American Idol Season 21 Hawaii Showcase Part 1 - Favorite Performances Poll

[StarWalker1]

Who did you enjoy the most? 

Edited April 17, 2023 by StarWalker1

[m1key]

Will need to do some re-watching and my opinions will most likely change. My immediate reaction is Kaeyra, Emma, and Nailyah. 

[QueenCami]

Elise, Emma, Nailyah

[chrisaba]

Emma, Nailyah and Elise

[QueenKalie]

Elise, Kaerya, Emma. 

[Shireen]

Kaeyra Emma Iam

[Mathacoo200315]

Elise Matt Lucy Iam Kaeyra Emma

[hazuki]

Kaeyra, Matt, Emma

[Carrie_On]

Iam, Lucy, Kaeyra, Zachariah, Emma

[StarWalker1]

For me it's Nailyah, Emma, Elise, Lucy, Kaeyra, and Iam

[nytsch]

1. Nailyah

2. Emma

 

As a TV fan, I am not convinced yet, but I loved these 2 

 

Also liked Lucy, Warren, Matt, and Elise (though I hoped for better from her)

[Persy]

I enjoyed tonight's episode quite a lot. The only performances I didn't enjoy was PJAE and Haven. I know Haven will get voted through since she's the teen girl that goes far. I want to hear more from her and see her redeem herself. Same with PJAE, he needs to redeem himself but he's fodder. I loved Iam, Nailyah, Elise, Emma, Kaeyra, Mariah, Matt, Lucy, Oliver, Warren, and Zachariah tonight. 

[allistr]

Elise, Matt, Kaeyra, Nailyah, Lucy.

Edited April 17, 2023 by allistr

[taylorkat]

Nailyah.

[FloorWax]

1. Nailyah

2. Matt

 

The end.

[erik g]

I voted for Matt but rewatching the performances i think my favorite was Nailyah

[jdanton2]

Nailyah and Matt.

[Hsamid]

Emma for sure.

 

Great vocals but also the most emotionally connected this episode imo. She has some of the best control and placement in terms of when to do runs, headvoice, etc. It rarely feels like too much with her.

 

Nailyah, Zachariah 

Iam and elise and Warren would round up my top 6 in that order. Didn't care much for the rest tbh.

Edited April 17, 2023 by Hsamid

[*Wallace]

I would probably rank the performances as the following:

 

1.    Kaerya - Don't Let Go (Love)
2.    Nailyah Serenity - Lovin' You
3.    Lucy Love - What's Love Got to Do With It
4.    Emma Busse - Lay Me Down
5.    Matt Wilson - Speechless
6.    Zachariah Smith - Lucielle
7.    Iam Tongi - Don't Let Go
8.    Elise Kristine - Holding Out for a Hero
9.    Mariah Faith - You Should Probably Leave
10.    Oliver Steele - Better Together
11.    Haven Madison - The Middle
12.    Warren Peay - Set Fire to the Rain
13.    PJAE - Golden
 

[CarmenSandiego]

I'll rank them later, but after re-watching the performances, my favorite is Nailyah.