American Idol S22 Rock & Roll Hall of Fame - Top 14 Discussion

[QueenKalie]

Jordan probably misses Australia. 

[*Wallace]

Nice performance from Kayko.

[jdanton2]

Idol must want Jordan gone .

[Solaris]

Another overdone song

[BlindMelon]

Not digging all of these overdone Whitney songs. I was hoping to see some out of the box type performances tonight. I love Whitney don't get me wrong, but so far we have THREE?! There was sooo much to choose from to have a more memorable, stand out, type performance. Meh.

Edited April 22, 2024 by BlindMelon

[Shireen]

Apparently Whitney Houston is the most imortant Rock artist who knew?

[keychange]

ugh not I Cant Make You Love Me... Jayna and Emmy battling it out in the overdone song olympics. 

[jjeem]

That is actually very true what Gene Simmons said about nerves.

[jdanton2]

Meghan Trainor had a Billboard #1 .

[*Wallace]

When it was said Emmy was singing a Bonnie Raitt ballad, I knew it was "I Can't Make You Love Me."  

[Someone648]

Am I reading 3 Whitney songs on R&RHoF night?

Such an expansive list and we got 3 Whitney songs

[BlindMelon]

Least it's a rock song.

[StarWalker1]

emmy sounds good so far

[Discovolcano]

How is this rock

[Solaris]

I thought she would do better with this song then she did. This is her weakest performance of the voting rounds for me.

[v-streamer]

I think I liked Emmy the least

[Elliott]

2 minutes ago, jdanton2 said:

Meghan Trainor had a Billboard #1 .

[TeamAudra]

Gene Simmons might be the best mentor ever, because every one of these contestants has shown some improvement tonight. 
 

Although, I think this song is too big for Emmy. 

[keychange]

one of her better performances imo but there were a few iffy moments.

 

tbh i'd actually love to see her cover "Without Me" by Halsey for #1 night tomorrow. I think she could pull of a cool country flip on it. 

[QueenKalie]

Emmy looks so pretty.  

[sublymonal]

Thought that would be the perfect song for Emmy but that was probably her weakest vocal thus far.

[hazuki]

Not another overdone song.. Emmy.. 

 

[Shireen]

Congratulations this is easily the 387th best version of the song.

[jdanton2]

Emmy started good but it started sounding a bit off towards  the end.

[StarWalker1]

it got a little too big for her in the second half