Which show had the best 3rd place? Idol or The Voice?

[Daillon]

Very clearly a rip-off of Gustavo’s poll but I’m very curious about this one.

[Gustavo527]

They were both snowflakes on this forum. I personally would pick Morgan, but i remember Leah being really good. 

[FloorWax]

I felt more passionately about Leah 

[Misirlou]

Morgan is more my style so I went with her. Leah was very good though.

[Teraginn]

1 hour ago, Daillon said:

Very clearly a rip-off of Gustavo’s poll but I’m very curious about this one.

 

Disgusted that no one made the 2nd place equivalent of this poll, I was scrolling down for much longer than I care to admit.

Anyway, Morgan >>>>>>> Leah. I like that Idol is much more welcoming of artists like Leah, but come on. It's no competition. 

[QueenKalie]

2 minutes ago, Teraginn said:

 

Disgusted that no one made the 2nd place equivalent of this poll, I was scrolling down for much longer than I care to admit.
 

[erik g]

I picked Morgan but I loved Leah too

[QueenKalie]

Leah had some good performances but Morgan hands down.

[Discovolcano2]

Leah. She has the whole package 

[Daillon]

I have to go with Leah  She checks all the boxes (vocals, artistry, versatilty, fun song choices…) Also worth noting that Heal was far and away my favorite performance (from both AI and TV) of 2022.

 

Morgan is also great though, and obviously the better vocalist.

 

35 minutes ago, Teraginn said:

 

Disgusted that no one made the 2nd place equivalent of this poll, I was scrolling down for much longer than I care to admit.

Sorry  But let’s be honest, we all know who would have won that one.

[Hsamid]

Leah Marlene. 

 

I don't think Morgan is the clear cut better vocalist tbh.. from what I remember Marlene was almost on pitch throughout her entire run. Her range and vocal agility is deceivingly good.

 

Morgan definitely has the edge in terms of raspy, gritty belts though.

 

 

[allistr]

I am picking Morgan, but Leah was good too, her "Heal" was 

[FunkyFrankie]

Morgan. Never liked Leah

[Hamza Tufail]

Don't do this to me. 

[Hamza Tufail]

Voted for Leah, because she had less votes; otherwise, I might've voted Morgan (Still very very close).

 

For me Both are Queens. Both had Amazing runs.

 

[Tmp 12]

Both are really good but Leah just connects well to every song she sings.She makes you feel what she's singing. 

 

Love morgan but felt like she "just sang" in some performances imo

[iloveadam]

I still remember Leah's Heal and Seperate Way.  Nothing from Morgan leave me any impressions , she's a good vocalist but very dull, maybe the song choices.

[ikwonic]

2 hours ago, iloveadam said:

I still remember Leah's Heal and Seperate Way.  Nothing from Morgan leave me any impressions , she's a good vocalist but very dull, maybe the song choices.

Seconding this

[Gustavo527]

18 hours ago, Gustavo527 said:

They were both snowflakes on this forum. I personally would pick Morgan, but i remember Leah being really good. 

Ok, i was trying to be nice here, but   

 

Morgan>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Leah. 

 

 

Edited December 16, 2022 by Gustavo527

[Someone648]

Morgan has the experience and vocal ability over Leah for sure but as an artist I'd pick Leah every day of the week.

[QueenCami]

Morgan.

 

Leah was great, but I recall one of her performances coming off a bit shouty. I also was not as much a fan of "Heal" as everyone else seemed to be.

17 hours ago, Daillon said:

I have to go with Leah  She checks all the boxes (vocals, artistry, versatilty, fun song choices…) Also worth noting that Heal was far and away my favorite performance (from both AI and TV) of 2022.

 

Morgan is also great though, and obviously the better vocalist.

 

Sorry  But let’s be honest, we all know who would have won that one.

I might have voted for Huntergirl

[christine58]

Leah Marlene