mean to keep harping on why I don't think Nathan's going to place high because I honestly really like him & I sound like a hater :dead: 

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 minutes ago, QueenKalie said:

Although the bookies favorite didn't win AI fwiw. 

that figures, oh well I had fun hoping for a minute :rofl:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just now, QueenKalie said:

Josh could still be in the top 2 though. 

Singing second and sixth out of twelve performances (counting two guest appearances) is a big disadvantage. The comments surrounding Asher's closing performance by Reba and Chance don't help Josh, either.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 minutes ago, RTV said:

Singing second and sixth out of twelve performances (counting two guest appearances) is a big disadvantage. The comments surrounding Asher's closing performance by Reba and Chance don't help Josh, either.

I would agree with this. Let's assume Asher wins who's getting second? Another R&B artist? I would assume in a one vote scenerio the majority of those votes would go to Asher. So I have a hard time seeing Nathan getting second. Karen had the most clear path to a win but she totally threw that out the window on her second performance so I don't see the country fans voting for her over Josh. Bryan sure as hell ain't getting second he's definitely fifth. So I think the most likely scenerio is a Reba getting both the top 2 spots because someone has to get second and people still love a male country singer. 

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 minutes ago, indii said:

I would be very, very shocked if either of Josh/Karen weren't in the final 2. I do think it's Asher but the chances that America votes 2 R&B-adjecent men into the top 2 are very very low IMO. The country voters are gonna bring someone to at least the Final 2 & it'll likely be Josh. I think there's been like 1 season in the last 10 where a country artist hasn't made the Final 2

 

I honestly don't mean to keep harping on why I don't think Nathan's going to place high because I honestly really like him & I sound like a hater :dead: 

I do think Josh will be in the Top 2 (Karen will not, you need to let that one go lol) but i don't see him as a winner. And ok, you are probably right about Nathan.

 

My final prediction: 

1. Asher 

2. Josh 

3. Nathan 

4. Karen 

5. Brtan

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I would prefer if ne8ther Nathan nor Asher win not because they don't deserve it but I don't need either of them to be stuck with that lucky recording contract that nobody can get out of .Let Josh win it .

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Haven't seen the performances because they haven't posted it but I'm nervous seeing that Josh got Go Rest High On That Mountain/cautiously optimistic at you guys predicting Asher to win...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think Karen is definitely 4th, Bryan is 5th.

Josh is getting 2nd place

1st is either Nathan/Asher. I think the producer really wants Asher to win and Chance’s comments will heavily affect America’s votes but I personally want Nathan to win 😭 His voice in A Song For You is so freaking daunting I can’t get it out of my head 😭. Asher was good but not as memorable in the finale song choices and I don’t blame them because many great singers have taken that Whitney.

 

I want Nathan to win please

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, itsamansw said:

I think Karen is definitely 4th, Bryan is 5th.

Josh is getting 2nd place

1st is either Nathan/Asher. I think the producer really wants Asher to win and Chance’s comments will heavily affect America’s votes but I personally want Nathan to win 😭 His voice in A Song For You is so freaking daunting I can’t get it out of my head 😭. Asher was good but not as memorable in the finale song choices and I don’t blame them because many great singers have taken that Whitney.

 

I want Nathan to win please

 

gollum2.gif.59fe71e5b0722440b32d2ff0f691

  • Haha 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

again all of this was written without reading the thread so apologies in advance for any hot takes lol

 

Nathan upbeat - cool song choice, I really like the "growly" part of his voice. thought he was killing it especially in the last 3rd of the performance

Josh ballad - it was fine? idk, Megan Danielle outsold, that's all I got

Asher upbeat - I was worried about this tbh but I really enjoyed his voice on this and he got some great vocal moments in there too

Bryan ballad - surprisingly this was pretty good... or at least I thought so before he sang the last chorus lmao

Karen ballad - I thought she could've nailed this but she just kinda... didn't? it wasn't bad, just underwhelming

Josh upbeat - I was bored

Nathan ballad - he's better on upbeat, maybe because the performance itself is such a big aspect, this was good but a little unmemorable imo

Bryan upbeat - cringe

Karen upbeat - not much to say about this? it was alright lol

Asher ballad - his low notes are so good and the little runs he puts in there, I'm sold

 

1. Nathan upbeat

2. Asher upbeat

3. Asher ballad

4. Nathan ballad

5. Josh ballad

6. Karen upbeat

7. Bryan ballad

8. Josh upbeat

9. Karen ballad

10. Bryan upbeat

 

Was kinda underwhelmed by everything other than the top 3... Nathan and Asher were the clear best tonight imo

  • Like 5
Link to comment
Share on other sites

28 minutes ago, nytsch said:

again all of this was written without reading the thread so apologies in advance for any hot takes lol

 

Nathan upbeat - cool song choice, I really like the "growly" part of his voice. thought he was killing it especially in the last 3rd of the performance

Josh ballad - it was fine? idk, Megan Danielle outsold, that's all I got

Asher upbeat - I was worried about this tbh but I really enjoyed his voice on this and he got some great vocal moments in there too

Bryan ballad - surprisingly this was pretty good... or at least I thought so before he sang the last chorus lmao

Karen ballad - I thought she could've nailed this but she just kinda... didn't? it wasn't bad, just underwhelming

Josh upbeat - I was bored

Nathan ballad - he's better on upbeat, maybe because the performance itself is such a big aspect, this was good but a little unmemorable imo

Bryan upbeat - cringe

Karen upbeat - not much to say about this? it was alright lol

Asher ballad - his low notes are so good and the little runs he puts in there, I'm sold

 

1. Nathan upbeat

2. Asher upbeat

3. Asher ballad

4. Nathan ballad

5. Josh ballad

6. Karen upbeat

7. Bryan ballad

8. Josh upbeat

9. Karen ballad

10. Bryan upbeat

 

Was kinda underwhelmed by everything other than the top 3... Nathan and Asher were the clear best tonight imo

Disagree on some bits but all fair, reasonable takes.

 

I was underwhelmed by everything but Asher and Nathan's uptempo.

 

I don't think a song for you was the best fit for Nathan tbh. He's not really a runner, and maybe I would have like him to sustain some of the notes longer.

 

 

 

  • Like 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...